An honest comparison between Shankar and Shaan - Page 7

Originally posted by: baghabayen

Completely agreed with safeena,

SHAAN IS THE BEST CAPTAIN.

Again the same thing about captaincy...many people here believe shaan is the best captain and mostly the the reasons given for that are ..he dint come to sing against a contestant , he was fair gave everyone fair chance to perform and is a good encourages his team. Is that all required to be a best captain??? Where is the ORIGINALITY ?...where is the IMPROVISATION? being INTUITIVE? throughout the competetion they just sang the song as it without any effort to vary the song be it one on one singing or medley. whereas the other team is trying a lot to improvise and are original. Also forget about singing ...even most of the theme or strategy they havent thought on their own.
1) Shreya started singing marathi song ..shaan sang dhagala lagli kala which is a marathi song next episode.
2) Shankar used Ganpati idol to pay tribute to the god..Shaan also the same thing with Lord Shivas idol.
3) Shankar started and followed by himesh to sing desh bhakti song shaan also did the same thing.
there r probably more ....I fail to see any originality in shaans strikers performances. I agree he is a good captain ..motivates his team well and stands up for his team but these r not enough reasons to be a best captain.

Originally posted by: rahul_02006

Again the same thing about captaincy...many people here believe shaan is the best captain and mostly the the reasons given for that are ..he dint come to sing against a contestant , he was fair gave everyone fair chance to perform and is a good encourages his team. Is that all required to be a best captain??? Where is the ORIGINALITY ?...where is the IMPROVISATION? being INTUITIVE? throughout the competetion they just sang the song as it without any effort to vary the song be it one on one singing or medley. whereas the other team is trying a lot to improvise and are original. Also forget about singing ...even most of the theme or strategy they havent thought on their own.
1) Shreya started singing marathi song ..shaan sang dhagala lagli kala which is a marathi song next episode.
2) Shankar used Ganpati idol to pay tribute to the god..Shaan also the same thing with Lord Shivas idol.
3) Shankar started and followed by himesh to sing desh bhakti song shaan also did the same thing.
there r probably more ....I fail to see any originality in shaans strikers performances. I agree he is a good captain ..motivates his team well and stands up for his team but these r not enough reasons to be a best captain.

Originally posted by: navaneeta

I guess that ORIGINALITY software (posted in another thread) did not reached Shaan ... hmmm very very sad.

I'm really getting enlightened from this forum ... so

- If in any movie someone wears a black suit, then in another movie by any chance black suit is worn .. then 'haila ... copy kiya' ... context ... pretext .... no matter ... so Shankar's team using Ganapati idol has been copied by Love and friendship theme using Shiva's idol ... but was not that copied from the movie itself .. Vinod Khanna singing before Lord Shiva ...'Bhole O Bhole' ... hmm so to showcase that ... Shaan's team should have sang ...'Roole ... Tu Roole😭' in front of Madonna Picture ... to prove originality ... great idea after Jala Do

- Shaan either stick to only HINDI song .. but that's also copy .. as others are also singing Hindi ... so Shaan need sto sing Chineese and Spanish Songs .... ORIGINALITY

- Desh Bhakti theme by Shaan ????? when? Shankar Started, followed by Himesh? But as per my meory goes .... Himesh in his 1st round after Shaan used Desh Bhakti and that was Shankar's first performance ... So Himesh started .... followed by Shankar in Jala Do ... and ohh I guess Shaan may use Desh Bhakti in the final round so you got the script and know that Shaan is scripted to copy .. right ....

Some more GK for me ....

