An honest comparison between Shankar and Shaan - Page 11

Created

Last reply

Replies

104

Views

16.9k

Users

28

Likes

148

Frequent Posters

navaneeta thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: nithyak

I dont want to instigate fights but these are facts.
Laughing at somebody's biwi or family is not a fun post. I have read your posts too and you even reached Javedji's pajama.
We all have brothers, sisters and parents and may be kids too so we should think twice before posting after all it was just a reality show.
It is an open forum that doesnt mean you will make fun by using such thoughts

@ Nithyak ... please read carefully .... I have mentioned about white color of the dress .... and the mood was fun mood ... there are so many direct post which talks badly about (and not in fun mood as well) Shaan's wife ... there is post where there is direct communal attack .. now leaving all these you have picked up a fun post .... and that too after 1 long week of the post. If you had any objection, issue with the post you could have told then itself rather than waiting for 1 week and trying cut post of one post in a different one ....
In a fun mood people talks a lot about many issues which otherwise becomes serious. You must have seen that in all TV shows and forums and all places ... talking in a fun mood about celebs and their surrounding are very much done everywhere .. any filmfare award function you find it .... after the show ended ... when someone told directly that Shaan is a bura person, why you did not protest that then ???? Isn't he also a respectable person ... why are you selective on some people by cutting pasting old fun post and trying to prove something ???? Now on that post someone said so Shaan is Ravan, Debo Kumbhakarna etc etc .... but it was a fun post, so was on a sporting spirit .....
I'm requesting sincerely do not pull out portion of week of posts from other threads after the show has ended .... have not you seen in KBC2 Sharukh himself tells over phone and acts like talking to wife and having some fun with audience that biwi will beat me, mujhe kapre dhona parega etc ... but was that real or fun ... please understand the difference.
Inspite of all this if you are keen on just bringing up fun posts only and keep a blind eye on all real posts where Shaan's supporters were name called, chopped, openly told as bura person, his wife acts on cry etc. etc .. and moreso communal comments ... I have nothing to say and anyone can understand the motto .... Jai Ho
P.S: I would not respond further as I'm signing off from the forum. The show has ended ....
Edited by navaneeta - 15 years ago
nithyak thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
Those were not fun posts.
Javedji was bashed in all possible ways.
bambooshoot thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
nithyaji, sorry I meant to hit the like button on navaneeta's post. But I did it to yours by mistake. She has given a very good explanation for your doubts and I don't see any need to explain further.

Thanks!
cooks09 thumbnail
Navigator Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
hi
very nice post .. thanks for that..
regarding mkmm ... shaan's team and him as a captain were far ahead than shankar's team. it is a known fact that shankar is a better singer, musician and very learned and trained singer but was very unfair captain. It was true that his team was weak but that was chosen by him so he can not argue about that and keep singing himself against shaan's team singers.
as far as shaan's musical background is concerned he is a son of very wellknown composer manas mukherjee and his mom is also a trained singer so music is in his genes and is a very well trained singer although he started his carreer as pop singer.
I wish that shaan's team was far superior in all respect and should have won
x.o.x.o thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
I completely agree with you (:
No offence to Shankar's fans, but seriously, it's like he might as well have been the only person in his team. He hardly sends the others, especially not his chupa rustams.
Although, I must say, he has awesome medley's and his team had very good singers, only if we could have heard them more.
And I feel that Javed Akhtar was very biased.


And yes Shaan has lost his temper a few times.. :P But his arguments always have a good point .. not 'because it was very similar to the original singer'. [seriously, wtf??]

Again, no offence, just my opinion

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".