Did you notice the marks on Preeta's arm? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

3.1k

Users

4

Likes

20

Frequent Posters

TheM5393 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: _Runa_

Asking all that questions you are trying to find logic. Logically yeh show bahut illogical hai😆 Sorry, I don't have answers for your questions. As I said I go with a flow. Because if I don't I just stop watching. Bas.

They show one day something and another day they show something opposite. They always do that. One day Rishabh doesn't believe Preeta and asks her do not come again ever. And then he comes to her wedding and says 'I always was on your side and always trusted you'. He said something like this, don't remember exact words. It was hypocrisy for me to see Rishab saying that. But I let it go because it will be many more times in the future too. That's how they write dialogues. So, yes, for me nobody is perfect in this show.

I can understand your anxiety. Karan not believing Preeta was the most illogical and irritating thing that happened in the show. We all know why they did it.

I don't hate Karan but I hate what he's done. I know he will suffer for this and he will pay. It's enough for me to continue watching and do not see him as a real person in real life. And I am not even a Preeran fan🙈

Rishabh ko side mei rakkho WO PREETA KA PATI NAHI HAI !!!! Wo SHERLYN ka pati hai!!! Uska patta kat chuka hai. Wo bechara halal ho gaya hai. Uska future shur se hi andhakar tha ab toh kuch bacha bhi nahi. 🤣

Khair lekin tumne sawal jab uthaya hai toh I feel as thou, because I have been bashing Karan and his actions left, right and centre I might as well 'go with the flow' and defend Rishabh as well. (BTW, NOT A RISHABH FAN, just prefer RishTa over Preeran). 😉

I agree Rishabh at Preeta's wedding alters 'threshold' did say something along the line of-

'Maine jabh bhi aapse kaha hai ke mai aap par vishwas karta hu to maine hamesha uss vishwas ko nibhaya hai, lekin aap ke vishwas pe terms hai conditions hai'

I also agree with the fact that when Preeta reached the 'hospital' to meet Mahesh Uncle, Rishabh asked her to leave, and when Preeta asked him that he had said that he believes every word that Preeta has said, Rishabh replied something along the line of-

'Haan main karta tha aap par vishwas, par ab nahi karta'.

And I know this sounds hypocritical BUT the difference here lies in NOT what he had said at the 'hospital' and then at the 'threshold', but what he said to Shrishty at the police station. Rishabh not only felt guilty for NOT supporting Preeta but he ALSO apologised to Shrishty for NOT supporting Preeta. Now this may sound like a very thin chain of logic, but it does in essence prove his words 'right' (only barely, and kind of theoretical) that his 'vishwas' on Preeta was (and I will like to put emphasis on the word 'was' at this stage) 'unconditional'.

P.S I STRONGLY believe that Rishabh is going to be the better husband in this show by a very WIDE MARGIN (but to Sherlyn) hence there is no point in bringing in Rishabh in this picture, considering the fact that he is out hit wicket (Or in football terminology he has already done an own goal sort of situation). The point I was trying to make when ranting about Karan was the fact that 'if' he is THE HERO of your show, why is his character being portrayed in such a fashion? AND even after being portrayed in such fashion WHY ARE people with proper intellectual capabilities STILL supporting him????

_Runa_ thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: TheM5393

Rishabh ko side mei rakkho WO PREETA KA PATI NAHI HAI !!!! Wo SHERLYN ka pati hai!!! Uska patta kat chuka hai. Wo bechara halal ho gaya hai. Uska future shur se hi andhakar tha ab toh kuch bacha bhi nahi. 

Khair lekin tumne sawal jab uthaya hai toh I feel as thou, because I have been bashing Karan and his actions left, right and centre I might as well 'go with the flow' and defend Rishabh as well. (BTW, NOT A RISHABH FAN, just prefer RishTa over Preeran). 

I agree Rishabh at Preeta's wedding alters 'threshold' did say something along the line of-

'Maine jabh bhi aapse kaha hai ke mai aap par vishwas karta hu to maine hamesha uss vishwas ko nibhaya hai, lekin aap ke vishwas pe terms hai conditions hai'

I also agree with the fact that when Preeta reached the 'hospital' to meet Mahesh Uncle, Rishabh asked her to leave, and when Preeta asked him that he had said that he believes every word that Preeta has said, Rishabh replied something along the line of-

'Haan main karta tha aap par vishwas, par ab nahi karta'.

And I know this sounds hypocritical BUT the difference here lies in NOT what he had said at the 'hospital' and then at the 'threshold', but what he said to Shrishty at the police station. Rishabh not only felt guilty for NOT supporting Preeta but he ALSO apologised to Shrishty for NOT supporting Preeta. Now this may sound like a very thin chain of logic, but it does in essence prove his words 'right' (only barely, and kind of theoretical) that his 'vishwas' on Preeta was (and I will like to put emphasis on the word 'was' at this stage) 'unconditional'.

