Film Critics Guild issues statement - Page 3

Originally posted by: Briaahna

Why shah tweet

Yeh dekho

https://x.com/moronhumor/status/1998967175986749538

What was the moron ( he claimed to be one in his id itself) on? He is definitely living under a rock and hopefully will remain there for the betterment of the world as we can do with one less person who mocks mental health…

https://www.reddit.com/r/BollyBlindsNGossip/comments/1peupud/deepika_posts_her_review_for_dhurandhar/

Although I didn't know about Anupama's and Sucharita's involvement-nature in the Guild, I missed in the text the advice to write reviews in a more professional way (which both of them don't do also for other movies, imo... at least I got this impression long time ago). One can express a personal leaning towards liking/not liking but simply bashing/hailing a movie isn't reviewing, imo.

Nevertheless, abusing or threatening or enforcing another opinion on someone isn't right in any way, so also not towards critics. Just scold them for unprofessional writing/reviewing... they give ample material for t h a t (like it was mentioned here).

SRK already congratulated in his own way without publishing it... he is friends with all of the main casting (the male ones) and he appreciates such a good work on the thechnical side. But I don't wonder that he reminds his readers that he prefers to openly praise a movie that shows a positive Indian spirit of a story equally based on real events. That's also a part of Pathaan's narration although the story is fictitious... patriotism isn't the same as nationalism... KI tells me:

"Nationalism generally carries a more negative connotation because it often implies an aggressive, exclusionary belief in national superiority, leading to xenophobia, conflict, and intolerance, while patriotism is typically viewed positively as a healthy love and pride for one's country, focused on its well-being and unity, though even patriotism can turn negative if it becomes extreme..."

When SRK was called an anti-nationalist in 2015, he still showed in many ways that he loves his country and is a true patriot. I also love him for that.

.

https://x.com/i/status/1999036434943283521

good reaction

ha ha---critics hai ya big trollers---

-good --this was bound to happen long-

State of our country

https://x.com/reelreptile/status/1999138683572674871?s=46&t=vevCm3I0SGjUvmq-Bjkadg

https://x.com/yearofthekraken/status/1999125084292919609?s=46&t=vevCm3I0SGjUvmq-Bjkadg

Critics don't know there's a guild for them

https://x.com/yogibabaprod/status/1999082828664017230?s=20

https://x.com/yogibabaprod/status/1999115000838021167?s=20

Here is what your favorite YouTuber has to say about this:

https://youtu.be/qdvZzNVT06w?si=5VeY8drgDQ3DyBUK