16th September
The second day of the second elimination round for the third batchRecap- The second elimination round for the third group started on Thursday where Vineet and Himani got green cards.
The judges are Kavita Krishnamurthy and OP Nayyar and the themi is songs from 2000-2005
Today's contestants-
Ujjaini and Sharib- Jatin Lalit
Irfan- Ismail Darbar
Joyeeta- Himesh Reshamaiya
The first contestant for the day was Irfan who sang Ae chand mujhe chandani ki kasam from Tera Jadoo Chal Gaya-
Good, controlled singing with lot of feel but whenever I listen to him, I think there is something missing. Any way he sang the whole song without any hitch. Very composed.
Mentors-
AS -Beautiful song and beautiful rendetion. Very good
JL- Though our contestants are up against irfan, we should give credit where it is due and irfan truly performed very well. Jatin said that if I was the judge, I would have definitely picked him.
Himesh- Kept on adding superlatives… in one work- "superb"
Ujjaini- Mause ki adla badli from Black (I must admit that I have not heard this song carefully earlier. But beautiful, difficult song- performed brilliantly. The song had lot of classical touch- Indian and western and ujjaini did very well. She sang with lot of emotion- perfect singing is the word. Surprise element in JL's gharana
Mentors-
Ismail- He said that he was lucky that he got to comment after such a beautiful song…and the singing was wonderful.
Aadesh- Aadesh said that with this kind of singing ujjaini can be a threat to nihira.
Himesh- Wonderful singing and said that ujjaini is a strong contender and will reach the finals.
Jatin lalit said that the whole credit for this song is to ujjaini because they did not quite agree to her song selection but she was sure that this song was different and will impress. And she prepared it herself.
Sharib- Mann ki lagan from Paap…sang well …lot of power – I thought he did slipped in couple of places and also his lower notes were not as clear but very powerful singing with good variation. Not trying to copy the original singer. Very good on higher notes
Mentors-
AS- Aadesh found the singing very good. He said that sharib had got him in dhun..which is the real sufiana singing...only few people can actually do like nusrat...
JL- Lalit said that today- one after the other all are performing brilliantly and it might be very difficult to judge them. Kavita K said that given a choice she would go away from here and make one of the mentors sit here. Jatin said that today both the boys have sung so well that even if one of them is shown red card, he will not let that participant leave…he will send 2000sms to save that person. They said that since everybody has been performing so good, they hoped that joyeeta will also continue in the same way.
Himesh- He was also impressed by sharif's performance and said that therse is some magic here today and he is sure that joyeeta will also keep this on.
Ismail- He found the singing very good and all of them were of the opinion that this has been probably the only day when all the contestants have performed so well.
Joyeeta- Piya tora kaisa abhimaan from Raincoat……the only thing I can say is much much better than the last performances…but still some thing lacking…..the throw was not good…though the classical notes were handled well…overall I did not find it very impressive.
Mentors-
Aadesh- He said that he found the performance ok…because he is a filmi music person and he considers it from that angle. Ismail interrupted saying that he uses classical stuff in his music and he found this good…….big fight started where we were shown that the judges did not know where to look…shaan trying to pacify these two…
The results were announced…..as all of you know by now, there are two rounds of singing in this charan but I think the fight ensured that there were no further rounds. The mentors were missing during the time when results were announced. This time I am writing the result because I think it won't make too much of a difference and has been also taken because the second round could not be held. All four were shown green cards. In my opinion ujjaini and sharib deserved it.
This is the big fight between aadesh and ismail which we have been hearing about…after which aadesh refused to come for the shoot. Now the news going round is that he has agreed because his students will suffer otherwise.