It was much more obvious then black suit....my point was there is no originality in the singing or the themes. Whatever they did was after someone else had already done. Out of all thousands movies he had to pick vinod khannas movie in which he sang in front of the idol???? he had to do the marathi song the very next episode shreya did.???? it was just to please the audience...that he realised it later that he could please more people by doing that. And what about singing??? its just a note to note copy of the song, against any other team its fine as not many have the capability to do vary a song...but shankar rockstars are doing it.
btw I accidently clicked on the like button on ur post :)

Originally posted by: rahul_02006

Again the same thing about captaincy...many people here believe shaan is the best captain and mostly the the reasons given for that are ..he dint come to sing against a contestant , he was fair gave everyone fair chance to perform and is a good encourages his team. Is that all required to be a best captain??? Where is the ORIGINALITY ?...where is the IMPROVISATION? being INTUITIVE? throughout the competetion they just sang the song as it without any effort to vary the song be it one on one singing or medley. whereas the other team is trying a lot to improvise and are original. Also forget about singing ...even most of the theme or strategy they havent thought on their own.
1) Shreya started singing marathi song ..shaan sang dhagala lagli kala which is a marathi song next episode.
2) Shankar used Ganpati idol to pay tribute to the god..Shaan also the same thing with Lord Shivas idol.
3) Shankar started and followed by himesh to sing desh bhakti song shaan also did the same thing.
there r probably more ....I fail to see any originality in shaans strikers performances. I agree he is a good captain ..motivates his team well and stands up for his team but these r not enough reasons to be a best captain.

It was much more obvious then black suit....my point was there is no originality in the singing or the themes. Whatever they did was after someone else had already done. Out of all thousands movies he had to pick vinod khannas movie in which he sang in front of the idol???? he had to do the marathi song the very next episode shreya did.???? it was just to please the audience...that he realised it later that he could please more people by doing that. And what about singing??? its just a note to note copy of the song, against any other team its fine as not many have the capability to do vary a song...but shankar rockstars are doing it.
btw I accidently clicked on the like button on ur post :)

Originally posted by: navaneeta

I guess that ORIGINALITY software (posted in another thread) did not reached Shaan ... hmmm very very sad.

I'm really getting enlightened from this forum ... so

- If in any movie someone wears a black suit, then in another movie by any chance black suit is worn .. then 'haila ... copy kiya' ... context ... pretext .... no matter ... so Shankar's team using Ganapati idol has been copied by Love and friendship theme using Shiva's idol ... but was not that copied from the movie itself .. Vinod Khanna singing before Lord Shiva ...'Bhole O Bhole' ... hmm so to showcase that ... Shaan's team should have sang ...'Roole ... Tu Roole😭' in front of Madonna Picture ... to prove originality ... great idea after Jala Do

- Shaan either stick to only HINDI song .. but that's also copy .. as others are also singing Hindi ... so Shaan need sto sing Chineese and Spanish Songs .... ORIGINALITY

- Desh Bhakti theme by Shaan ????? when? Shankar Started, followed by Himesh? But as per my meory goes .... Himesh in his 1st round after Shaan used Desh Bhakti and that was Shankar's first performance ... So Himesh started .... followed by Shankar in Jala Do ... and ohh I guess Shaan may use Desh Bhakti in the final round so you got the script and know that Shaan is scripted to copy .. right ....

Some more GK for me ....

It was much more obvious then black suit....my point was there is no originality in the singing or the themes. Whatever they did was after someone else had already done. Out of all thousands movies he had to pick vinod khannas movie in which he sang in front of the idol???? he had to do the marathi song the very next episode shreya did.???? it was just to please the audience...that he realised it later that he could please more people by doing that. And what about singing??? its just a note to note copy of the song, against any other team its fine as not many have the capability to do vary a song...but shankar rockstars are doing it.
btw I accidently clicked on the like button on ur post :)

I am sorry your post doesnt make much sense to me.

[QUOTE=Killer007

@ rahul_02006

navaneeta, perfect answer for killerbhai👏👏

Originally posted by: Killer007

It is so sad that this forum is dominated by 3-4 people, & others are not even entitled to give their honest opinion! 😔

I think no one is stopping you to give your point of view. But please don't expect everyone to agree with your personal honest opinion. It is always nice to have different points of view.