Three years pass and the story leaps into ugly, miserable territory! - Page 8

Created

Last reply

Replies

129

Views

13.6k

Users

41

Likes

382

Frequent Posters

deejagi thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#71
Mansi sorry to Say this but even i dont think we have got 3 years leap. The war with Uday Singh was already on the floor even before the birth of kids. Even the war on Amer was waged to suppress the Rajputs and after marriage he was able to think little logically and now has lost all his sense. May be the talk between MS and US failed and hence this war and the time referred were in that context. May be they may give Salim directly after this war and ehen he returned he may get to hear the news of Jodha's pregnancy.
one more thing is that jodha is still wearing the same discoloured pink and green dress. Surely they cant lost for 3 years. Jokes apart, Jalal knows he is illogical and still has the same love for Jodha but as he is being haunted that his love for her costed their child, He is not ready to show is weak side and covering it with his Rudeness. He is grabbing the opportunity to escape the haunting memories of his oids death and hence this instant war declaration.
We still have scope for Ruqu to get exposed after this war. Lets wait for that with hopes.
Edited by deejagi - 11 years ago
ILTHBEB thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#72
in whole scenario one n only Jodha whose character is kindling luminously. despite remaining guiltiness in herself of Jodha, Jala forcefully imposed sense of guilt in Jodha's mind n made her quite lonely but Jodha didn't crumble down, she stood still with her self respect, stood for jalal acc to her promise that in ups n downs of life she would always remain with Jalal. Hats of jodha.
If this brutal behavior of Jalal is his own manner to vent his agony then i would like to say he selfishly has used only Jodha as his forefront.
Edited by ILTHBEB - 11 years ago
deejagi thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#73
Guys let us not take his words to Jodha about him telling her to be with Husein seriously as any man in distress will do the same when he realizes that his love or lust of the night cost a life. Even he knew those words he said in the night about you should have been with Husein were shallow as he had sent words for her service with Moti and that was the clear reason Moti asked Jodha when she returned in the night, that she was supposed to spend the night with her husband that night. Its just that he could not live with that guilt, he was trying to wash out that feeling in the rain water and when Jodha approached him and tried to console him that he should not blame himself for that situation, he just tried to off shoulder it on her. Jodha was clearly aware of that and that was the reason she didn't fall apart with his words and tried to follow him. Otherwise, if his words had the intensity of the blame, she would have collapsed then and there. So lets not take each and every word with the face value.
vinitaj27 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#74
Someone called zee abt the three yr leap n they called back to confirm that no leap has taken place n the account on twitter of the writer could be fake or misused. They seem to have preponed the chittor war.
skanda12 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#75

Originally posted by: Akdhaparijatluv


Mansi I feel cheated and got betrayed yday as a viewer for adoring this love story til now... Leave abt it's epicness its not even ordinary love story where lovers stick to each other thru thick n thin not blaming each other... I hv vented out enuf yday n today I got shocking news from my frz that three years leap took place yday ... JJ don't even talk in these three years so it's finally evil won over good as ruk succeeded in seperating JJ for three years which she wanted... Cvs confirmed three year leap it seems and may b soon we get two years kid Salim track as auditions were gng on...just now saw Salima begin with cute kid of two or three years... I guess he is Salim so track got strtd... And this cv also mentioned that til diwali JJ wil b seperated... Mansi wen ruk is the one with whom jalal dimt talk for years for some reason n here they made NR n showed Jallu blaming her (heart breaking ) and JJ dint talk for these three years... Their love dint even last for one year... Cursing cvs lik hell

I just called Zee myself. they have confirmed that there is no 3-year leap from their side. So they have used natakiya rupanthar to prepone Chittor War. So Jo-Ja separation of 3 years is not the story they are following. Zee said on or before Diwali they will both reconcile and be close again. Also Ruq pardaphash is definite, he has confirmed many times with balaji he says!
skanda12 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#76

Originally posted by: ..PT..

Very nice write up.

Fairly new to forum, love your posts.
Have been reading your old episode analyses. What a wonderful n thorough job you have done. Kudos to u.