P.S I STRONGLY believe that Rishabh is going to be the better husband in this show by a very WIDE MARGIN (but to Sherlyn) hence there is no point in bringing in Rishabh in this picture, considering the fact that he is out hit wicket (Or in football terminology he has already done an own goal sort of situation). The point I was trying to make when ranting about Karan was the fact that 'if' he is THE HERO of your show, why is his character being portrayed in such a fashion? AND even after being portrayed in such fashion WHY ARE people with proper intellectual capabilities STILL supporting him????

I think I didn't explain properly, sorry. Talking about Rishabh was just an example. Not for a comparison Karan-Rishabh. And definitely not for bashing him. So you don't need to defend Rishabh😁 I don't like some layers of his character but it doesn't make me see him as a bad person. I know he's a good guy. Don't make me to like him. I don't hate him at all 😆 Just remembered about that dialogue and gave an example of an inconstancy of characters and their words. Didn't mean to bash him. It could be Karan, Rakhi or Sarla as well as an example 😁

@bold - I don't have an answer you want🤕 You keep going to ask me but I can't answer for the people you are talking about. I tried to show you another perspective, my perspective as a viewer. I can't talk for others. I accepted Preeran as a pair from the very beginning. Because for me it was always very obvious that they are going to be leads. Have never thought about Rishta as a leading pair🤷 So for me their marriage was just the question of time. Now I just keep watching for what the writers have for us to continue the story. If it would be interesting I will keep watching. If not then I'll stop.

And the most interesting thing for me to see how all of them (Karan, Preeta, Rishabh, Sherleen, Prithvi and Mahira(!) ) will interact within the circumstances they have now. It's not like I want Preeta to go to honeymoon with Karan tomorrow. I am not dying to see them together or their suhaag raat😂 So if you want to have an answer from a die hard Preeran fan you should ask him😄 I like the story even if it has some cruel and unfair moments. And along with that I am trying to analyze different characters from their POV. It's not easy given the logic of the show is illogical 🤣

Actually I would never watch this show if the leads were goody-goody. It's boring. People are not perfect. People do a lot of mistakes. When there is no problem then there is no story to watch. I really can't imagine what the writers can show us for 1000+ episodes if the Rishta happens. They would have to change Rishabh's character into someone like Karan/Abhi to develop the story. Then we would bash Rishabh and bless Karan😄

As a viewer I prefer to analyze, to bash, to sympathize, to love, to hate not a perfect protagonist or any other character of the story than a perfect one. It's not boring. See how interesting discussion we have together due to Karan's betrayal 😄

The forum is very active this days thanks to Karan and his galati😁

Jokes apart the turn the story took now gave us a lot of thoughts to share. I like it.

P.S. Just for clarifying 😄 It doesn't mean I see Karan as the perfect husband🙈

TheM5393 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: _Runa_

I think I didn't explain properly, sorry. Talking about Rishabh was just an example. Not for a comparison Karan-Rishabh. And definitely not for bashing him. So you don't need to defend Rishabh😁 I don't like some layers of his character but it doesn't make me see him as a bad person. I know he's a good guy. Don't make me to like him. I don't hate him at all 😆 Just remembered about that dialogue and gave an example of an inconstancy of characters and their words. Didn't mean to bash him. It could be Karan, Rakhi or Sarla as well as an example 😁

@bold - I don't have an answer you want🤕 You keep going to ask me but I can't answer for the people you are talking about. I tried to show you another perspective, my perspective as a viewer. I can't talk for others. I accepted Preeran as a pair from the very beginning. Because for me it was always very obvious that they are going to be leads. Have never thought about Rishta as a leading pair🤷 So for me their marriage was just the question of time. Now I just keep watching for what the writers have for us to continue the story. If it would be interesting I will keep watching. If not then I'll stop.

And the most interesting thing for me to see how all of them (Karan, Preeta, Rishabh, Sherleen, Prithvi and Mahira(!) ) will interact within the circumstances they have now. It's not like I want Preeta to go to honeymoon with Karan tomorrow. I am not dying to see them together or their suhaag raat😂 So if you want to have an answer from a die hard Preeran fan you should ask him😄 I like the story even if it has some cruel and unfair moments. And along with that I am trying to analyze different characters from their POV. It's not easy given the logic of the show is illogical 🤣

Actually I would never watch this show if the leads were goody-goody. It's boring. People are not perfect. People do a lot of mistakes. When there is no problem then there is no story to watch. I really can't imagine what the writers can show us for 1000+ episodes if the Rishta happens. They would have to change Rishabh's character into someone like Karan/Abhi to develop the story. Then we would bash Rishabh and bless Karan😄

As a viewer I prefer to analyze, to bash, to sympathize, to love, to hate not a perfect protagonist or any other character of the story than a perfect one. It's not boring. See how interesting discussion we have together due to Karan's betrayal 😄

The forum is very active this days thanks to Karan and his galati😁

Jokes apart the turn the story took now gave us a lot of thoughts to share. I like it.

