An honest comparison between Shankar and Shaan - Page 9

Created

Last reply

Replies

104

Views

16.9k

Users

28

Likes

148

Frequent Posters

safeenafarheen thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#81

Originally posted by: rahul_02006

Which medley with theme are u are u talking about?? newyas I dont remember it.

Get your facts right safeena...2nd january against shreya he sang Marathi song which is not part of a regional theme ...regional theme was after that.

I kinda think they wouldnt have thought of bringing an Lord Shivas idol on the stage if they hadnt seen shankar doing it.
(I cannot get rid of the red font)
wife child????? how is it connected to music ka muqabala????

I am sorry to say I wasnt much impressed by Shaans medleys...I found shreyas and Shankars medley better.
and Ya I do enjoy shankars alaps and sargams , atleast something different and not many singers can do what he does. neways I said what I had to probably wont be saying nething further.



r u a astrologer,who can say anything is if shankar doesnt bring ganapathi,shaan wont bring lord shive,we really not impressed lot with shankar all medley,few o them amazing,but alaps,dhinchak was really boring now by listening from him in all medleys,in his songs etc..

ya its connected to copy cat issue"chhild and wife"..ya both r marathi songs..shreya sing marathi means shaan cant ya,shaans medely based on that time masti damal,he was selected bengali,marathi,hindi songs for masti,dhamaal theme.if someone sings marathi number,another one cant sing marathi number kya..shaan stareted singing bengali sings,shreya too followed,u cant say we cant sing on those regional songs,if we started arguing with this baseless opinion ,it wont end rahul fan..for u shankar medleys best,but peoples r getting bored now with shanakr singing in rounds and medey alaps,got this info with lots of sites anf=d with this sites,i too felt,shankar is maha guru in those,he uses them all time...

i dont want to argue with baseless combination ya..u dono about shaans talent,look out his album tanhadil,tishangi,lovelogy,take me to ur heart,aksar,many albums with a grt message and theme,shaan is maha expert in making theme and his song selection was amaizing..wonderfu medelys by shaan from the first to last,loved by all publics,majority love shaan medleys and strikers performances..
Edited by safeenafarheen - 15 years ago
navaneeta thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#82

Originally posted by: Killer007

.... aapko opnion (honest + dishonest) dene se bhi koi nahi mana kiya ... ek bhi post bataiye jaha pe "DO NOT WRITE or POST" ... CHOP/ KILL likha hua hein ????

"DO NOT WRITE or POST" ... CHOP/ KILL likha hua hein ????" These words need not be necessarily written! as soon as you see someone giving their critical views about shaan u start debating & defending for no reason, u keep quoting & arguing with that person!
That is what I meant!
First of all I must say that you have an amazing sence of understanding where you write in BOLD "others are not entitled to give their honest opinion" and when being asked how you derive to that conclusion and where you have been stopped to put down your opinion ... then you say "these words need not be necessarily written" .... but you write in such a polite manner that if any Shaan/ other supporter try to write anything in their favor or express their POV they would be CHOPPED .....so you even have gone to the extent of WRITING those words which breaks the norm and use abusive language for Shaan supporter ....
Morderators ... If you follow the posts ... please look into the basic decorum of writing and help the forum to be fun filled and constructive and request to take action against persons who use polite words as CHOPPED for other forum members....
Now coming to your point .... Well as you mentioned this forum is opened for all to share their POV, so be it anyones supporter, they are entitled to share/ express there POV and STICK to it ...
But it has been sensed that someone starts writing/ abuse people in 'new', 'new' ID's and their sole motto is personal and direct attack to Shaan Striker's supporters for reason unknown to me ....
yes, my favourite team is Shaan Strikers .... JEETENGE SHAAN SE 😊
Edited by navaneeta - 15 years ago
somone999 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#83

Originally posted by: navaneeta

I love thy sence of humor ....
- When other tell bad to others (except Shaan) - that's fun mood
- When Shaan wins - It's scripted
- When Shaan protest any unfair happenning - He is jealous, direct ..... what not
- When Shaan is made to loose - he deservers it or 'scripted to get sympathy'
- When Shaan team get less marks by one person - Those are respectful people
- When Shaan's team, specially Anwesha gets good marks - Gajji arranged the show to promote Anwesha .. so all judges (like puppet) HAVE to giver her marks ,,,,,
Reading all these posts my logic sence is really getting imbalanced .... I better leave reading and concentrate on our sensational debut and roti plan ....
Ending with thy national anthem ..... Jala Do Yeh Laundry Ka Bill .. Dhin Tak .. Taka Dina Dha ⭐️




Excuse Me For interrupting you, but I HAVE NOT SAID ANY OF THE "ABOVE STATED POINTS" in any of my posts, you can check them from the start till today.

