
CHAPTER 02 - A MERE WOMAN
The morning Khushi broke the clay pot, she had been trying to read and walk at the same time, which her mother had told her no fewer than eleven times was how civilized people became casualties.
The book was a slim volume of Sihr-ul-Bayan that she had borrowed, without asking, from her father's study three days ago and had been carrying around the house ever since, reading it in doorways and on staircases and apparently now on the kitchen wall where the pot of soaked lentils had been left by the neighbor's wife for the evening's shami kebabs, in perfect safety until she arrived. She had been turning a page which had required both hands. The pink embroidered dupatta had done the rest.
The pot went over the low wall and splattered the yellow lentils with the resigned air of things that had no say in the matter.
Khushi looked down into the courtyard below, then at the book, still open in her hands at the offending page. The verse looked back at her, unhelpfully beautiful.
"Khushi."
Her mother's voice came from the inner room. Not a shout or a scream. Sakeena Farooqui had long ago discovered that loudness was wasted on her daughter, it only made her contrite in the short term, which was not the same as careful in the long term. What worked, mildly, was the particular quality of stillness she could place inside her daughter's name. Like setting down something heavy on a table. Here. Look at this. Look at what you have done.
Khushi looked over the wall at the lentils.
"It slipped," she muttered, hiding the book behind her back.
Sakeena appeared in the doorway, adjusting her dupatta over her head. Her fine-boned face was the kind that had been beautiful at twenty and had become, over the years, something better, more earned, the beauty of a woman who had thought hard about things and it showed in the fine lines of her forehead. She looked at Khushi, who had her arms behind her back, then at the lentils below.
"Ammi," she began. "I was almost at the end of the — "
"Was the end of the masnavi worth the lentils?"
Khushi considered this with more genuine seriousness than the situation perhaps demanded. "It's a very good masnavi. The best of Mir's work one could argue."
Sakeena looked at her daughter for a moment and sighed, this daughter of hers who had been dropping, spilling, upending, and occasionally breaking things her entire life in the service of whatever had captured her attention in the preceding moment, and who had never once done it carelessly, which was the thing that made it impossible to be truly angry about. Everything Khushi broke, she broke while reaching for something. Sakeena had long ago decided this was either her greatest flaw or her finest quality and that the difference between the two would be determined by what the world chose to do with her.
"Put the book down," she said, already reaching for the jar of lentils on the shelf above. "And come and help me with the meal."
_________
Faizabad woke differently from other cities.
It did not announce itself with the air of grand tehzeeb, like Lucknow, which Khushi had visited once as a child, not quite the raw river-life of smaller towns. A city of in-betweens and pieces. First the smell of the river, then the sound of the ghats, then the azan that began at four in the morning from the old mosque at the lane's end and did not fully stop until well after the city had decided it was day.
The Farooqui house sat on a lane that was wide enough for a cart and a half, in the older quarter near the western ghat. It was a two-storey house of faded ochre plaster, with a wooden balcony that had been repaired so many times it had become, structurally speaking, a philosophical position on repair itself. The ground floor was half-home, half-business where Shafiq Ali Farooqui's import trade occupied the front two rooms, the shelves stacked with ledgers and bolts of cloth and the particular organized chaos of a man who kept everything in his head and very little of it where anyone else could find it.
Upstairs was where the family lived: Sakeena's kitchen that always smelled of methi and cardamom, Khushi's room with its view of the lane, and the small prayer room with a framed calligraphy of the religious verse that Khushi had, without telling anyone, positioned slightly toward the window so the light could find the gold ink in the lettering at the right hour, she had explained once, when caught adjusting it. Sakeena had looked at this explanation for a long moment and then let it stand.
The conversation between mother and daughter happened, as their important conversations usually did, in the kitchen.
Not because either of them planned it that way — it was simply that the kitchen was where Sakeena spent her mornings and Khushi orbited her mornings, and the combination of warmth and occupation and the comfortable noise of the mohalla outside produced, reliably, a quality of candor that more formal settings did not.
Sakeena was grinding spices with her marble mortar and pestle, her back half-turned, when she said. "A letter came from Lucknow."
She said it without preamble, it was how she said important things, simply placing them in the room when the room was ready.
Khushi had been waiting for this sentence since the previous evening, when she had noticed the quality of her father's silence at dinner, that of a man who has been given something and is still deciding where to put it. She set down her copper cup to measure the flour. "From the Malik household?"
"The vakeel's letter, yes. Your father read it last night." Sakeena set down the grinding stone. "Twice."
"Well, what did it say?"
"That the household has considered the proposal with interest. That the family has been reviewed — " a brief movement at the corner of her mouth — "and found adequate. That they propose a period of acquaintance before the formal confirmation is made." She turned to face Khushi. "And that they are aware Abbas has pending business with the Malik court and would be honored to receive the Farooqui family as their guests during his visit."
