*Season 2, Week 8* Analysis Thread

thedramaqueen thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#1

Welcome to the weekly analysis thread, where we dissect the heck out of the characters, situations, and the possibilities for the leap! This thread is dedicated to in-depth character and story analysis in this new phase of the show. Let's explore how the show, in its complexity makes us think. We leave the thread open-ended so that we can discuss varied topics with each other in a more informal way, and new thread begins every Sunday evening for ongoing discussions as the week unfolds. If you are interested in this exercise, jump right in!

_____________

Everyone is invited to join as long as they avoid:

1. Moral policing. This thread should be an inclusive and safe space for people to express their views. This is a work of fiction and multiple interpretations only make it a richer experience. If something about the show makes you uncomfortable, be open to the idea that you might be missing the necessary perspective that someone else could provide.

2. Bashing CVs. Criticism is welcome, but should be focused and constructive.

3. Bashing the characters, or pitting them against one another. If you think either the Dixits or the Boses are entirely right, and the other entirely to blame, this is not the thread for you.

And most importantly...

4. BASHING OR PERSONAL INSULTS OF OTHER MEMBERS

This means we accept other people's viewpoints with respect, and don't call them names for not agreeing with us. Either we continue the argument calmly, supported by examples from the show, or we respectfully agree to disagree and leave that discussion alone.

Additionally, if you notice something being discussed on another thread in the forum that you would like to get a perspective on here, please link it in your post and let the other Thread Maker know. This allows for them to come and discuss here if they like and makes us all good neighbours.

___________

Links to Previous Threads

Week 1 Week 6

Week 2 Week 7

Week 3

Week 4

Week 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

400

Views

34.2k

Users

58

Likes

5.1k

Frequent Posters

thedramaqueen thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: deepsel

Finally managed to read through the entire thread and what amazing posts I read here 👏 Hats off to every one of you, I may not be in agreement with some points but still accept my "super likes " for the mere way of writing them in such matured way👏

Absolutely loved friday's episode ..penned my thoughts and posting it here too for your Sunday read.. See you can't open new thread without me posting in weekend naa😉 😆

Deepa I had been itching to sit down and respond to your post. Kids, office and housework I tell you.. Keeps you away from such important matters 🤢. I couldnt go to bed before replying to this one.
Of course the thread is incomplete without your thoughts. 🤬or not 😃

Friday's episode is nothing short of a miracle for me. I was bowled by the sudden layers makers have inflicted in that single episode and wanted to pen my thoughts as soon as I saw the episode. What a perfect ending to the not so perfect start of the week 👏 Post might be long, read at own risk😆


Dev never had to slog for any perfect relationship as he was always given when demanded/asked including Sonakshi who ran to his arms the day he confessed. But today his own blood asked him to prove his perfection to be a father and that shook "The Dev Dixit" for the first time. Had Sonakshi raised this doubt 7 years back, both won't be standing here today heartbroken by their very own tiny Kargosh !

Absolutely. Soha likes Dev. What I was most impressed with is, that its not that Soha has no place for her "papa" in her life (contrary to what our Dr perfect Bose thinks). She absolutely has a place for papa. She drew him as per her imaginations and has a certain bar that Our Dear Zulifi Dixit needs to meet. What I was also thinking is, subconsciously has sonakshi actually built the image in Soha;s mind which is like Dev? Is that why she ended up drawing a man who looks like Golu's bigcha?

Leaving aside the age factor and the morality of asking perfection by a 6 yr old, I loved how makers showed young children tend to believe what they see in face value. Suhana for the past 6 years has seen only one father figure and that was Bijoy and for her he is the father value for perfection, hence its not a surprise that she wanted to know whether her "Papa" is at same level or not. This very statement showed how much she missed a father figure indirectly in that tight knit Bose family. Why else a child wishes for a father to be perfect only when he drops in school, asks about dinner , loves at every step, etc etc ..? Somewhere down the line Suhana missed that love Bijoy showers on Sona😳


Another mind-blowing confession which I don't know how many of you thought like me is Dev's explanation for Suhana's question " Why couldn't you call momma and figured out I was there ?". Well we all know that he doesn't know her existence but that doesn't justify him for not approaching his estranged loved wife and that hit Dev as well. See his reply " Miss Bose ( I felt he addressed both Sona and Suhana here 😉) I know you are very angry on me, I even don't know what should I do to reduce your anger..but now please give me a chance, I will try to my fullest ability to prove you am not a bad person". Is he hinting Sonakshi that he is ready to woo her back and asking for a second chance for taking her granted the first time? Also when he said " I know you think that I didn't take care of your mother, hence couldn't take care of you" , are makers hinting he did approach Sona behind her back to help but everyone thinks otherwise?

I had been hoping against hope that is someone helped Sonakshi build her business it might as well be Dev. Because that's what he does - builds businesses and stalk. Why would he not do that this time. I wish he did. Soha wishes he did. This would have been the last stalking assignment of his life.