So, i request you not to point such things at me and PLEASE don't try to be personal. I can give my Point Of View and have every right to do that. Don't MISQUOTE me.
-swati- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#84

Originally posted by: safeenafarheen



r u a astrologer,who can say anything is if shankar doesnt bring ganapathi,shaan wont bring lord shive,we really not impressed lot with shankar all medley,few o them amazing,but alaps,dhinchak was really boring now by listening from him in all medleys,in his songs etc..

ya its connected to copy cat issue"chhild and wife"..ya both r marathi songs..shreya sing marathi means shaan cant ya,shaans medely based on that time masti damal,he was selected bengali,marathi,hindi songs for masti,dhamaal theme.if someone sings marathi number,another one cant sing marathi number kya..shaan stareted singing bengali sings,shreya too followed,u cant say we cant sing on those regional songs,if we started arguing with this baseless opinion ,it wont end rahul fan..for u shankar medleys best,but peoples r getting bored now with shanakr singing in rounds and medey alaps,got this info with lots of sites anf=d with this sites,i too felt,shankar is maha guru in those,he uses them all time...

i dont want to argue with baseless combination ya..u dono about shaans talent,look out his album tanhadil,tishangi,lovelogy,take me to ur heart,aksar,many albums with a grt message and theme,shaan is maha expert in making theme and his song selection was amaizing..wonderfu medelys by shaan from the first to last,loved by all publics,majority love shaan medleys and strikers performances..


@bold,
I have a objection on this line.. I for one and many of my friends ar enot getting bored of alaaps..
So do not make a generic statement that people are getting bored..maybe you are...
Also you need liking for certain kind of music to appreciate the improvisations done by shankar..actually I admire shankar for that..
So please do not make such generic statements
safeenafarheen thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#85
@swajit-its our opinion,i saw in lots of websites,youtube,facebook,if,orkut,many..at first people felt happy on shankar alaps,seeing his talent..but now they feel bored now as it shankar was including in all his medelys,in his songs..thats it..we dint say anywrong,that shankar was not good,he was damn good on that alaps,but repeatin alaps,dhinchak,its quite bored for me,i dint said u to agree with this..
-swati- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#86

Originally posted by: safeenafarheen

@swajit-its our opinion,i saw in lots of websites,youtube,facebook,if,orkut,many..at first people felt happy on shankar alaps,seeing his talent..but now they feel bored now as it shankar was including in all his medelys,in his songs..thats it..we dint say anywrong,that shankar was not good,he was damn good on that alaps,but repeatin alaps,dhinchak,its quite bored for me,i dint said u to agree with this..


U can say I am bored..I am just saying do not say lot of people thats it...because it is not true...not all people write on IF or other sites...so do not make such generic statements
navaneeta thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#87
[QUOTE=Killer007
You check all my post I havent attacked shaan fans. Its all shaan fans who started quoting my post & arguing for no reason & I have given a little harsh reply to them! As soon as there is something unfavourable u start attacking. Even in this thread I had just given my POV or analysis, people started quoting & arguing on the shaan behaviour part, I had written other things also but u all wanted to argue on that part only, purposely for creating controversy & nothing else!
I am not a shanker fan nor shaan fan, so it doesnt matter much to me, i would be happy if shaan or shanker whoever deserving wins!
POV and analysis needs words like ....
" It is so sad that this forum is dominated by 3-4 people, & others are not even entitled to give their honest opinion!" Comment from your post....
Also another comment which was too Personal was " Shaan's Fan ... x,r,n,s, b, b etc ... keep defending EVEN AFTER BEING CHOPPED" .... Again part of your post only ....
I do not need to check all your post .. neither I want nor I have time for that ... these two are enough to put the same word ... When I asked who has stopped you to put your POV then you say those does not needs to be written .. right ... so you admit that nothing such was being written on behalf of your specified x, r, n, b etc etc Shaan supporters....
If somesone say Shaan or anyone who is their favourite as Ordinary singer, Jealous etc .. etc ... yes, supporters do have the right to defend and counter that alligation ... why there is any objection for that ....
There are difference in comment when you say that you did not liked a particular song or whose medly was better as per your POV that's different ... you may find people mentioning things as repeatative and many do not like that same approach etc etc ..... which is fine, as public anyone can share a view. But going to the extent telling bad names for forum members and captains (like Chopped, Jealous etc etc ...) is something out of decorum and rude ....
The purpose of this forum is not to bash other members using abusive words .....
Edited by navaneeta - 15 years ago
somone999 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#88
@ Killer007 and navaneeta

