Would Aman have married Ada or Roshni if things were a lil different?

Guys, I have been wondering something about Aman. I find him a complicated man. Just for the sake of argument lets consider the following scenario.

Aman's marriage is not fixed yet. The talks are in progress with Ada and her family. Aman's family thinks Ada might be Ayana. Aman has met Roshni in the same circumstances as depicted until the day they meet in Aman's library. Roshni's mom is not a courtesan. She is some ordinary widow. Now Aman somehow found out that both Ada and Roshni are Ayana.

Who will he marry? What do you guys think goes in Aman's head?

Originally posted by: VSCFan

Guys, I have been wondering something about Aman. I find him a complicated man. Just for the sake of argument lets consider the following scenario.

Aman's marriage is not fixed yet. The talks are in progress with Ada and her family. Aman's family thinks Ada might be Ayana. Aman has met Roshni in the same circumstances as depicted until the day they meet in Aman's library. Roshni's mom is not a courtesan. She is some ordinary widow. Now Aman somehow found out that both Ada and Roshni are Ayana.

Who will he marry? What do you guys think goes in Aman's head?

Ada is not ayana its shown in episode.

I know. I am considering a hypothetical scenario. I want to know what goes in Aman's head. What people think about him? And how much that is different from what i think of him.

Originally posted by: VSCFan

I know. I am considering a hypothetical scenario. I want to know what goes in Aman's head. What people think about him? And how much that is different from what i think of him.

I think if Ada is ayana then he would married her only . As ada is from london and is from respectable family. I think Aman is smitten by Roshni sometimes but her childish behaviour and talkitve nature irritates him like hell .

Copying my reply

A weird situation, both are Ayana .

He will get to know both, like spend time with Ada to understand her as well. Then see, with whom he has a connect.

Originally posted by: VSCFan

Guys, I have been wondering something about Aman. I find him a complicated man. Just for the sake of argument lets consider the following scenario.

Aman's marriage is not fixed yet. The talks are in progress with Ada and her family. Aman's family thinks Ada might be Ayana. Aman has met Roshni in the same circumstances as depicted until the day they meet in Aman's library. Roshni's mom is not a courtesan. She is some ordinary widow. Now Aman somehow found out that both Ada and Roshni are Ayana.

Who will he marry? What do you guys think goes in Aman's head?

I think it will be Adaa because she is known to his family also

And in a way the family may even want a high class daughter in law [atleast his mother] (not insulting anyone)

no one was knowing about Roshni sooo Adaa is the choice considered

If Baazigar has any say then for him it will be maybe Roshni

Last it depends on Aman with whom he wants to spend his life with

Originally posted by: magicalM

I think if Ada is ayana then he would married her only . As ada is from london and is from respectable family. I think Aman is smitten by Roshni sometimes but her childish behaviour and talkitve nature irritates him like hell .

I like your answer. It makes sense. May be thats what he would have done.

As far as I think , I am not still not sure what he would have done. I guess I haven't paid enough attention to him so far. :)

Originally posted by: Madhura..

Copying my reply

A weird situation, both are Ayana .

He will get to know both, like spend time with Ada to understand her as well. Then see, with whom he has a connect.

me too copying my answer here. Now we will continue here.

So thats an examsheet answer! :D

Tell me what you think? What do you feel its should be like?

Lets consider no courtship and things like tht.

I know he is not real and the best person to answer this would be the author of the story but what if you were the author? What would you make him do?

Originally posted by: Alexia_Wilson

I think it will be Adaa because she is known to his family also

And in a way the family may even want a high class daughter in law [atleast his mother] (not insulting anyone)

no one was knowing about Roshni sooo Adaa is the choice considered

If Baazigar has any say then for him it will be maybe Roshni

Last it depends on Aman with whom he wants to spend his life with

Loved your answer, way it should go.

Family background, status, then Baazigar and last is Aman..

Originally posted by: Alexia_Wilson

I think it will be Adaa because she is known to his family also

And in a way the family may even want a high class daughter in law [atleast his mother] (not insulting anyone)

no one was knowing about Roshni sooo Adaa is the choice considered

If Baazigar has any say then for him it will be maybe Roshni

Last it depends on Aman with whom he wants to spend his life with

Now 2 people in this thread think it would be Ada :) Would your answer be still the same if i let yo be the author of Aman's character?