*Season 2, Week 29* Analysis Thread

Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#1

Welcome to the weekly analysis thread, where we dissect the heck out of the characters, situations, and the possibilities for the leap! This thread is dedicated to in-depth character and story analysis in this new phase of the show. Let's explore how the show, in its complexity makes us think. We leave the thread open-ended so that we can discuss varied topics with each other in a more informal way, and new thread begins every Sunday evening for ongoing discussions as the week unfolds. If you are interested in this exercise, jump right in!

_____________

Everyone is invited to join as long as they avoid:

1. Moral policing. This thread should be an inclusive and safe space for people to express their views. This is a work of fiction and multiple interpretations only make it a richer experience. If something about the show makes you uncomfortable, be open to the idea that you might be missing the necessary perspective that someone else could provide.

2. Bashing CVs. Criticism is welcome, but should be focused and constructive.

3. Bashing the characters, or pitting them against one another. If you think either the Dixits or the Boses are entirely right, and the other entirely to blame, this is not the thread for you.

And most importantly...

4. BASHING OR PERSONAL INSULTS OF OTHER MEMBERS

This means we accept other people's viewpoints with respect, and don't call them names for not agreeing with us. Either we continue the argument calmly, supported by examples from the show, or we respectfully agree to disagree and leave that discussion alone.

Additionally, if you notice something being discussed on another thread in the forum that you would like to get a perspective on here, please link it in your post and let the other Thread Maker know. This allows for them to come and discuss here if they like and makes us all good neighbours.

___________

Links to Previous Threads

Week 1 Week 6 Week 11 Week 16 Week 21 Week 26

Week 2 Week 7 Week 12 Week 17 Week 22 Week 27

Week 3 Week 8 Week 13 Week 18 Week 23 Week 28

Week 4 Week 9 Week 14 Week 19 Week 24

Week 5 Week 10 Week 15 Week 20 Week 25

Created

Last reply

Replies

216

Views

18.5k

Users

32

Likes

2k

Frequent Posters

sona_naksh thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
congrats on d new thread ..
loved d discussions in d last one ..n m pretty excited to know how devakshi sort dis issue out
cscs thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
Congratulations for the new thread.
kshah1987 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
when do TOI spoilers usually come out?
GKaPyar thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#5

Thanks and congrats on this new thread.

Just can't hold my anticipation for exciting peak of the "New Pyar Ke Rang" track. Keeping faith in makers to give us justified outcome of this extraordinarily beautiful and unique track. Eager to see some Power Packed performances!!!!

Hurrray... This makes my 50th post on IF. Sincere thanks to all my IF friends for your encouragement to this Newbie!!!!

Thanks again for this wonderful thread which inspires me to write (Good or Bad) every day.

Sincerely,

Ji 😃 😃 😃


EDIT: Just realized, this 50th post made me a Groupbie. Confused on what that means but assume it has to be something better than before. 😆

Edited by GKaPyar - 8 years ago
sjain thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
Congratulations guys..Its fresh start new week and new thrill new episodes

Just going back to past week activities It was one highly hyper controversial hustle bustle kinda week..Dev's unseen side came out in full swing and Sonakshi's incompetency to handle her husband..Noth's flaws were quite interestingly highlighted..where if in one episode Dev looked wrong in another Sonakshi was faulty..This see saw of emotions feelings was way too intriguing and will push you to get deeply involved with it..Highlight of this week was major revelation of Vicky lieing and being the major culprit in Dev Sonakshi's separation..It completely changed the equation between Dev Sonakshi..With getting even more paranoid and impulsive regarding protecting Soankshi where as Sonakshi felt suffocated and little helpless..She is so unable to judge his behavior cant really figure out how to make this situation better and in between Soha is too facing the consequences of it

I am hoping and looking forward for a balanced and very entertaining week ahead..How this story will progress and how far Dev's restrictions will go where as how long Sonakshi can sustain through this..will they find some middle ground or not..Will she leave Dixit house to be with Boses again..Will Boses come to know the tough situation between Dev Sonkashi ..I am way too curious to know what wil happen..

Looking forward for wonderful deep reviews here..Guys you all are doing wonderful job..Just keep them coming..I could see so many comments replies valuable feedbacks..superb..keep it up..Enjoy have fun

PS I saw some one mentioning Dev needs to consult doctor..I dont think his problem required any medical attention..Its not something which has reached to a level from where he can not come back..Inspite of this fact that his issues are deep rooted he has always been able to balance his emotions..But this burst out happened post that accident night..which kinda pricked the bubble of feelings and this came out out with such fierce intensity..All he need a bit of assurance and safe handling majorly from Sonakshi and rest from his family..I also feel Asha can be a great help in this case..I feel he can may be talk to Asha or Asha can give some advice to Sonakshi which can better the circumstances..Fingers crossed

