Is Dilshad doing wrong? - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

39

Views

2.6k

Users

21

Likes

129

Frequent Posters

beekay1 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: Ankita.M



Asad has given his full life to his mother, to his family, to the women in his life. Has Asad ever been selfish ever? LOL you gotta be kidding me saying he is wrapped up in his own world. Dilshad was out of the house when Asad and Zoya were bickering. But when his Ammi comes into the picture in any scene at any moment, Asad's entire attention goes to her, his concerns lie in her.

@bold: Yes, Asad has given his all for the ones he loves, no doubt about it. But that does not give him the right to decide their happiness too. If you watch the scene again, Asad is pulling Zoya's leg. He does look at Dilshad but he does not see her unhappiness. Now did Asad do anything wrong here. No Not At all. (One of the reasons, I love QH is because they depict more of the real life situations). Now the way Asad and Zoya are very normal. Nothing wrong about it. If Asad was not engrossed in Zoya, it would have been strange.

Dilshad was scared because she knows she is about to do something questionable.

It is 'questionable' from whose POV. Dilshad is scared of Asad's hatred for his father. Dilshad is scared of hurting Asad. Dilshad knows that Asad will not see her POV because of this. To her it is not 'questionable'.

As viewers, we know that Ayaan and Zoya's marriage is invalid. But does characters in the serial know? Everyone of them think it is valid. Yet Asad walked with someone else's wife. Even though Asad forced Zoya to sign the papers, Zoya forgave Asad and made the decision to walk out of SM. Similarly why can't Dilshad do so too.

The same Dilshad slapped her own son in front of the entire world without thinking that her son wouldn't do anything as cheap as what had been made out to be, she spoke for Zoya, she spoke up against Asad whenever he was wrong. But the same Dilshad falters today not because she is scared of her own son, but because she knows what she is doing is not the best decision she has made.

Dilshad slapped Asad because Asad admitted he was guilty. When Zoya told her about what happened, Dilshad did not believe Zoya until she saw Asad. If Asad had opened his mouth and told Dilshad, he was not guilty she would not have slapped Asad. So don't blame her for that.
She is not scared of Asad's anger but of his hatred for his father and knowing that her decision will hurt Asad.

The question here is, that at what cost is Dilshad choosing her happiness? She has been abandoned by a man 17 years ago, left with nothing but misery and two beautiful but helpless children. She lived a life of dignity by earning every penny with the help of the son who shouldered her and helped her at that age like her parent more than child. And today she is choosing to go with a man who didn't think twice before leaving her and does not think twice before telling her to come live with his second wife under the same roof? 🤢 Asad is not being selfish he is trying to do the right here, by safeguarding his mother from going through another set of insults. He is fighting for her and not himself.

Dilshad is not a child. So when she made the choice, she knows what she is getting herself in for. Forgiveness is a virtue that one of the toughest to have. Forgiving a person does make one lose dignity, in fact it enhances dignity.

Dilshad need to make that choice.
Najma saw beyond Dilshad's smile, That's why she walked into SM knowing that she can get insulted there. But she did it for her mom. She saw her mother's tears.
Sometimes being over-protective is not good. Asad need to see beyond Dilshad's smiles. If Dilshad is prepared to go through another set of insults, Asad should let her. The main reason being Asad knows very well that Dilshad still loves Rashid a lot no matter what.




P.S. enjoying the discussion 😃





.Kiran. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: beekay1



P.S. enjoying the discussion 😃






Asad and Zoya's situation is entirely different. First of all, they don't have any responsibility towards anyone neither do they have children. And when they made their sacrifices, they didn't exactly abandon each other or betray each other. Though Zoya was angry at Asad but she did it for him willingly. It was just a compromise to save someone's life. Asad didn't just leave Zoya and never looked back for her. He told her he'll take her back and came to meet her. He didn't abandon her. & He did take her back. He stood up for his love unlike Rashid Ahmed Khan. And Asad didn't sleep with another woman and then came with his child from another woman back to Zoya and then left her again. Did he now?
FarhaadkiMahi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#33
i beg differ @beekey
yes asad force zoya to sign nikahnama but if somthing happen to nikhat that time zoya never forgive herself because it her stupidity.this divorce guilt nothing infront of nikhat sucide guilt .i think zoya should thank asad that he free her from that guilt n support through all track.
asya love built on scarafice
while radil love built in zainab grave.
i really proud of asad.
BTS_07 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#34
is dilshaad wrong ? you cant help who your heart loves but who does your heart love more ? obviously for dilshaad her love for rashid surpasses anything ! she is definitely wrong in going back to rashid even if he is dying or she is alone ! dilshaad can love him as her husband but as the father of her children this man is worse than pathetic ! a father is supposed to protect his children , give them happiness , love and make their dreams come true ! but he has done nothing ! he abandoned them , left them with sadness and asad lived his childhood struggling to help his mother make a better life ! when rashid had the audacity to say dilshaad is his wife 1st before asads mother , it broke my heart ! bcoz it proves he would rather be a husband 1st before a father ! dilshaad as a wife may be making the right decision but as a mother to asad and najma - I would never look in that mans direction ever again ! and then rashid says whether you like it or not im taking your mother ! and you wonder y asad hates him ? rashid did the same thing 17 years agao ! he got asad attached to Ayaan and he ripped him away from asad ! this proves rashid hasn't changed at all and dilshaad is a fool for going back to him !
RandomSquared thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: zara1ksg