He is so used to impressing and making Misses Bose feel special, that this should come as second nature to him. However, little Ms bose is also a little Ms Dev. And we know what happens when Khargosh and obodhro end up in the same person. Dev has his work cut out.

He bares his sadness impulsively to Sona how he is left alone for the second time after his momentary return of happiness only to be snapped back to reality that he was sharing this to the same person who was the cause of his loneliness the first time😆 And Sona gives back which even Dev accepts till she mentions how "her baaba was affected when his maa visited" and that triggers his anger how one father's sentiment is hailed and other's brushed aside a moments ago!!

Just like Ishwari who takes pride in her upbringing, when he heard Sona oozing prideness in Suhana's upbringing he snaps why a father role is sidelined because he knows how much flawed he is by his mother's so called perfect upbringing and so is Sona now and he needs to prove that to her, hence the challenge.

Trip and lift is another beautiful symbolism here showing how he will be there by her side to save her from falling and added bonus to show how Bijoy is not a perfect father as everyone portraying here because he couldn't save his daughter from pain all the time and Dev's proud face to Boses when he said " Take care of your daughter" said it all which in turn impressed Suhana as well. So Dev's entry to Suhana's heart can be achieved only via Sona's 😉

The same event showed Bijoy how flawed he is as a father and hence the insecurity peeking around Suhana because he knows how Dev can charm his way back into his daughter's life and he will be left wondering !

Now the same Dev who snarled at Ishwari for barging Boses house to see Suhana suddenly mellows after his talk with Golu and invites his mother himself why? Because how can he will become a good father himself as Suhana wants when he can't understand the feeling of his own mother? He never says whether he forgave her or not but simply brushes the issue aside because he is trying to understand a mother's heart - Sona's here to be precise😳. He can forgive Ishwari but can never forget her mistakes which was very glaringly shown in that scene.

Dev tells his mother he doesnt blame her. He has really amputated that relationship with her. He knows its no point talking to Ishwari about anything related to Sonakshi. There are no gile-shikwe now

Sona's illusion of being perfect is the result of that "Dev's right to be Suhana's life" speech to Bijoy but when the day that right indeed comes to force am sure makers will show her flaws too 😳.

To become a good father, Dev needs to show Suhana his roots which is "Ishwari" like Bijoy and Asha are roots on Boses side whom she adores. His action may be stupid but it proved how willing Suhana was to see her father's side of family when she immediately joins him momentarily. But glad she remembers her values in an instant to teach Dev the right way! Also CVs are touching "My mom knows best and I live for her" nerve of Dev and introspect himself through Suhana which Sona failed to show him or he even failed to realize himself !!

suhana is curious about her father's family. however, she is still not willing to let her own family down. This was beautifully played

A man who never sways away from his ways , bows toward the right direction for the first time seeking permission from the mother of his child straight through the front door !!👏

Suhana is the binding force of Dev , Sona , Boses and Ishwari, who is going to show how each one is flawed inspite of them taking pride in their perfection ...and friday's episode is the starting point of this realization !! Well done CVs 👏 !!

beautiful lines Deepa




amaypranay thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
Congratulations everyone, What a rocking thread this is 👏

@Deeps fantastic post regarding Friday's episode 👏
timbarucha83 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
Hi everyone thanks for the new thread
sona_naksh thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#5
Just like most of the people here ..i too think dev had atleast tried once to reach out to sonakshi just to make sure she is fine ...but i m thinking about the fact that he may not have done it too ...although not doing it ...as in not making sure that sona is fine when he knows she has been thrown out of the house in the middle of the night is sth i feel dev is not capable of doing ...

During ritwick time also dev's stalking sona and all was from his firm believe that sona loves him and not ritwick But this time he dint have faith in sona's love coz for the lady who thinks he takes her as gold digger , or doubts her professional capabilities or is jealous of her success , or belittles her coz she cant be a mother ...a lady who can think so low of her can not love him ...hence his parting words to sona ...n dev's fb also says that as much as he is hurt by sona's parting words n actions he is hurt by his words too ...

So for him not going behind sona makes sense too ...coz for him dere was nth left not even love ...and second thing if he had done any such thing he would have told sona by now ...atleast after knowing abt suhana's ques
..but i would love to be pleasantly surprised if cvs are holding it as trump card ...

Sorry if i offended anyone by chance ...
Shaavi thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: sona_naksh

Just like most of the people here ..i too think dev had atleast tried once to reach out to sonakshi just to make sure she is fine ...but i m thinking about the fact that he may not have done it too ...although not doing it ...as in not making sure that sona is fine when he knows she has been thrown out of the house in the middle of the night is sth i feel dev is not capable of doing ...