Khushi was quiet for a moment. Outside, the mohalla was in usual morning chaos of the kabab seller's first fire, a child being called in from the lane, the azan's final call dissolving into the ordinary sounds of the day beginning.
"Did they know that I was to accompany Abbas bhai to the city?" she asked.
Sakeena's expression confirmed it without requiring words. The invitation had the Daadi begum's quality, too precisely timed, too conveniently arranged to have arrived through the vakeel alone. She had heard about Abbas's dealings and had engineered an occasion. She wants to see you went unsaid both between them and was entirely understood.
Khushi looked at her hands with flour coating her palms and dusted them. She thought, as she had been thinking, in fragments, since the proposal had first arrived three weeks ago, about what this meant. Not in the abstract. In the specific, practical terms that her father would have been calculating and that she was capable of calculating too, even if no one had asked her to.
The Farooqui family was comfortable. Her father's trade was steady, his reputation good, his standing in Faizabad respected. But comfortable was not the same as secure, and the trade was subject to the seasons and the roads and the shifting alliances of merchant networks that her father managed with patience and intelligence and a great deal of goodwill that could, she understood, be called in at any moment by people who had more weight than goodwill.
A match with the Malik family, one of the most significant noble houses in all of Awadh, was not simply a personal arrangement. It was a transaction of a kind her father's world understood very well. Stability in exchange for a daughter. The family's standing elevated. Future dealings protected. Her cousin brothers would negotiate from a different position in a world that understood exactly what the Malik name meant.
She knew this. She had always known it. She was not naive about the machinery of arranged marriages or about her own position within it.
What she also knew from the two previous proposals and their conclusions, from the landlord's son from Barabanki with his incurious eyes, from the merchant from Jaunpur who had addressed every remark to her father rather than to her as though she were a piece of furniture being discussed for purchase — was that knowing the machinery existed and being at peace with being fed through it were different things. She had refused both previous proposals, and her father had allowed the refusing, and she was aware this was not a freedom that would extend indefinitely.
She was twenty-two. The world's patience with a woman's opinions about her own marriage had a specific and well-documented expiry date.
And, her hands trembled at the thought, it wasn't a match with just any member of the Malik family. It was with the Nawab himself. An honor for generations.
"Ammi," she whispered.
"Mm."
"Will anyone ask me?" She said it plainly, without heat, without the performance of grievance. Simply as a question about the mechanics of this engineered thing. "At the end of this... when the family sits together to confirm or decline, will my opinion be sought?"
Sakeena took her to the small table adjacent to the kitchen and sat down across from her.
Cupping the round face in her weathered hands, she said. "Your father will ask you. Genuinely, not as a formality. What you tell him will matter to him." She held Khushi's gaze with the directness of a woman who has made a decision to be honest when dishonesty would be kinder in the short term. "I cannot promise more than that. The decision involves more people than you and more considerations than your comfort. That is the truth of it."
Mr. and Mrs. Farooqui had only one child. Alas, the child was a daughter, a fact the world had never quite allowed them to forget, whispered about behind their backs and, with the casual cruelty of people who consider themselves merely practical, said plainly to their faces often enough. A daughter did not carry a name forward, did not inherit a trade, did not sit across a negotiating table and build what her father had built into something larger. A daughter was, in the accounting of the world they lived in, a liability dressed in the temporary clothing of a blessing.
Khushi had grown up understanding this the way you understand the walls of a house you were born it, of something that has always been true and will continue to be true regardless of your feelings about it. And so this — a nawab's proposal, a household of this standing, a match that would open doors for her father's trade and her cousins' futures and the entire network of Farooqui commerce that ran quietly through the region — this was the thing a daughter could do. The thing that transformed the liability into an asset, the burden into a bridge. Her refusal, if it came, would not simply be her own, it would land on all of them disastrously, on her father's carefully maintained standing, on Abbas's contract, on her mother's dignified silence in the face of twenty two years of sideways remarks about sons. She had no illusions about the weight of that.
Khushi covered her mother's hands with hers and tried to receive her words with an attempted smile. There was no ounce of bitterness in it, she had no use for bitterness, it was a quality that required more energy than it returned.
"Then I will give them something worth considering," she finally said.
Sakeena looked at her daughter for a long moment. Then she leaned forward and kissed her forehead and cheeks.
"Try," she said, blinking the moisture from her eyes. "not to drop anything while you're there."
_________
She thought about it for the rest of the day, not anxiously though she could not stop the restless tapping of her foot, but with the focused attention she gave to everything she had decided was worth examining properly. She thought about what she knew and what she did not know.
