Would Aman have married Ada or Roshni if things were a lil different? - Page 2

Originally posted by: VSCFan

Now 2 people in this thread think it would be Ada :) Would your answer be still the same if i let yo be the author of Aman's character?

If I was the author of Aman's character then I would look at two situations

one that how his life will be with Adaa

second how his life will be with Roshni

It totally depends on with whom he will be happy with

And this question will get answered only when we get to how will the family dynamics be in both situations

Originally posted by: VSCFan

me too copying my answer here. Now we will continue here.

So thats an examsheet answer! :D

Tell me what you think? What do you feel its should be like?

Lets consider no courtship and things like tht.

I know he is not real and the best person to answer this would be the author of the story but what if you were the author? What would you make him do?

Indeed it is! But then, for me to give an answer I would like to analyse or see few things. You clearly mentioned considering Roshni till library scenes, even till then we got to see Roshni a lot and even you told description of her mother

If you see Ada was hardly explored, and even her family.. though really liked what was showed about her. But they both didn't even have a 5 minute convo.

So will not give an answer here.

It’s too confusing

First family thought ada is ayaana then came to know roshni is ayaan

I don’t think aman was interested in marrying either one of them his main agenda was to keep family safe .

When his mom was almost dying he had to marry roshni

When he was ready to marry ada evil 🦹‍♀️ jinn tricked him

If roshni was from normal family aman or Ammi had no problem

We can’t blame them because society don’t accept these things in real life .

But have to say aman is different with roshni she affects him more than ada .

With ada it’s responsibilities / namesake he chose to talk before marrying ada but roshni is like precious possession for him he is himself and he decides on his own as if she is only born for him he is driving force he never let roshni decide so he decided to marry even though it was for Ammi

Ada and roshni came in his life almost same situation when his life was in danger he was chosen to marry ada

To save his mom he had to marry roshni

Both are same situations but with ada he talked and let her decide but with roshni he took the charge and decided to marry her right away( it’s ownership )

I don’t think he would have married rosh / adda

If Salma was not part of roshni then drama never would have been complicated and he wouldn’t have any problem marrying her

I think in this case he would have definitely married Adaa. Bcoz he makes it so obvious that he never would have married Roshni if not to save his Ammi. And he was kind of OK with marrying Adaa. She comes from a respectable family after all.

Originally posted by: HRfan26

I think in this case he would have definitely married Adaa. Bcoz he makes it so obvious that he never would have married Roshni if not to save his Ammi. And he was kind of OK with marrying Adaa. She comes from a respectable family after all.

Even I agree with your point

Adaa is atleast known to the family unlike Roshni who has only met with Aman and by the look he does get irritated by her.

I think two scenarios would’ve been possible

Firstly - Aman was portrayed as a practical- honest person while his nikkah to Adaa was being undertaken. He informed her (we know that it was Raakh Jinn but he didn’t) of the trouble she was getting into. Going by this Aman , he would’ve got to know both of them before deciding whom he wanted to be with.

Secondly- Aman is loyal to his family and his family is affluent. Affluent families rarely make alliances beneath them in wealth - they go for ones on par with them (most arranged marriages are made between families on equal level we’re wealth is concerned whether upper class or middle class). Going by this Aman would’ve chosen Adaa
as Parveen would most likely have chosen her.

I feel in future we may see some makeover and improvement in Roshni personality also. As Aman is too intellectual in nature and Roshni is too childish ya cute but irritating . She has no idea what danger a Jinn can be . I want some improvement in Roshni personality. Seeing her mom evil nature and double attitude I feel Aman is protecting Roshni from outside world also. In precap also Aman is staring at Roshni with that face which shows he want to like Roshni but cant as she is very childish and that is constantly being shown in her body language and talks , behavior everything. If Aman wants to start conversation with Roshni how can he start with Roshni as i dont feel their mental level is matching at this point.

If Roshni is not Salma adopted daughter still i feel Aman keeps getting irritated with her because of her irrational talks. Even that bakery shopkeeper had fainted. Roshni should now talk less and start getting some knowledge from Aman's library . Lots of books are there 😆

Originally posted by: magicalM

I feel in future we may see some makeover and improvement in Roshni personality also. As Aman is too intellectual in nature and Roshni is too childish ya cute but irritating . She has no idea what danger a Jinn can be . I want some improvement in Roshni personality. Seeing her mom evil nature and double attitude I feel Aman is protecting Roshni from outside world also. In precap also Aman is staring at Roshni with that face which shows he want to like Roshni but cant as she is very childish and that is constantly being shown in her body language and talks , behavior everything. If Aman wants to start conversation with Roshni how can he start with Roshni as i dont feel their mental level is matching at this point.

If Roshni is not Salma adopted daughter still i feel Aman keeps getting irritated with her because of her irrational talks. Even that bakery shopkeeper had fainted. Roshni should now talk less and start getting some knowledge from Aman's library . Lots of books are there 😆

I agree with your point[may I know your name??]

Roshni needs to become more matured so does Aman needs to become more approachable

They cant connect with eachother that well because they cant understand eachother till now

But one thing is similar in both of them that for them their families come first

Originally posted by: Alexia_Wilson

I agree with your point[may I know your name??]

Roshni needs to become more matured so does Aman needs to become more approachable

They cant connect with eachother that well because they cant understand eachother till now

But one thing is similar in both of them that for them their families come first

Me Megha, actually Roshni needs to be a bit mature then only proper conversation can take place between Roshan.

Deleted. I dont know how to delete a post entirely. I always want to post with quote and forget sometimes.