Watch

TEAM

Phir Subah Hogi India Forums

Why strong woman characters never work in India?

Page

Next Last

Pirated_Fun

@Pirated_Fun

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

I have fallen in love with the show ,It is well directed emotional , reralistic and gives us hope to fight for better tomorrow

Sugni is a strong character which was clear from the promo , when she refused to get her sardhakai.Now I don't know why but all the time strong woman characters hardly works the way weak ,doormat bahus work in tv

Zee Tc now a days giving us strong woman characters like Krishan of afsar Bitiyan or Hitler didi from HD ,Now Sugni , but none of them are getting high trps It is sad that strong woman who can give indian women the courage to fight for injustice is not liked by mass.

Edited by --PiaSenGupta-- - 13 years ago

Quote

Created

13years

Last reply

13years

Replies

Views

Users

Likes

Frequent Posters

-Nakshatra-

@-Nakshatra-

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

It's not that such strong woman characters don't work. May be the show is yet to garner better response because of the strange tradition it depicts. By time people will accept shows with bold subjects rather than ridiculous saas bahu crap. This show particularly by Story and Screenplay is way ahead. Applause to everyone behind the show.

Edited by -Nakshatra- - 13 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

-Srushti-

@-Srushti-

Sparkler

+ 7

Posted: 13 years ago

Hey Pia..I agree with you to some extent...about the examples you cited...Hitler didi..I think started with great TRPs mainly bec of Rati Pandey...but Personally I think they have messed the story( Sorry if you are fan😳...Only mhy POV),,,We were complaining same thing about Gulaal..which was a story of a strong girl...that it was not going well with the audience inspite of the story line...and other bahus who are always crying get higher trps...may be the audience connects well with the underdogs😕..Dont know,,,may be we wil have to wait till they become strong enough to connect with strong audience😳

Quote

Putija

@PutijaChalhov

Stunner

+ 9

Posted: 13 years ago

Pia nice post maybe the audience does not like the women in pants but the minority who like dont give TRPs we have the trps always behind the wicked dominating saas and the submissive crying bahu type of shows if you see the top trp getting shows or maybe some reality shows.

Experiments dont seem to work over a longer period I am liking the social drama and Sugni of PSH dont know how long the PH and CH will sustain it without spoiling the interesting story line

Quote

KhatamKahani

@KhatamKahani

Stunner

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: chalhov
Pia nice post maybe the audience does not like the women in pants but the minority who like dont give TRPs we have the trps always behind the wicked dominating saas and the submissive crying bahu type of shows if you see the top trp getting shows or maybe some reality shows.

Experiments dont seem to work over a longer period I am liking the social drama and Sugni of PSH dont know how long the PH and CH will sustain it without spoiling the interesting story line

Which is why I wish they some of the shows I am enjoying these days have some kind of timetable and END in mind.

The biggest culprit is the attempt to prolong the show as long as possible, only to have the plug pulled with only weeks' notice.

Quote

734167

Suspended

Posted: 13 years ago

only reason i can show that is PSH is imposing only on bedni n thakur but no offence some people thinks its a problem of that state only why we ll watch that show but i'm hopeful if cv keeps putting input they ll definitely emerge as winner cause hard work bold contents are always winner.n i'm hopeful it ll be able to take place in people heart.Moreover,its a critically acclaimed successful show n once ipl ends psh ll get more new viewers

Edited by AbiAnshUtpol - 13 years ago

Quote

734167

Suspended

Posted: 13 years ago

i think common people don watch these shows who need this more than awared people who regularly watch this shows.u know these shows get at least similar trp every week means for this shows theres certain types of viewers who are mainly want the country to change by bold content.i hope all common people ll too join us to watch such beautiful shows

Quote

pallavi25

@pallavi25

Inactive

+ 5

Posted: 13 years ago

Dont worry, it will get there!

PSH has been on air for only what? 2 months or so? And already its TRPs have made it to the toppers list at least here on IF!

Its such a well made show that slowly it will pick up through word of mouth, I will recommend it to my friends and family, u all also do so and it will garner more and more viewers as the story progresses!

As for the dhokla shows they are only enjoyed by the Gujju Bens and housewives who only enjoy kitchen politics and suffering DILs crying buckets at the slightest reason!

As for the top ranking Diya aur Baati hum, some ppl love to see a bahu being tortured, they have some kind of sadistic streak, also the hero of that show is a total hunk so some women only watch the show for him I guess! 😆

Serial No. Rank Date Day Start Time Programme TVR

1 8 06/05/2012 Sun 21:00 KNORR SOUPY DID LITTLE MASTER 2 AUDITION 3.74

2 20 11/05/2012 Fri 22:30 PUNARVIVAH 2.65

3 22 11/05/2012 Fri 21:59 MRS KAUSHIK KI PAANCH BAHUEIN 2.46

4 24 07/05/2012 Mon 21:00 PAVITRA RISHTA 2.31

5 36 07/05/2012 Mon 21:30 PHIR SUBAH HOGI 1.75

6 40 10/05/2012 Thu 19:59 HITLER DIDI 1.55

7 46 08/05/2012 Tue 20:30 YAHAN MEIN GHAR GHAR KHELI 1.38

8 48 07/05/2012 Mon 19:29 CHHOTI BAHU 1.35

9 59 06/05/2012 Sun 11:05 HFF HUM AAPKE HAIN KAUN 1.17

10 62 11/05/2012 Fri 19:00 AFSAR BITIYA 1.02

As we see, PSH is on rank 36 in total of all channels, now count out the IPL matches and its on a higher rank. Its number 5 on Zee so its not too bad for a brand new show, right?

Edited by pallavi25 - 13 years ago

Quote

Rupa

@-rupa-

Rocker

Posted: 13 years ago

I agree ...i am also one of them who dont see afsar bitya or hitler didi ..i am not sure of there story line but hopefully PSH story should be great enough to see .

Quote

kamala2012

@kamala2012

Inactive

Posted: 13 years ago

#10

I agree to some extent but not fully. There are some shows, like Pratigya, who has always been a strong woman. Depends on how people think about strength. Some people think being patient and loving is strength. But Pratigya and that heroine of Ruk Jaana Nahin they are strong women or girls.

It all depends on the story. How they show the characters will decide everything.

Quote

1 2

Why strong woman characters never work in India?

Related Topics

Explore Topics