P.S. Just for clarifying 😄 It doesn't mean I see Karan as the perfect husband🙈

Aree behen, tumko koi explanation dene ki zaroorat nahi hai, my questions were more generally directed towards the world than anyone in particular. Khair, the fact that Karan and Preeta were the lead couple of the show was made abundantly clear not in the show but more with the way how Zee and the promo makers treated Karan and Rishabh as characters.

HOWEVER, I must also add the fact that I have never seen any EK show give this much actual plot significance to a third-wheel character. (up until recently in the new KZK) because the first Bajaj in the old KZK was important, but Ronit Roy was ALSO playing Mihir Virani in KSBKT so he would disappear/die more often in that KZK than you would think actually possible.

Anyway, now that I HAVE really thought about this, I feel as thou there was definitely a SIGNIFICANT reason as to why they showed Karan behaving AS DISRESPECTFULLY as he did.

Edited by TheM5393 - 5 years ago
_Runa_ thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: TheM5393

Aree behen, tumko koi explanation dene ki zaroorat nahi hai, my questions were more generally directed towards the world than anyone in particular. Khair, the fact that Karan and Preeta were the lead couple of the show was made abundantly clear not in the show but more with the way how Zee and the promo makers treated Karan and Rishabh as characters.

HOWEVER, I must also add the fact that I have never seen any EK show give this much actual plot significance to a third-wheel character. (up until recently in the new KZK) because the first Bajaj in the old KZK was important, but Ronit Roy was ALSO playing Mihir Virani in KSBKT so he would disappear/die more often in that KZK than you would think actually possible.

Anyway, now that I HAVE really thought about this, I feel as thou there was definitely a SIGNIFICANT reason as to why they showed Karan behaving AS DISRESPECTFULLY as he did.

@bold - I don't know what is KZK☺️ I know only KKB and KDB😆 But I get what you mean. Yes, this is actually the thing I like.

And they give an importance not only a third-wheel but others characters too. All the actors have their good parts to play. This is the difference I see between KKB and KDB. KKB was always about Abhigya and Tanu (till the 20 years leap). Others characters were for a furniture most of the time😕 And here we have a bunch of good actors brilliantly playing their roles. I appreciate this about the show. I like even Sherleen and Prithvi, never skipped their parts!🙈😂

TheM5393 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: _Runa_

@bold - I don't know what is KZK☺️ I know only KKB and KDB😆 But I get what you mean. Yes, this is actually the thing I like.

And they give an importance not only a third-wheel but others characters too. All the actors have their good parts to play. This is the difference I see between KKB and KDB. KKB was always about Abhigya and Tanu (till the 20 years leap). Others characters were for a furniture most of the time😕 And here we have a bunch of good actors brilliantly playing their roles. I appreciate this about the show. I like even Sherleen and Prithvi, never skipped their parts!🙈😂

KZK- Kasautii Zindagii Kay!!!!! - Ekta's most successful Romance drama!! (THE SHOW WHERE ALL HER ORIGINALITY WAS LEFT AT) 🤪

Anyway, I do agree with point of how everyone has an ACTUAL role to play in Kundali Bhagya, as in every character seems important and has importance to the actual narrative in the story. No one is just their for the laughs (i.e Mitali Bhabi I am indicating at you🤣). If I may say so the casting in Kundali Bhagya has also been better and more consistent in Kundali Bhagya than Kumkum. Everyone seem to have fit so well in their respective characters, that the show feels very authentic. Considering I know a LOT of people who aren't happy with the casting of the 'all' the new generation casting that has been done.

Related Topics

Kundali Bhagya Thumbnail

Posted by: jasminerahul

11 days ago

Chal Mere Bhai ( Come on, brother) Karan Preeta Rishab

Chal Mere Bhai ( Come on, brother) Part 1 I dedicate this SS to my dearest friend Salley who asked me to write a PreeRan Rishab Tejasswi Prakash...

Expand ▼
Kundali Bhagya Thumbnail

Posted by: jasminerahul

1 months ago

Pyaar Ka Pehla Vachan...Ghar Jamai ShaLki Preeta SS

Pyaar Ka Pehla Vachan...Ghar Jamai(The first vow of love...Resident son-in-law)Part 1 Thank you so much dear Sydell for this lovely cover page....

Expand ▼
Kundali Bhagya Thumbnail

Posted by: jasminerahul

3 months ago

Fanboy:Shaurya Preeta Karan Palki SS

Fanboy Part 1 The concept of this SS is inspired by the malayalam movie 'Maanathe vellitheru' which is a psychological thriller.But this SS...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".