Asha Bhonsle as Zee srgmp judge

Guys I just saw an advertisement in zee tv of saregamapa where Asha Bhonsle will be the judge. A sigh of relief by us all. The future of Zee srgmp was in trouble but with the presence of Asha Tai i hope we will get to see a great show and listen to some good quality music on the show.

anu

Hi a_b

These days, A lot of people hate himesh & a bandwagon of same is running.

I'm not favoring himesh but what I miss here is the general respect of the art.

If you say, future of SRGMP was in danger with himesh in it...That means a lot!

So I jus wanna know why exactly you hate himesh so much!

Dont come out with an answer like :bcoz every1 hates him or obviously he is bad etc...

If you can pinpoint technical reason, it would be great!

BTW: Thanks for the post dear!

(My opinion 4 himesh: An avg. singer but

deserving & higly talented music composer in terms of

techniques used in his tracks & textures of his tracks)

Good point Vijay - you seem quite practical. I'm glad not all of us here are emotional fools 😉

I think its good to stick to the topic here - which says Asha is coming in as a judge... 😊 It would be interesting to see how she would be judging the participants... Because, she is the one, who has seen and endorsed all kinds of music and should not have any kind of bias!

But, its surprising that she will come is as a judge so early in the game!

Originally posted by: Vijey Umang

Hi a_b

These days, A lot of people hate himesh & a bandwagon of same is running.

I'm not favoring himesh but what I miss here is the general respect of the art.

If you say, future of SRGMP was in danger with himesh in it...That means a lot!

So I jus wanna know why exactly you hate himesh so much!

Dont come out with an answer like :bcoz every1 hates him or obviously he is bad etc...

If you can pinpoint technical reason, it would be great!

BTW: Thanks for the post dear!

(My opinion 4 himesh: An avg. singer but

deserving & higly talented music composer in terms of

techniques used in his tracks & textures of his tracks)

Editted my post but not because of your opinion.I dont like anyone is my opinion and singing from nose is certainly not quality singing. I am sure many at IF will agree with me that Himesh is not even an average singer. He may be a good music director but then he should do what he is best at. Why try something which he is not capable of.This is my point of view and i believe i have full right to present my point of view. Dint mean to hurt anyone.

Originally posted by: *Jaya*

I think its good to stick to the topic here - which says Asha is coming in as a judge... 😊 It would be interesting to see how she would be judging the participants... Because, she is the one, who has seen and endorsed all kinds of music and should not have any kind of bias!

But, its surprising that she will come is as a judge so early in the game!

thanx di for coming back to the topic yes it is surprising to see Asha ji as a judge so early i believe the format of the show is changed a bit because earlier i believe there were only the mentors and no judges

Originally posted by: a_b

thanx di for coming back to the topic yes it is surprising to see Asha ji as a judge so early i believe the format of the show is changed a bit because earlier i believe there were only the mentors and no judges

We had judges for the earlier rounds in C2005 as well - like Alka Yagnik, Kumar Sanu, Jagjit Singh, Daler Mehndi, Shiv-Hari, among others. They had to job of basically cutting down the field from 28 to 10.

But yes, Asha ji is a bigger name than all of them. However, they all came in pairs - is Asha ji going to judge alone?

Originally posted by: Vijey Umang

Hi a_b

These days, A lot of people hate himesh & a bandwagon of same is running.

I'm not favoring himesh but what I miss here is the general respect of the art.

If you say, future of SRGMP was in danger with himesh in it...That means a lot!

So I jus wanna know why exactly you hate himesh so much!

Dont come out with an answer like :bcoz every1 hates him or obviously he is bad etc...

If you can pinpoint technical reason, it would be great!

BTW: Thanks for the post dear!

(My opinion 4 himesh: An avg. singer but

deserving & higly talented music composer in terms of

techniques used in his tracks & textures of his tracks)

Asha Ji!! Is the best. It is a great pleasure to see her in the judges seat. Also HR was mentioned in the post if this was a "New Flash" post about Asha Ji on the judges panel it should have been left at that only.

Please i would like hear a few good "technical" faults as well. Voice / style of a singer is a personal opinion so dont use that and state only facts please. I am......................... waiting. 😉

Originally posted by: shadyhtown

We had judges for the earlier rounds in C2005 as well - like Alka Yagnik, Kumar Sanu, Jagjit Singh, Daler Mehndi, Shiv-Hari, among others. They had to job of basically cutting down the field from 28 to 10.

But yes, Asha ji is a bigger name than all of them. However, they all came in pairs - is Asha ji going to judge alone?

Cant say that i guess so because they showed only Ashaji in the advertisement

Originally posted by: a_b

Cant say that i guess so because they showed only Ashaji in the advertisement

If they want to make it extra spicy they should bring on Lataji too😉

ah what fun it will be😆

honestly I dont think Ashaji should come to the show, no matter what she does/how decent she is, people will be throwing c**p at her, nobody gets spared, and I would really hate to see it, if you dont beleive me come back after the show ends and then tell me