Mrinalvati's actions

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

CutiepieAD

@CutiepieAD

Sparkler

Posted: 7 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: KalyaniPanchali

I agree. But for the pain Mrinal has gone through, she must think of those innocent people with empathy.

Everyone reacts to situations in a different way. Few people who went through injustice in past empathise with people going through the same. Few don't. Mrinal is a practical character. It's not wrong on her part to think about her own kingdom more than Malwa.

Agreed again. But she could have better with Malwa. That's it.

Sure, she could n should have been better.

Now I totally agree. She's totally grey and not out to out negative. But not positive. Prithvi is flawed, more towards positive.

I feel she does have positive shades. Like her love towards her brother and his family, her kingdom n subjects. But yeah Prithvi has more positive shades than her. That's how opposites attract, don't they?

I like none of those kings. 🤢 But Mrinal is definitely not like them entirely. She's a lot better. And Prithvi's character is really amazing. 😊

Of course she is not like them. What I meant was she represents their thought process of conquering lands n Prithvi represents the thought process of defending lands n preserving art.

My replies in blue

Quote

SStephy

@SStephy

Dazzler

+ 3

Posted: 7 years ago

#12

Some stories and characters are not just about right or wrong. Some characters are meant to be about what they do, why they do and what happens and what are the consequences to them and those around them. To me, Mrinal's character comes in that category. Of course, Mrinal's actions and ideology aren't ideal and shouldn't be emulated. But one can still watch her journey... from where she was, to what she has become and finally to what will become of her... and one can still feel for her or with her as the story progresses.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

MuguetDScorpion

@MuguetDScorpion

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 7 years ago

#13

IKR yesterday she said she wants to destroy the entire Malwa. Why ? Why not just kill the king's family like he killed her family ? Why kill people who aren't even aware of the past ? So far I am liking Tailap more. Yes he is cheating on his wife but at least he is not living for his revenge.

Quote

Daakshaayani Aadarsh

@PandavPranayini

Voyager

Posted: 7 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: angel_juhi04

This show is simply showing right and wrong things done by people. This is not to idolize anyone. This is hardly any love story. I understand what you said but according to what you said even Panchami was also self-centered who should be hated. She made sure the Kurukshetra ewahapoen even after many of her loved ones tried to stop the war to avoid destruction and killings of innocent people. She wanted all 100 Karavas to due even when only 2 of them were culprits. Because of her many more innocent Ives were lost. Still all she was concerned was for her revenge. Still she is idolized like a God. But Mrinal is not shown in the show to be idolized except for some of the things.

Panchali was self centered who should be hated? 😲 Who told you? She made the Kurukshetra happen and so did Lord Krishna. So now Lord had to be hated as well? The Kurukshetra was not to punish Panchali's culprits. It was to destroy adharma. It was a Dharmayuddha. It happened because Suyodhana refused to accept the peace proposal. I don't say she was a Goddess, but she was divine. She has an ansh of Parvati Devi in her and was born of out of fire. How can you compare her with Mrinal? Panchali was born to install Dharma on the Earth. The war happened in the entire Bharatavarsha and many innocents all died cause it was needed to establish a new age. It is was Lord's will. Even after going through so much, Panchali was never self centered. She was Lord Krishna's sakhi (friend). She has gone through much much more than Mrinalvati, but she seek justice not revenge. Krishna showed us that if you humiliate a woman, what happens. The destruction. And the remaining Kauravas except Vikarna laughed at her as she was being disrobed. They are equally her culprits. Vikarna had to be killed cause he supported adharma in the war. Panchali is definitely ideal. One can learn so much from her. She's not a typical lady nor like Mrinalvati. She was divine. And if you know, South India worships her as as Goddess.

Mrinal can't be idolised. I love ideal characters. Maybe that's why. But I'm enjoying the show. And I love Mrinalvati, don't think I'm not liking her. I like ideals more that's it. 😊

Edited by KalyaniPanchali - 7 years ago

Quote

Daakshaayani Aadarsh

@PandavPranayini

Voyager

Posted: 7 years ago

#15

Originally posted by: CutiepieAD

My replies in blue

I think that whatever she's doing, is not wrong from her eyes for what she had gone through. My universal perspective is making things difficult. 🥱

Quote

Daakshaayani Aadarsh

@PandavPranayini

Voyager

Posted: 7 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: S.Stephy
Some stories and characters are not just about right or wrong. Some characters are meant to be about what they do, why they do and what happens and what are the consequences to them and those around them. To me, Mrinal's character comes in that category. Of course, Mrinal's actions and ideology aren't ideal and shouldn't be emulated. But one can still watch her journey... from where she was, to what she has become and finally to what will become of her... and one can still feel for her or with her as the story progresses.