She knew the broad facts of the Malik household from her father's history with it, and from the mohalla's ambient knowledge of Lucknowi affairs that filtered into Faizabad through traders and travelers. She knew that Ibrahim Malik, the previous nawab, had been a man of enormous reputation and a privately complicated history. She knew that her father had done business with him and had been failed by him, not crudely, not with confrontation, but with silence where a reply should have been, with the door closed before you had finished your sentence.
She knew the son was not the father. This was what everyone said. She was aware that everyone saying it did not make it true, but she was also aware that the people who said it. Abbas, the traders who came through Faizabad, the general tone of the city's opinion of Arnav Malik, said it with relief of people who have been comparing and have found the comparison favorable. That was more than a rumor. That was a pattern.
She did not know what he was like. Not in the ordinary hours. Not in the spaces where character was actually visible, the morning before the formality, the evening after the duty, the corridor between the public rooms. She would not know this from any account she had been given. She would only know it from being there and only if he permitted.
Which was, she thought, precisely why she should still be going.
Not because Daadi Begum had engineered the visit. Not because Abbas had convenient business in Lucknow. Not because the Farooqui family's standing would benefit from the match, which it would. Not because her opinion might not carry weight at the end of the process.
Because she had been given a door — a real one, however arranged, however the engineering behind it had been conducted and she was not the kind of woman who stood in front of real doors and did not open them.
She went to find her father.
_________
Shafiq Ali Farooqui was in his study, his spectacles on top of his head, a letter in his hand that he did not put down when she knocked on the open wooden door.
"Come in," he said, without looking up. "Close it."
She did, and sat across from him in the chair that had been her chair for as long as there had been important conversations in this room, the one slightly closer to the window, where the river was audible on quiet mornings.
He looked at her over the top of the letter. Then he set it face-down on the desk.
"Your mother told you," he asked. "About the vakeel's letter, yes?"
She simply nodded and watched him clean his spectacles then put them back on. These were the stages of his processing, she had learned them over years like how one learn the rhythms of a city one have always lived in, not by study but by accumulation.
"There is also this," he said, and turned the letter face-up and pushed it toward her.
She looked down at it. The handwriting was formal, the Urdu script of someone who had been taught by a careful hand and had spent years making it his own. Not the vakeel's hand. Someone else's.
"He wrote to me himself," her father remarked. "Before the vakeel's formal letter was even drafted. His own hand." He paused. "I have been sitting with it since yesterday."
She scanned it quickly. It was a brief letter comprising three paragraphs, formal and correct, the language of someone who had chosen each word with the awareness that the words would be read by someone who knew how to read between them. There was acknowledgment of the proposal, expression of the Malik household's serious interest and then the request that the Farooqui family consider the visit as an occasion for genuine acquaintance rather than mere formality.
This was the second time the visit had been mentioned, she noted to herself.
And then the last line, which she read twice.
I am aware of the history between our families and the distance it has placed between us. I write in the hope that this letter marks not the continuation of that distance but its conclusion, that what begins here begins, as all things worth beginning, from a different page.
When she looked up from the paper, her father was watching her quietly.
"He knows about the letters," she commented. "The ones you sent that were not answered."
"Oh, he knows." Shafiq folded his hands on the desk. "Which means either someone told him, or he found them himself when the estate was settled after his father's death, or he looked for them specifically." He paused. "A man who looks for the evidence of his father's failures and then writes to the person his father failed... that is a particular kind of man."
"And you believe him?"
"I believe the letter," her father said carefully. "A man can write a true letter and still be something other than what the letter suggests. I am not naive about this." He began folding the letter and placed it in the top drawer. "I am also not naive about the difference between a man who writes nothing and a man who writes this."
Khushi was quiet for a moment and drummed her fingers against the table.
"You are not coming with us," she said. "For the visit."
"Abbas will go. He knows the court, he knows the trade, he will represent the family well." Her father looked away from her. "It's a matter of a few days and he has met the nawab twice, in the business negotiations. His read of the man is, well, it is worth having from someone who has seen him in a different register than the formal rishta process."
She looked at her father's spectacles on top of his head, at the ink-stained fingers, at the man who had kept the unanswered letters in his drawer for twenty years and had, this week, received a reply that was ten years too late and had chosen to believe it anyway.
"Abba," she said, holding her breath.
He looked up.
"When I come back," she said. "Whatever I find... you will listen?"
"I have always listened to you, dear." he said. Simply. As a fact.
"I know," she said, still her stomach churned. Everything was happening all at once. "I only wanted to say it before I go."
He picked up his spectacles and cleaned them one more time, which was not necessary, and announced. "Abbas leaves in a week. Begin your preparations right away."
She nodded and stood, reaching out a hand as she asked. "May I keep it?"
He opened the drawer and handed it to her without a word.
She closed her fingers around the folded paper carefully and put it in the pocket of her kurta.