During ritwick time also dev's stalking sona and all was from his firm believe that sona loves him and not ritwick But this time he dint have faith in sona's love coz for the lady who thinks he takes her as gold digger , or doubts her professional capabilities or is jealous of her success , or belittles her coz she cant be a mother ...a lady who can think so low of her can not love him ...hence his parting words to sona ...n dev's fb also says that as much as he is hurt by sona's parting words n actions he is hurt by his words too ...

So for him not going behind sona makes sense too ...coz for him dere was nth left not even love ...and second thing if he had done any such thing he would have told sona by now ...atleast after knowing abt suhana's ques
..but i would love to be pleasantly surprised if cvs are holding it as trump card ...

Sorry if i offended anyone by chance ...



Dev belongs to the category "neki kar aur dariya main daal". Someone who would help but not talk about it or tell it to the person he helped as a big thing. Best example is when he gets the cake to Sonakshi for her mother's birthday. He gets the chef to bake the cake in 4 hrs, takes care of his kids for that time and then arranges vacation package for them as a thank you for their help with cake. He doesn't tell anything about this to Sonakshi. Not when he takes the cake to her nor any time. Sonakshi comes to know of everything only because of chef.

It is also similar to him booking a taxi service for her after her accident where she doesn't have to pay the total fare but has to pay only a part of it. My guess is that he did make sure Sonakshi was safe, but through somebody whom he trusted. But also since he was angry, he did not want to know anything personal about her.

Just guessing... I am very curious too to know if he did help her or not... 😃
siddhi.d123 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#7
@sona naksh: I too think that Dev didn't keep tabs on Sona but I would be happy to be surprised.I am not really able to sympathise with Dev.When he talks about being left alone and suffering and wanting to be happy again it sounds hollow to me.I would like to see his journey or his suffering to really understand his pain.Nor do I understand his anger towards Sona or his overacting in front of her he knows she came back to him but he still now claims that Sona never understands him.What really are his expectations from Sona?? He just keeps on claiming his right on Sona and Soha but is not willing to take any efforts to it.He should really stop playing the victim card it's going overboard now 😕
Samzz thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8
Finally! After days of waiting and catching up with the episodes I am here ( and also succeeding in making two more friends watch the show 😆)
Frankly speaking, I was surprised with the forum's reaction for the three episodes aired last week. If the cvs would show sudden change in Dev towards Sona and sudden realisation of Ishwari, it would be The End and happily ever after in about 10 episodes and not so real in my POV.

The hurt and pain are too deep rooted to just brush off their anger. Both are childishly stubborn in admitting anything to themselves. Belive me, I found golu and soha more mature in their simple talks than devakshi in their fights😆. Cvs rightly brought out the golu soha convo about their little 'insecurities' telling us that only if adults would talk their hearts so openly

Dev's reaction to Sonakshi for making him wait is not surprising for one thing, he did something similar. He is assuming its a tit for tat and naturally lost his temper. But the incident that really was impressing was the father-daughter meet. Suhana was not particularly happy when she saw her father. She simply opened up her heart and told I will call you papa only when you win my heart. But this sterness is only towards her father not to her friend. She is normal with him as a friend but a stern teacher as a daughter. Her maturity in this dual role amazed me a lot. In all these I couldn't help but feel sorry for Dev for his helplessness and vulnerability.
coolmeet thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#9
Yayy congrats to all for anther thread.
Let's rock
sona_naksh thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Shaavi

[BR][BR]Dev belongs to the category "neki kar aur dariya main daal". Someone who would help but not talk about it or tell it to the person he helped as a big thing. Best example is when he gets the cake to Sonakshi for her mother's birthday. He gets the chef to bake the cake in 4 hrs, takes care of his kids for that time and then arranges vacation package for them as a thank you for their help with cake. He doesn't tell anything about this to Sonakshi. Not when he takes the cake to her nor any time. Sonakshi comes to know of everything only because of chef.[BR][BR]It is also similar to him booking a taxi service for her after her accident where she doesn't have to pay the total fare but has to pay only a part of it. My guess is that he did make sure Sonakshi was safe, but through somebody whom he trusted. But also since he was angry, he did not want to know anything personal about her. [BR][BR]Just guessing... I am very curious too to know if he did help her or not... [:D]

completely agree with u shaavi ...my own opinion is dev has somehow made sure sona n her family were safe and with all d basic necessities ...he has not kept tabs on sonakshi nor has gone after her ...but he somehow ensured her security

as far as dev not telling anyone abt it ...i agree ...he never told anyone and helped dem behind deir back ...n i guess after dev n sona talked abt dev giving money to saurabh ...dev told sona i dont believe in show off ...so i know he is completely capable to hiding a favour he has done to anyone ..but right now him nt going behind sona is questioned by his daughter i feel shud push him beyond limits ...
but den telling watever he has done just to gain his daughter's trust is also against dev ...

lets c ...m eagerly waiting for some fbs if we get to know dev's side of story ...but looking at dev's hair n beard ...i dont think makers have planned any [LOL]

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".