Was Lord Krishna the Hero or the Villain of the Mahabharat ? (Blog) - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

46

Views

5.9k

Users

21

Likes

145

Frequent Posters

Deetha. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: belleza

I agree with some parts of the article. Hmm..or may be with most parts of the article.

Kauravas did Adharm first,hence Krishna too followed it!! Tit for tat right..??What kind of a logic is that? For god's sake he is a god. He shouldn't be following Adharma just because the opponents did.

In my opinion,In the battle of greys he chose to support his legal cousins. Ever heard of nepotism?

Okay.Now let me make it clear. I respect religious sentiments. Whatever written in my post is simply my opinion.


If he actually wants to be a God no need of this Mahasangram 😛 He could have simply killed everyone he wanted to , not letting his family get a scratch.

It's just the way he did. As I already said to clean the dirt you should get ur own hands dirty first and then think of cleaning. And if you don't agree to this a simple example.

A thorn is only removed by a sharp object , just like a thorn??

So being Good won't kill the Evil, So Evil kills Evil.
Deetha. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: mnx12

One Q: What would have been MB like if Krishna wasn't born?


Simple!! We will be living in a land where still may be someone ruling us ruthelessly?
debasree04 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: -Blind.Dance-


If he actually wants to be a God no need of this Mahasangram 😛 He could have simply killed everyone he wanted to , not letting his family get a scratch.

It's just the way he did. As I already said to clean the dirt you should get ur own hands dirty first and then think of cleaning. And if you don't agree to this a simple example.

A thorn is only removed by a sharp object , just like a thorn??

So being Good won't kill the Evil, So Evil kills Evil.



This is 100% truth...poison kills poison...
When one knows Chinese we cant talk in hindi (just an example)
Pamalo thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#44
i can't bear someone telling bad bout the supreme god i hate it bt thnks to u i came 2 noe ppl r there who think like this also.
Edited by Pamalo - 11 years ago
Deetha. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: debasree04


This is 100% truth...poison kills poison...
When one knows Chinese we cant talk in hindi (just an example)


Okay not to offend you!! I agree to the bold line but I found it a bit funny 😆😛
Edited by -Blind.Dance- - 11 years ago
Medha.S thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#46
It is not about what he should have done and shouldn't have done -- more about what those people he was doing it or not doing it to deserved.😆

If i have been unfair and deceitful all my life, kept planning conspiracies to kill people -- In my end time, i would be ashamed to even expect fairness let alone demand it.
Poison can only be cut by poison after all.

And he was born as a human for reason -- if he only reincarnated on earth to be God then he could have just killed the whole opposition with a clap of his hand -- his family and devotees safe and sound.

The reincarnations are here to teach us something -- What you learn from Krishna is that you get what you give and he will e there to give it to you.

The chandal choukadi could be as deceitful and unfair as they wanted -- But Krishna was the ultimate trickster.
rendezvous thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#47
It is true that Shri Krishna was God, he could have killed everyone himself and saved several people who deserved to live but it was very important for Pandavas and their supporters to do this battle on their own so Krishna can spread the following messages thrugh them: 1) Teach people that good always wins against evil. 2) you must always side with truth no matter what personal sacrifies you have to make. 3) Respecting your elders is good but do not bear injustice as this will only encourage people to follow the wrong path and more more such valauable teaching.
A lot of people says he supports pandavs indiscrimately but that's not truth because he reprimaded Draupadi, Arjun, Bhim, etc as needed when they were out of line as well. For ex: He reprimanded Arjun for speaking disrespectifully about Karna, Draupadi for considering her insult was so great that it was okay to just fight, loosing several innocent lives, without giving peace a chance.

Some say Draupadi disrespected Duryodhna and brought about the dice game but be truthful, when you see someone falling your first reaction is to laugh. It's not right but it's human nature. What Duryodhan did was way out of line, bhabhi was and is considered as your mother and to try and disrobe your mother is an unpardonable crime.

Krishna was said to have used trickery in bring about the death of Bhishma, Drona, Karna etc. The point is that they had to die.

Bhisma himself told Yudhisthar that bring a woman in front of me and I will drop my weapons, Shri Krishna had to suggest Sikhandani's name as Mahadev gave Amba this boon that your will be responsible for Bishma's death.

Dristhadum was born to kill Drona. He could never kill drona in a fight so Drona himself taught him and gave him a boon that if circumstances demand then I give you the right to kill me. In fighting against pandavs drona forgot his words so Krishna suggested a way which wil cause Drona to drop his weapons making it easy for dristhadum to kill him.

karna might have been daanveer but he supported his friend blindly to the extend that he called Draupadi a prostitute. He had to be killed as well. Karna was cursed by his teacher Shri Parshuram that his Vidya will leave him at the time he needs it the most, plus Karna helped kill an unarmed Abhimanyu, a 12 year old kid by trick so he did not deserve to die the death of a warrior.

Bhim was bound by his oath to kill Duryodhna by breaking his thigh. Gandhari knew her son is wrong but she still misused her powers to make her son as strong as Vajra so no weapon could kill him. Shri Krishna first tricked duryodhna to ensure his thighs did not become of vajra and then reminded bhim to fulfil his oath.

Everything he did was to protect dharma but despite being a God his still honoured Gandhari's shrap and accepted the full destruction of yadhuvanshi's to fulfil it.

These are not the actions of a Villian.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".