Agreed. I hope people don't idolize her and set out for revenge. 😆

Quote

Daakshaayani Aadarsh

@PandavPranayini

Voyager

Posted: 7 years ago

#17

Originally posted by: MuguetDScorpion
IKR yesterday she said she wants to destroy the entire Malwa. Why ? Why not just kill the king's family like he killed her family ? Why kill people who aren't even aware of the past ? So far I am liking Tailap more. Yes he is cheating on his wife but at least he is not living for his revenge.

Exactly. Living for revenge. That thought is not sitting well with me. I see life is a very different way. 😆

I'm enjoying the show so far and hope I'll continue to do it. As interesting as Mrinal as, I hope she realises what life is.

Quote

@bugsbunny12

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 7 years ago

#18

Originally posted by: KalyaniPanchali

Quote

Daakshaayani Aadarsh

@PandavPranayini

Voyager

Posted: 7 years ago

#19

Originally posted by: bugsbunny12

😆😆

Quote

anshvi

@anshvi

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 7 years ago

#20

Hello

Here are my 2 cents on Mrinal

The beauty of this show is that we have flawed, grey and real characters who are not pure white or black !

For me Mrinal is also grey !

Mrinal is blinded by revenge...All she thinks about is revenge and beyond that often fails to look at things

She attacked Singhdant during a festival the same way Singhdant attacked her family years ago during a festival...A lot of innocents were killed during that attack...This we know was not justifed

She told Jhakkala that for one Kosha so many innocent women died same way for one Singhdant a lot of innocents died too

We also saw how Mrinal takes all of Tailap's decisions..sometimes she imposes them on him...He came to her when he was very disturbed and wanted to speak to his akka but Mrinal instead asked him to go on the war..At that point she was the warrior Mrinal and not Tailap's akka.

She used Satyashray's alliance as a means to gain support of Bhillamdev and didn't inform Jhakkala about the same...On the other hand she refused to intervene in Kosha-Tailap matter stating that it was a private matter...But we do know that in those days alliances were done for political reasons...Yes Mrinal could have spoken to Tailap but again Mrinal stated her POV that as per her this was a private matter but she did give Jhakkala the right to deal with Kosha..So, in a way she was not completely wrong or right...She herself said that for her Mankhet is above all personal relations..So, we do know what her POV is and whether it is right or wrong is a matter of perspective...Like i personally feel that she should maintain a balance between her duties for Manyakhet and her duties as Mrinal towards her family... I personally wanted her to see how disurbed Tailap was..In that moment she should have thought like Tailap's akka and not Manyakhet's princess

Yes...some of her actions can't be justified but we do know the reasons behind them

Mrinal is still living in the past...She is haunted by those memories when her family was murdered brutally in front of her eyes

All she remembers is them dying and the face of the man who killed them !

he is a woman who lost everything right in front of her eyes...and all was left was her little brother...Mrinal is overprotective now as she can't lose Tailap and bear the same pain all over again

Mrinal is a warrior who wants revenge...They day she lets go of her revenge is the day she will once again become Tailap's akka. Jhakkala's sister in law and that Mrinal who loved music.

What makes Mrinal grey are a lot of things

Mrinal is not a cruel tyrant...Yes she has banned music but Manyakhet has also flourished under her rule...So, it seems she is a strict ruler and does impose certain rules but she is not a cruel dictator.

Remember she gave full money to those Africans who fought for her and died in the battle.She even told Jhakkala that those who died were women ! Yes at the end of the day we shouldn't be judged by our profession...we all are humans...She does have empathy.

Mrinal still keeps fast for his brother's safety, She does love him a lot and will never let anyone harm him...She cares for her family...she is loving towards Villas but it is the pain that she has inside her heart that prevents her from living freely

Mrinal did allow Jhakkala to deal with Kosha..unknowing of the fact that Jhakkala will take such a drastic step

See, her actions can't be justified coz of her tragic childhood but if she could be justified then she would have been a white character but Mrinal is a beautiful flawed and grey...That is the beauty of the character.

That is her journey...A girl who is blinded by revenge, who believes in the ideology of war will go through a journey and learn the ideology of peace, development, art and culture.

P.S.- For me Ashoka was called great not because he ruled India but coz in the end he adopted the path of peace and harmony...He adopted Buddhishm and was known for doing a lot of developmental work..It is his transformation from an ambitious tyrant into a peace loving man who believed in development that made him great in my opinion

😊

Edited by anshvi - 7 years ago

Quote

1 2 3 4

Mrinalvati's actions - Page 2

Related Topics

Explore Topics