Every one has its own perspective.Creativity is subjective i found her great in Geet and MB that is my perception and majority of ppl who watched her in Geet and mb .For me it was good and for you it was not great that is ur pov .I don't think her all roles are same as i hv watched her all shows.Muskaan was comic role ,Geet was bubbly and later become mature .Geet has many shades she was bubbly,emotional and brave too who fought her whole family for sake of her child.She even fought maan for her self respect.Madhu was mature who stood her grounds against arrogant RK and even went to revenge rk but later gave up becoz cvs gave up to fan demands and got them married.In ETr2 she fought battle against evil grand dadi queen .Pardes was one show where i didn't like her acting becoz story and character was so bad.Her character was quiet different in all shows.And about crying which actress on itv fon't cry even so called maya use to cry after comitting crimes .You think her best is over for me her best is yet to come and itv roles are very plain female characters with all mahaanata and bhashan so for female actress to get challenging roles in the itv is near to impossible becoz itv females all about crying and sacrificing.Now coming to same acting and dialogue delievery srk will deliever dialogues and cry with his own style na .He can't deliever dialogue like nana patekar.I mean every actor has its own style and way they can't change expressions becoz they will smile ,laugh ,smirk and cry like they do in real life they can't change their smiles ,laughs or dialogue delievery but yeah different character give them challange but itv lacks in challenging characters as you urself agree on that.DD took role of nandini becoz obviously she wanted to play grey role where nandini is selfish and non guilty but writer spoiled nandini beyond repair what can actor can do.I find only two actresses good in these current tv actresses that dd and jenny both are average actresses with own limitations but they are much much better than other ott actresses like gopi bahu hence they are overhyped because currently they are best available on tv.Vaise when person become famous ppl hv habit of calling them overrated .Atleast DD is known by her original name by viewers unlike actresses who are just recognized by their characters only.Ppl know her as DD as geet madhu gaytri how many actresses achieve where ppl recognize your original name along with character names on itv.This is becoz mass was able to connect to her as well her acting. Your or this forum opinion is not universal many find her quiet good so you see its just way of seeing thing differently.I respect your opinion i will agree to disagree with you.@mockingbird: I didn't watch Madhubala but I saw Geet, Ek tha Raja and pardes. Though in geet, she was okay in romantic and you know how pushing against the wall abuse manhandling wala romance. I said okay but contrary to fans, I didnt see anything great. She was just okay. But then in the other three serials, nothing extra ordinary. I find her a decent actress but very overated for me because her acting is the same and it's boring to see especially for someone who saw three serials of her. She uses same style, shivering/lip shaking isnt new, her pout and delivery are same and hasn't changed.
I would say that she must take versatile role, but then again in tellywood, there isn't much scope, it's dormat bahus all over again. Since some of her fans said she won't take black/grey stuff, then obviously people will be bored of her. Besides, she played a Rani, then pardes she played pocessed woman with spirit 😉, so she got the chance to play versatile characters which other people doesnt get but she did not use that chance to level up her acting. She seems stuck.I didnt see her as muskaan but i'm assuming after muskaan was geet and that period was her optimum point where according to fans she did great but after that, she had a sinking graph. For me she was average before now she is below average. Seeing her in silsila doesn't look like she is some senior. She looks like a newbie, who smirk and was smiling secretly when Maunal was fightingThis is purely my pov but I feel that DD has reached her peak performance. her max level so she cannot do more better.