Also Soankshi working from home or not..well She never pointed out her financial independence in the last conversation of friday's episode I mentioned in my previous reply too..She wants to grow and flourish..and definitely everything can not be handled while working from home..Its not about ego as well she didnt say Dev wants her to quit..But by being restricted she can not do things which she probably dreamt of for her work..her baby app..Even with the help of family she did manage to grow Soha in lovely way and she can do it now as well..Even if Soha was left to her family probably most of the times in 7 years but she was never their responsibility she was always Sonakshi's

@Shaavi I loved that Mahabharat and Ramayan thing..lovely mann WOW

No offense My POV
thedramaqueen thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#7
Mahua, sonakshi did not. By bringing ishwari into it, the conversation went in that direction. And ended up in "Its not my money. It's yours"
Shaavi thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8
Thanks Mahua. Ramayana and Mahabharata play a very huge role in most people's lives in India(maybe outside too. I am generalizing based on it's popularity with media. There has been more than one version and series based on these 2 epics.) We hear about these two epics most of the times in one way or another.

In Ramayana, absolute morality was given the highest importance, while in Mahabharata relative morality was considered paramount. As Lakshmi mentioned, Arjun is a representative of humanity whereas Krishna stands for divinity. If Rama strove to keep his public image impeccable, Arjuna fought against his own relatives, killed his own paternal grandfather for keeping his image in front those people whom he called his family,irrespective of what others thought. Rama upheld the absolute morality, Arujna defended relative morality.

Sam, coming to Bhishma, his name means He of the terrible oath. By keeping his oath, he preserved the absolute morality(dharma), but failed to do his duty towards relative morality(karma). He left the ruling of the kingdom to his two incompetent step brothers whose children ended up fighting and killing each other for the throne of the same kingdom. In the end he once again fought with the amoral(Duryodhana) to fulfill his oath of serving the throne which is once again dharma instead of fighting on the side of dharma, there by failing in doing his karma.

Ajrjuna on the other hand followed relative morality(karma) and did not endorse absolute morality(dharma). Dharma says you should not harm your own family and fight each other for land, gold, woman and other materialistic things. But karma is exactly what Arjuna defended by lifting his bow in the war. He also ended up killing his own brother(Karna) in the end similar to Bheema who killed Duryodhana. Krishna endorsed the following of "karma" and said leave the fruits(paap aur punya) of this acts to me.

In KRPKAB, Sona is behaving like Bhishma and keeping the absolute morality(dharma), while Dev like Arjuna is following the path of relative morality(karma). According to Gita, it says do your duty to keep the dharma and not the other way around. Gita endorses karma as the way of life. These are some of the quotes from Gita which talk about the importance of karma --

  1. "It is better to live your own destiny imperfectly than to live an imitation of somebody else's life with perfection.
  2. "You have the right to work, but never to the fruit of work. You should never engage in action for the sake of reward, nor should you long for inaction. Perform work in this world, Arjuna, as a man established within himself - without selfish attachments, and alike in success and defeat.
  3. The meaning of Karma is in the intention. The intention behind action is what matters. Those who are motivated only by desire for the fruits of action are miserable, for they are constantly anxious about the results of what they do.

Sonakshi prefers the image of perfection for the world irrespective of being perfect for your family. But Dev goes for perfection for his family and doesn't care about being perfect for the world.

I am really liking the way these 2 characters are written and how contrasting they are shown and how they are so much influenced by mythology. Yet we don't really see it as mythology as these themes are embedded rather than just said in plain words. I mean when we see Ramayana or Mahabharata we are not able to directly relate the characters to people we know. But through this series, we can see how much influence they really have in our lives. And that to me is amazing.
Edited by Shaavi - 8 years ago
aarcha thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#9

Good to c that great discussions r goin on in our thread. Sometimes I wonder, y r v even discussing this ?? But these discussions r the colours of our luv towards this show..kuch rang pyar ke aise bhi...

Dev Dixit again started looking for short cuts to solve his problems. Wen he badly wanted a nutritionist for his mom, he closed all gates for Sonakshi n forced her to take the job for him. His intention was good but he chose a wrong path to fulfil it. He didn cared for Sonakshi's emotions but his only priority was his mother's health . Sonakshi @ first was reluctant to take up the job seeing the rude nature of Mr Dixit but later gav in realising that she's doing injustice to her proffession as well as to a patient who needs her assistance very badly. Saurav too made Sona understand the typical behaviour of Mr. Dixit bcoz of his immense luv towards his mom , jst like the way they had it for their mom .It's all past now . But now Dev wants Sona to do all her work from home bcoz of her safety as well as for the well being of Soha . But wat if something happens @ home ?

After the truth of eviction , Vicky turned as the sole culprit where he had kept Dev as the one who made eviction notice for the Boses . I expected Sona having some heart to heart , meaningful talk with Dev. All these yrs, everyone in Bose house including Sona blamed Dev , @ least he needs such a comfort from Sona . Some nice words . But Cvs r nt yet ready for a Dev Sona whole hearted talk in it's true senses unlike with photographs, empty rooms or in inebriated state.