I was initially very sad to see ja accusing jo n pushing her away.
I admired Jo's resilience n her undying love even in the face of rejection n cruel accusations from ja.
I liked how Jo did not break down n become too depressed or Run away from problems, but still had the spunk to come n confront ja about the ethicality of killing so many people in the name of angst, n pain. (I still can't accept Ektas justification of ja's mass murdering 30,0000 in chitoor in the name of jalal becoming jallad due to kids death),
Jo did not act like the guilty n hide from jas anger, I liked how she went to him and tried to reason with him,
she was just giving him time to recover from the loss, having rejected her, her love, the solace n comfort in her arms, n sharing the misery, ja was hurting even more,

Why did he do it? Accuse n reject her?
In addition to what others have said abt guilt n pain n hurting I wld like to add,
Ja cld have supported Jo, accepting their mutual mistake n guilt, comforted each other n gotten over the loss n pain relatively easily,
Ja cld have just blamed himself, his failure as a father n husband, Jo wld have comforted him n accepted the loss n gotten over it,

But he accused ja n hurt her n rejected her so she wldnt come to him to comfort him, n make him forget his loss n pain
for he wanted to hold on to his pain, holding on to the pain is holding on to his kids ,
Letting go of the pain n healing is letting go of his kids n slowly forgetting his kids.
He didn't want to heal, he didn't want to forget, instead he wanted to not let his sons go,
only when he is ready to accept that they r gone, only when he is ready to face the loss, his anger, n guilt will go n he can mourn, n heal, n go on with his life.
I am not justifying his actions.

Really liked the thilak scene.
When ja shouted that only the person who is supposed to do the rasam has to do it, I loved it for multiple reasons,
Finally he shouted at Ruks,(however silly the reason maybe, or even it was meant for her) he shouted at her, hoorah!
maybe he was trying to bend Jo to his will
Even after overtly pushing her off, he still wanted her to send him off with blessings
MYbe he was saying butt off Ruks, not your place, u stay where u r supposed to be, don't interfere
Maybe he is saying as a king I have my duties

Felt like there's still hope. If Jo had broken down wld have hated ja. Since Jo is strong n fighting for her love n seems to understand ja, I have decided to wait n watch what ja is going to do before giving up on JA or feel too upset about it.

P.s. Infant mortality was so high in those days, I guess people just attributed it to fate n will of god. Don't think people went berserk, they mourned but didn't loose thier heads like ja. They probably were more like Jo. Cvs threw in the love making, n guilt trip between Jajo, to move the story, n show war jalal.

Thanks for reading my posts. That line I've marked in blue is very very good!
skanda12 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#77

Originally posted by: preetgurti



Btw he said three years leap happened and diwali will be jodha akbar back together episode

I just spoke to Zee. he said he verified with balaji, they have not shown a leap, they have used naatakiya rupanthar to "prepone" the Chittor War soon after twins death. Also he said Jo-Ja will reconcile on or before Diwali and Ruq pardaphash is definite and confirmed by balaji to him!
Edited by skanda12 - 11 years ago
skanda12 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#78

Originally posted by: karishma.s

Mansi, to say I'm disgusted would be an understatement. I understand that he is feeling guilty, but putting the blame on jodha was callousness and cowardly. Anyways ,mansi, the three year leap has not happened as the soul talk said time passed. Jalal said three years in respect of the rajwanshis. I seriously want jodha to leave Agra as clearly no one deserves her. Nor her amer family not that disgusting Agra harem. I so want jodha to tell jalal what all she had to undergo cause of him and his backstabbing relatives. First his badi ammi , then his childhood friend BEK, and after standing by and loving him and accepting these villains she gets a curse for her kids and finally blamed for her kids death by her own husband? He needs to get some home truths straight. Now he will go for war, seeing the damage he caused he will realise that nothing and no amount of barbarism can get his kids back. I think the cvs are trying to repeat what Ashoka felt after the war of kalinga. People will curse him further. Jodha's words are going to haunt him mansi. He will become like a dead body and a person who nobody will want to come near. During the war he will realise or someone will tell him that the very love he blamed for taking his kids life was responsible for bringing them into this world in the first place. Then he will go crying to jodha, but mansi, point is I think jodha by that time would have completely hardened and would not want to see his face. See till now she feels that his heart is hurting and she knows that some essence of that Herat is there. After she gets to know what he did in the war, she will turn cold to him. That is how I want it to be. I want her to say that she has nothing to do with him any more. She should tell him to go to his cheat come lying come best friend, his BEK. See we very well know that they will end up together, but in no way I want jodha pregancy at this time. As Gem said it will look fake. Unless they show him understand that it was his love that made his kids come in this world in the first place. I fully expect jodha to be disgusted after this war.

Karishma, read Sunny's post on this thread. It is very refreshingly different, and it will help change your perspective. Worth a read!
surochitadutta thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#79
You can't even imagine how desperately I was waiting for your post... I really thought maybe your post will be able to make me feel better... But Mansi Di aaj even your post did not have any effect on me... Something inside me Is broken beyond repair (related to JA)... The LOVE STORY DIED YESTERDAY..

