Patchy beginnning: First episode review - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

70

Views

6.7k

Users

30

Likes

154

Frequent Posters

AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: LadyMcbeth


Did we need to have Nidhi stand 14th all over India in the MBBS exam if she was so opposed to passing it in the first place? Had they just shown her to have passed the exam, it would've sufficed. Her extreme dislike at being a doctor in first place, just does not justify her passing the exam with flying colors. It is extremely difficult to pass the exams in the first place and if she did it without studying then she must've been a genius or a prodigy. Because without passion, one cannot simply stand 14th in the MBBS exams. It was sooo OTT ... 😆




LOL it was creative license😆...but I actually liked that scene in the epi...Nidhi being so pissed off while her dad was trying to hide his smile😆...even Anjie was cute in this bit. I guess it was more about the concept than the 'reality' of passing a MBBS with a great rank or something.

If you wanna talk OTT, there was FAR worse stuff in the epi...I found the Ashutosh scene more OTT...he ripped a freakin CURTAIN, dude😆...I wish they'd kinda eased into showing Ashutosh's feelings about the house *sigh*...I loved the thehraav they showed with Ahmer...those solitary walks he used to take in the garden or brooding by himself...they aren't being able to get that effect across in KTLK
Ruky07 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: Ruky07




😆 destiny yes i do believe in this concept but i want to be in her shoes because i try so so hard sometimes to achieve what want but it does not according to plan. i think i need to change my prespective am going to fail then i might achieve even higher grades 😛 sheer luck
14 rank ! OMD streching it to far she must have a one of kind brain structure

Edited by Ruky07 - 14 years ago

Ruky07 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#33
dnt need to so formal no need for the thank you
LadyMcbeth thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#34

Originally posted by: nureat01



LOL it was creative license😆...but I actually liked that scene in the epi...Nidhi being so pissed off while her dad was trying to hide his smile😆...even Anjie was cute in this bit. I guess it was more about the concept than the 'reality' of passing a MBBS with a great rank or something.

If you wanna talk OTT, there was FAR worse stuff in the epi...I found the Ashutosh scene more OTT...he ripped a freakin😆 CURTAIN, dude...I wish they'd kinda eased into showing Ashutosh's feelings about the house *sigh*...I loved the thehraav they showed with Ahmer...those solitary walks he used to take in the garden or brooding by himself...they aren't being able to get that effect across in KTLK


red - My only grouse with that scene is - they could've just shown that she's passed the exams. All over India 14th aney ki kya zaroorat thi? I couldn't connect with that part simply because if she didn't care to be a doctor, there was no need to show her stand 14th. Kuch bhi bolo, I JUST couldn't get past that scene. I 100% agree with Ruky07 (sorry don't know your name) ... Kisi ki kismat itni bhi nahi chamakti hai. Kuch jyada hi creative license use kiya director ne...

blue - Exactly! That was the part, where he flared up his nostrils and ripped the curtain. 😆 I was like ... woah dude! Kuch jyada hi OTT tha!
Edited by LadyMcbeth - 14 years ago
chammak_challo thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#35
I am really happy to see Kritz back on the screen - I like her family part but the first part of the epi was a bit depressing😕
Ruky07 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: chammak_challo

I am really happy to see Kritz back on the screen - I like her family part but the first part of the epi was a bit depressing😕



😆 😆did it depress u that much ?
Mru_bee thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: nureat01

I've recently watched DK and that's still fresh in my mind but still I watched the first epi of KTLK with an open mind.

First things first...the beginning was JARRING...HORRIBLE choice of bg music for the flashback of Ashutosh's past...sounded like a an animal dying or something whatever was supposed to be the voice of a kid singing...and I found the scene a bit rushed...as if they were just cutting from frame to frame to quickly show Ashutosh's past without letting the audience FEEL his emotions or the depth of his attachment to the house and his baba...dialogues weren't that great either. MB is a great actor but I don't feel the production values are doing him much justice.

hahaha @ the bg music! It was jarring, it did sound like an animal dying! hahaha. They dived right into the melodramatic wail(?) and anguish (with curtains being ripped?), is this a short series? Looks like one 😛😆 .

Secondly...Nidhi and family...not bad...some scenes are straight lifts from DK like Nidhi walking along the wall to get to Anji's house...the bulb outside Anji's dad's office...the actors cast are pretty similar features wise to the DK cast...

I liked the scene where Nidhi is trying to touch her dad's feet but he wouldn't let her...the dadi bua is kinda OTT...but then the original in DK was loud too...the father is nicely cast and his scenes with Nidhi are good too but again, I get a sense overall of rushing with the epi...they don't really let you soak in the characters and keep jumping from one to the next in quick succession.

For a long time, I was wondering whether it was the entrance exam results she was worried about or the final exams result! And also, it is kinda OTT that someone wouldn't know how well they did in the exam and actually think they might have failed! Nidhi is okaish right now. The father is the better of the cast, the rest are ok.

Another flashback I found rushed was Ashutosh and the lawyer telling him the house has been bequeathed to someone else...and it was unnecessarily dramatic too with showing him ripping the curtain😕😕...

Anji-Nidhi are sweet together...

The cook is a very random character.

Is the cook, the indianised version of Dr. Iqbal? I hope not...

Overall I feel they tried to stuff too much into the first episode and they need to fix the pacing...this isn't a weekly like DK was and they need to fix the flow of the epis...seems like too much is happening in one epi only. The backgrounds of the characters need to be established better.

So overall, I didn't like the bg music much barring the few bits where they played the 'kuch toh hai zaroor' portions of the title song...and the direction is poor...nothing very impressive...production values could have been better.

I agree with this, and though I shouldn't compare, this was a much better first episode than the other series, I was looking forward to as well (the trp earner!). And I really hope they dont overdose on the title song in every episode..



-- Mru
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#38
@Mru: LOL even I wondered if this is a short series given how the epi felt kinda rushed :S ahh well.

I actually just happened to catch the epi on TV and liked the Ashutosh bits more now...lol...maybe the first print I watched online was pretty bad and didn't give a clearer sense but I liked MB in the opening scene this time around...I ignored the besura kid singing in the bg music...lol

TV quality makes a difference I guess...lol...

Agree with you about the title song too...hope they don't overdose on it like BALH ppl do...but I really do like that 'kuch toh hai zaroor' line...beautifully sung.
medhapp thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#39
personally I did not have much high expectations from the show especially since I am a die hard fan of the original serial DK..so I was happy with the way the first episode turned out...nothing great compared to DK but definitely better than the current breed of TV serials...they are so slow and they just drag the story line..I liked the pace of the episode it was to the point... in the first episode it self they showed the first meeting between the main leads instead of dragging it like it happens in other serial through various scenes for almost a week where they just always pass each other without ever meeting...At this pace and with some twists in the storyline the serial may end in a year but that would be nice ...bringing it to a logical end in timely manner instead of just dragging the serial and then all of us complaining on this forum about how boring the serial has become...all in all Iiked the episode..better than the current crap of other serials.
intruderfast thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#40

well ashutosh bits were nice ,mohnish is doing terrific job

kritz is ok , but her character is slightly ott , anyways things might pick up from today

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".