Dev is afraid that he may loose Sona again. He can't survive without her so he can't loose her @ any cost . But the fact is that nobody can separate them but themselves. Y Vicky was able to separate them in season 1 ? It was bcoz of them only. They didn trust each other . The scenario got worsened by the emergence of prenuptial agreement n eviction of the Boses from their house. Vicky succeeded in projecting Dev as the culprit . Now after this eviction truth, Dev was cleared from one of his faults . But the prenup is still der. I wish Ishwari confesses to Sonakshi bout the prenup & how she cheated Dev to sign those papers. If that too happens, Dev'll b cleared of all his faults which actually was never his. I'm still feeling bad for Dev thinking bout this. He was projected as a culprit of some crimes which he actually had no idea bout. If all misunderstandings bout Dev gets cleared , then Sona can make him understand that no matter wat happens, she's never ever gonna leave him again. If he get such an assuarance, Dev no longer need to b insecure or over protective bout Sona. For that a heart to heart peaceful talk bet Devakshi is essential. Either Sona need to book a resort jst like the way she did to celebrate their SR or Dev need to book an entire restaurant, jst like the way he used to do for others like Ritwick or Payal but try to do the same for themselves too. Hav a meaningful peaceful convo away from all these hullabaloo , spend some time happily n clear all the misunderstandings.

But I didn like Dev showing dictatorship towards Sonakshi . Don try to impose our decisions on others but ask their consent & unanimously take decisions. Sona had lived 7 yrs away from Dev n she herself established well in her career , @ the same time , she single handedly managed looking after Soha , of course with the help of her family . AOS, if anyone comes to hinder in her professional life ,citing the well being of her child , I don think Sona can take that as lightly , nt even normal humans can. Independence & freedom of speech r everyone's right .Esp for an entrepreneur like Sona who took decisions by herself so far , it'll b very difficult if one fine morning someone , even if it's her husband , out of anxiety taking a decision bout her job without her consent . Dev is trying to impose his decisions on her which is wrong. Dev shud've consulted her b4 taking any actions on her behalf. For this , this duo needs to open up. Cvs , pl make them talk. They can even talk bout their bitter separation n try to find out wer they went wrong. Introspection is essential once in a while. ( Dev had already irritated Sona with the tracker app installation in her mobile without her consent )

Dev's anxiety n anticipations r actually baseless . Sona's late night experience was a mere accident. It was neither a planned one nor she belongs to Z category .But this is wat happens everywhere, including metropolitan cities wen a woman is left stranded @ late night. Jst like Sona said, people will take an umbrella during rains to reach their destinations rather sitting @ home , wen needed. V , sometimes falls prey to such dire circumstances but learn some lessons from such incidents too. Same goes with Soha accident too. It was a result of carelessness , nothing else.

I'm nt gonna say dev shud b saved or sona shud b saved but rather let them save n help themselves. Both of them r biased , flawed n nt doing the right things for the time being .They need to pour out their hearts for themselves, minimise the differences n need to look things from each others POVs. Put themselves into each others shoes n then try to deal things .

. Lets rewind the writers words.. all characters r real, incorrigible n unpredictable. Wen they fight , they pick the points that r most convenient to them , ignoring instances n arguments that don't suit their side. So incidents like this will shower in our show . As per spoilers.if sona leaves Dev for a while n goes bak to her house , it'll surely giv a wake up call to dev as for a healthy family life, nt only luv n care but giving space too is important. The couples shud've good communication bet themselves n respect each others decisions but never force / impose ourselves on our partners . As for viewers it's jst like Dev said in season 1 , looking thru the rose glasses... sab kuch gulabi gulabi dikhta hai. If v look thru, Dev glass , u'll only c his goodness n if u c thru sona glass , u can c everything good bout her but try to c things from both sides, everything ll b crystal clear n only then v can relate to this unpredictable , deep rooted , impossible ( both Dev n Sona.. tumi ekdom impossible ! ) characters.

P.S. I always felt the look of these actors surely enhanced the POVs of characters in influencing the viewers. If it's nt for Shaheer, I don think ,Dev wud get such a recognition even with/without his flaws n the same goes with Erica's Sonakshi too.

Btw, Sonakshi had warned Vicky nt to do any harm to their family or Dev even after knowing his hand in their eviction from their house. But after knowing his failed attempt to sell Dev's software , Sona didn even lift her small finger ( some other finger was apt, but anyways ) against him. How cud that even possible for a strong, independent , intelligent girl like Sonakshi ? CVs..Kuch bhi !!

YASHO1997 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#10
Guysss good morning!!!
I can't hold my excitement in anymore!!!
The week will be a blast!!
You know mera imagination kya hai?
Sona frustrated goes to Bose house. This I am saying because right now she won't be able to understand him so I think only asha can help.
While here ishwari will knock sense into dev.
Both realizing their mistake should go to each other...maybe farmhouse where they pour out everything they are holding back or at least start the process. And I am greedy... So maybe sona will be in the same dress and you know...ahm.. Ahmmm!!
This will be the perfect scenario!
Abhi tak toi spoilers have also not come out and tvserial updates has also not given any news... Do after Monday and maybe starting of Tuesday we know nothing.. So damn excited!!!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".