I know Jalal is in deep agony but that does not give him the right to put the entire blame on the woman who has just lost her sons.. As if Hassan and Hussain were his kids only and Jodha was nothing to the twins... He was equally responsible for that night... Jalal is pretending as if he was a Sadhu and Jodha came to him with the intention of bedding him and seduced him for that... I am feeling dejected, hurt, cheated... That dialogue of the Jalal's when he said just because his innocent kids were killed ruthlessly, even he would kill innocent Rajvanshis... Was so crass and disgusting... Why did they even bother showing Chittor track when they won't be able to give a justified reason for that... If they can show Jodha being sidelined and punished for no fault of hers in this Natakiya Rupantar then they could have very well skipped Chittor Massacre...


Whatever they show now in the show will have no effect on me now... As I have put up with all kinds of crap tracks just because the they have kept the Love Story intact but now when they have killed the love story I have nothing more to hope or expect from this Eakta's versions of Jodha Akbar... Whatever they want to dish out they can as I am least bothered... If not for Rajat and Paridhi I would have stopped watching the forever... Now I so badly want this show to be shut down... Jitni der yeh show chalegi untahi Akbar the great ka naam kharab hoga...


RIP AKBAR AND MUZ and LONG LIVE THEIR BEAUTIFUL LOVE STORY...



skanda12 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#80

Originally posted by: mm250314

mansi your post was full of positivity ...you have described the episode beautifully ...we are really disgusted with the way the cv's have given us the most shocking twist ...jalal had vented out his guilt ridden pain upon jodha !!!!!!!!...to justify the cruelty of chittor war the cv's have laid it's blame upon the twin's death and a return of a jallad jalal with no dil, no mohabbat for anyone !!!... as jalal had found his dil due to jodha they thought that only in this manner the war massacre can be reasonably explained ... in typical serial type drama the leads have been separated ... separation is ok but why jalal acted like that ? ...i was reminded of a story in which the hero ,due to an accident of his child , blamed his wife saying that as he had to blame someone due to his misplaced guilt for letting the accident happen he can only blame her coz she ,his wife ,is closest to his heart and not the nearby pedestrians coz they meant nothing to him ...and in that story his guilt persisted for 10 years . is a similiar thing shown here?... .i don't know if 3 years have passed but i believe that whenever a leap is introduced a voice over or a small strip is given to portray it so i am not sure about 3 year leap ... and moreover in a nr timelines can be altered ... keeping very low expectations i am still curious to see what cv's will show now ...it is a serial and not a true account of real incidents in akbar's life and we should not spoil our moods due to the sadist writings by the makers ... . . . coming to the episode , the first scene was very poignant in showing the deepest pain of a father . as usual rajat was splendid ...in the rain scene i think that the one sentence given to jalal was a piece of sadist writing ...it was shocking to hear him say that ...i can't understand why there was the need to place the blame upon jodha ? except to make it more dramatic for some viewers . both were deeply hurt ,whereas jodha was strong and calm jalal was displaying his cruel self ...but jodha was true to her character , she was very strong and not a single word was uttered by her in protest she was guilty herself ...upon herself she could tolerate any blame but when she realized that the war will not place akbar in a good light and innocents will be left to die she had proceeded to voice her protest ...she knew that jalal was angry with her but still she was not defeated ... the soul talk was symbolic to indicate that their souls are still entwined and so we can hope to see a beautiful love story ! ...i liked the way he looked at jodha while discussing with maan singh ...jalal was shattered by his son's loss and his failure to protect them and he had just poured his frustrations upon jodha . i think that only jodha understands him and inspite of her own pain and guilt she was very mature in handling him and sha had not shouted back at him, she had not gone to amer after hussein'd death ... the tilak scene was very good , both displayed their feelings through their expressions and eyes ..., he was excellent in showing ruqu her place ---ruqu can never take jodha's place and he had not embraced ruqu coz of his separation from jodha ...he was slightly jolted to see jodha's blood and a little disoriented afterwards when he had turned back away from jodha and others ...i have hope that still jodha exists in jalal's heart , he may sideline her or blame her but he still loves jodha and jodha has not stopped loving him inspite of his imperfections ...if cv's are a little smart they can show the resurfacing of their love very aesthetically ... let us see how they will proceed in this regard ...

Yes the tilak scene was a redeemer to an extent. But let's see. the part I liked was when he shouted to Ruq to shut up.!😆😆😆😆😆

Related Topics

Jodha Akbar thumbnail

Posted by: IshqHaiWoEhsaas · 3 months ago

On June 18, 2013, Jodha Akbar 's very first episode was telecasted. (And in all honesty, I think it changed my life. Sparing a moment today to...

Expand â–¼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".