This is my review for the Tamil movie:
First of all, don't follow the reviews. Read them, by all means but go and see for yourself and judge it yourself. Reviewers are not experts. If someone pays me money to watch a film and write a piece on it, I will become a reviewer too!!! That does not mean that my opinion is better than someone else's. 😆
I saw Ravanan last night with my sisters and brother. We loved it. It was fabulous...and sorry Mani, it is a lift off Ramayana. Of course the story is wafer-thin. It starts with Ragini being kidnapped and Dev pursuing Veera. It's like watching 48 Hours or some Hollywood movie. In the wafer-thin story however, there is a richness of acting and visuals. Dev (Privithiraj) is Rama, Ragini(Aish) is Sita, Veera (Vikram) is Ravana, Prabhu (Singam) is Kumbakarna, Sakkarai (the character) is Vibhusena, Karthik is Hanuman and Vennila (Priyamani) is Soorpanakha. 14 days spent in the forest is 14 years of Rama's banishment. In the epic, Rama asks Sita to do a fire jumping test. In Ravana, he asks her to take a polygraph (lie-detecting) test. 😆
This is not a film for Ramayana faithfuls. It is not for people who love good vs evil epics. This film is about shades of grey. You will not feel sorry for Dev; your sympathies will be for Ravana. Vennila is not the lustful, vengeful asura but rather an extremely charming, cheeky sister who suffers cruelty. (I won't elaborate any further as I don't want to spoil it for those who hadn't seen it). You flinch at many moments, you feel your heart harden at certain times and you cry along with Ragini. You will not do this at any other Tamil movie except Mani's, because it is so unpredictable.
Everyone goes on about how gorgeous the visuals were. I agree, but to be honest, I did not focus on that because for me the characters grabbed me with their intensity, the storyline dragged me along the lush greenery of the forests. Sometimes the dialogue made it difficult for me to follow but some of it was very cryptic -e.g when Veera tells Dev: Your wife is like gold....even when you burn her in fire, she will shine like even brighter." Even the music took a back seat and this was new for me as I just adore ARR.
Aishwarya was an eye-opener. She stood out....and she used her own voice and did a very good job too. Vikram - no need to say anything more. Privithraj was cold and pitiless. And yes, Vikram had a beautiful moustache and Privithiraj was clean-shaven. 😉
Hindi version was crap apparently but again Vikram was rumoured to have done a brilliant job there.
Moral of the story: No one is 100% good, no one is 100% evil.
My rating: 51/2* out of 5.
45