is dilshaad wrong ? you cant help who your heart loves but who does your heart love more ? obviously for dilshaad her love for rashid surpasses anything ! she is definitely wrong in going back to rashid even if he is dying or she is alone ! dilshaad can love him as her husband but as the father of her children this man is worse than pathetic ! a father is supposed to protect his children , give them happiness , love and make their dreams come true ! but he has done nothing ! he abandoned them , left them with sadness and asad lived his childhood struggling to help his mother make a better life ! when rashid had the audacity to say dilshaad is his wife 1st before asads mother , it broke my heart ! bcoz it proves he would rather be a husband 1st before a father ! dilshaad as a wife may be making the right decision but as a mother to asad and najma - I would never look in that mans direction ever again ! and then rashid says whether you like it or not im taking your mother ! and you wonder y asad hates him ? rashid did the same thing 17 years agao ! he got asad attached to Ayaan and he ripped him away from asad ! this proves rashid hasn't changed at all and dilshaad is a fool for going back to him !


exactly, what hurt the most was the lack of compassion they had in what they were doing and how it was hurting their child. I guess Dilshad loves Rashid more than Asad.
crazyforfun thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#36
Dilshad is wrong and right in my opinion...
right,
because she has seen loneliness and has a right to be happy with her love;now that both her kids are settled she can put her happiness first.
Wrong,
because she has said yes to staying in SM.If rashid loves her,he should stand up for her rights and take her to live with him in his own house not SM.The idea of sharing husband is repulsive to any self-respecting woman.She should have conveyed this to Rashid and seen his reaction and then decided if he was worthy of her love.
As we know,Rashid is spineless and selfish and cant give happiness to anyone.So she should not go against her son for this kind of a man,how much ever she loves Rashid
sheilasandhu thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: VashH

@ sheilasandhu:
Congratulations !! My Dear. ..
See you have changed colors .
Awesome. !!! 😉


Thanks darling and i am sure you gonna be next😉
sheilasandhu thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#38

Originally posted by: beekay1



P.S. enjoying the discussion 😃


@ Bold ... To forgive is divine but to repeat a similar mistake or to fall in to a pit hole when you know it is there is stupidity. She can forgive Rashid but she need not accept him back at the expense of hurting her children who were her pillar of strength and who stood by her and with her during her most trying times which were caused by the same idiotic Slime ball called Rashid.

If Rashid really loved her than even after he left her and the kids for whatever reasons he could have provided for them on the sly but NO he was busy sleeping in a mansion on king size bed making more babies with a Bimbo than worry about the so call love of his life. Load of CRAP . The only reason he is doing it is for himself cause he does not want to die feeling guilty of abandoning Dilshad. If he only knew he has just made things worse for himself in terms of guilt.

I sincerely hope Asad would do something to give him a major heart attack that either leaves him paralyse or kills him. ASAD TURN NEGATIVE FAST PLEASE







lovely_lady thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#39
I'm new to this show, but from what I've seen, I agree.
I think that chess game today spoke volumes. Especially the way zoya (i think) said that he was worried about one piece that he forgot about the other. And thats it, he was engrossed in zoya and forgot about dilshad.

and i don't think Dilshad is necessarily wrong in wanting some happiness, a partner, for herself. But i think she was wrong when it came to talking and discussing this with asad. and i also think that rashid is not the man for her, despite what they say.

honestly speaking, i think that this track was kind of needed, especially to bring some closure to dilshad. from the beginning of the show, its shown how dilshad pines for rashid, despite her professing to remain away from him. before, he left her, for no reason at all. she's always had the 'what-ifs' in her head. now with this track, she'll get to kind of experience all the 'what-ifs' and if my prediction is right, she'll get closure. she'll realize that rashid isn't the man he used to be. that he isn't the guy for her. she can't depend on him like zoya does to asad or even how najma does to imran. and i think that's when she'll finally break away from his 'saya.'

but if she ends up staying with him, then idk.

part of me feels like asad needs to get over his anger at his dad and forgive him. asad carries that burden daily and its not healthy. but then another part of me feels like rashid doesn't deserve as ad's forgiveness. idk. i actually have hope in the CVs :)
Go4welkin thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#40
Dilshad has right to be happy but what is the definition of happiness? It is not that she found her soulmate and she is going to live with him in their love nest peacefully for the rest of her life. Here we are talking about Dilshad leaving her own home where she has all comforts, dignity, authority, a loving son and a caring daughter in law and going to a hostile environment where she is not welcomed by other inmates except for Rashid. If Rashid is really longing for Dilshad then he should have taken a seperate house so that Dilshad had her dignity intact and won't have to co exist with Razia and Guffur. Dilshad won't be happy in real sense because she won't feel at home in SM because she has to deal with akwardness of living with Shirin, Razia and Gaffur under the same roof. Also, she cant totally ignore impact of her decision on her children, who equally suffered due to Rashid's wrong choices in life.
Dilshad is not choosing any happiness, It is more like sacrificing her dignity, disrespecting her son's love and attachment just to tend to dying wish of her so called husband on humanitarian grounds that are too complex and beyond comprehension of mortals. Yes, she is absolutely wrong to choose Rashid because what is being offered by Rashid to her is not happiness at any level and infact it comes across as a punishment that Dilshad is willingly accepting due to her blind love.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".