Please Relax. MKMM is going to end soon. I think we all should join our hands for peace and a good farewell for each other, rather than fight. Please Forgive Each Other for whatever you both said. End it.
navaneeta thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#89

Originally posted by: somone999


That was just said in a fun mood. I have more examples of Shaan saying things MORE DIRECT. But lets leave it. Don't want to argue.

- When other tell bad to others (except Shaan) - that's fun mood
- When Shaan wins - It's scripted
- When Shaan protest any unfair happenning - He is jealous, direct ..... what not
- When Shaan is made to loose - he deservers it or 'scripted to get sympathy'
- When Shaan team get less marks by one person - Those are respectful people
- When Shaan's team, specially Anwesha gets good marks - Gajji arranged the show to promote Anwesha .. so all judges (like puppet) HAVE to giver her marks ,,,,,



Excuse Me For interrupting you, but I HAVE NOT SAID ANY OF THE "ABOVE STATED POINTS" in any of my posts, you can check them from the start till today.

So, i request you not to point such things at me and PLEASE don't try to be personal. I can give my Point Of View and have every right to do that. Don't MISQUOTE me.
@someone999 ... the above points have been my observation from post 'AGAINST' Shaan ... not specifically you ... I was sharing what I have seen from posts .... and since you mentioned Shankar told Mohit 'BECHARA' out of fun mood, the reply happened to be against your post ...
There are posts which say:
- Shaan behaves badly ... when x told about Shankar M telling Mohit 'Bechara' that was countered as ...... that's fun mood
- When Shaan wins/ anticipated to win due to strong team performance there are posts telling - It's scripted
- When Shaan protest any unfair happenning there are posts telling - He is jealous because Shankar M came to sang against Shadab and Anwesha ....
- When Shaan is made to loose by JA, and his points, where other juries also countered that point, post is there telling - Either he deservers it OR 'scripted to get sympathy'
- When Shaan team get less marks ONLY by one person and supporters comment, posts exist telling - Those are respectful people
- When Shaan's team, specially Anwesha gets good marks we have a thread alreay on that - Gajji arranged the show to promote Anwesha .. so all judges (like puppet) HAVE to giver her marks ,,,,,
Whatever I have mentioned were facts from posts and all exist in the forum ... but it's not that you (someone 999) have written all those posts ... I have nothing against a forum member or person ... I was commenting against all these comments put against the team I support and summarizing my POV .... and I only quoted your "Fun Mood" for Shankar telling Mohit 'Bechara' ...
Edited by navaneeta - 15 years ago
bambooshoot thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#90

Originally posted by: somone999

@ Killer007 and navaneeta

Please Relax. MKMM is going to end soon. I think we all should join our hands for peace and a good farewell for each other, rather than fight. Please Forgive Each Other for whatever you both said. End it.


someone999, I have nothing against your posts and I think that you put forth your points in a very civilized manner. You may have noticed that I have even supported you a few times.

Of course everyone has a right to argue their POV. As long as they do it in a civilized manner, nothing matters. After all, this is a forum and the purpose is to discuss one's POV.

However, there are a few people here, that try their best to instigate others. When someone sees a statement like this:
" Shaan's Fan ... x,r,n,s, b, b etc ... keep defending EVEN AFTER BEING CHOPPED" ....
especially from a newbie what is one supposed to decipher? Every x, very r, very n, every s, every b and every b who is Shaan's supporter will be forced to think that it is he/she that is being talked about. It only increases the unrest over here.

Both you and I would like to see the same thing. Peace in the forum! There is nothing wrong with healthy discussions and having some fun. As long as there is no name-calling or personal attacks, it is fine!


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".