_________
Abbas arrived the same evening.
He was thirty-two, broad through the shoulders, with an open face that inspired immediate confidence and a laugh that arrived before the joke had fully landed, which should have been annoying and somehow wasn't. He had been Khushi's favorite cousin since she was six years old and had climbed the mango tree in the old family house on a dare and gotten stuck, and Abbas had climbed up after her without being asked and gotten stuck alongside her, and they had sat up there together for forty minutes until the gardener noticed the children with mango stained mouths and loud laughter and got the ladder, an incident which became the foundation of a solid friendship.
He was also, beneath the easy manner, a serious businessman, who had learned that affability was not the opposite of shrewdness but its most effective disguise. His textile dealings with the Malik court had been in negotiation for the better part of a year, significant enough that the Malik vakeel had made three trips to Faizabad and Abbas had made two to Lucknow before the terms were close to agreement.
Nargis was with him, as she always was when the journey was long. She was a small, composed woman who had made her peace with the world's tendency toward disruption and navigated it with complete equanimity. She loved Khushi with the slightly exhausted affection of someone who has spent years being fond of a person who was quite regularly disruptive.
Abbas found her in the kitchen the morning after his arrival, standing at the window with the book open in one hand and a cup of tea going cold in the other, looking at the lane below with a peculiar expression.
He leaned against the doorframe and watched her for a moment.
"You've read that same page four times," he said. "Your reading comprehension seems to be going down in your old age."
"I haven't." She huffed, looking away from the window as he came in and helped himself to the tea she had forgotten. She closed the book with a snap. "I was thinking. An ability not granted to everyone clearly."
"I gathered." He sat at the table with her tea, entirely untroubled by having taken it. "Why are you so nervous?"
"I told you I was thinking— "
"Deep philosophical thoughts and all, yes." He waved this away. "What is it?"
"It is nothing," she mumbled, sitting from across him.
"Excellent," he said. "Tell me about the nothing."
"I am wondering," she said finally, unable to banter with him as she usually would. "whether he will find me..." she paused, looking for the right word."...excessive."
Abbas was quiet and pressed his lips together as if suppressing something that was going to come out regardless.
"Excessive," he said.
"I have been told, on more than one occasion, that I am — "
"By whom?"
"The tutor who resigned."
"The tutor who resigned," Abbas said, his tone losing a degree of playfulness. "was a man who found his own opinions excessive. He was not a reliable measure." He waved his hand as if to dismiss the notion. "Khushi, we are talking about one of the most significant man in all of Awadh. He has been managing the court since he was twenty-two." He paused. "I do not think he is going to be undone by a mere woman."
The mere woman comment instantly raised two pairs of eyebrows. One of which belonged to his own wife.
"I also ask questions." Khushi said, interrupting when he tried to uselessly convey what he actually meant, to Nargis, rather than her, to whom he has directed the insult.
"What?" He looked at her. "Well, yes."
"Direct ones."
"I am aware."
"And I have opinions about — "
"Khushi." He leaned forward. "I sat across a negotiating table from this man twice. I watched him listen and respond to things that were actually said rather than the convoluted version of them." He paused. "He is not going to find you excessive. He is going to find you... " He stopped, appeared to consider the right word, and then produced it with the satisfaction of a scholar with a revelation. "Clarifying!"
She looked at Nargis, who shrugged, then at her cousin.
"Clarifying?"
"Like a good itr, you see." he eagerly explained. "Unexpectedly strong. Stays longer than anticipated. Changes the quality of the room." He picked up her cold tea again and made a face. "Also occasionally responsible for making people slightly lightheaded, but we will address that concern if it arises."
She threw her book at him and hoped it would hit him in the face.
He caught it, of course he caught it, he had been catching things she threw at him since they were children, and set it on the table as if he expected exactly this outcome.
Nargis threaded her arm with Khushi's and looked at her husband. "I think what my dear husband is trying to simply say is that an extraordinary man will require an extraordinary woman by his side." She patted her hand. "Remember, Khushi, it is a privilege to be undone by the force of a mere woman." She leaned back, arched her brow at Abbas as if daring her husband to contradict, who in response, nodded wisely without a word. "Did you know the sheermal in Lucknow is said to be an art itself. The saffron bread, baked in a clay oven with heavenly smell? " She concluded with complete sincerity as if the food in the new city was also legitimate and important consideration.
Abbas looked at his wife with the expression of a man has been married long enough to find this entirely charming.
At long last, since the day began with lentils and letters, Khushi felt the twisting and turning feeling inside her loosen, fractionally, into something more like the warmth that only appeared among the people she loved dearly.
_________
What do you make of Farooqui family members? Your thoughts are most appreciated.
Happy 15th anniversary of the show in advance.
Edited by mistlefoe - a day ago