sushant didn't derserve 30. - Page 5

Originally posted by: digitalone 33

from my side 24 is more then enough
but only 21 for sure for this performance
not 30 he dont deserve that
[/QUOTE)

24 is good..that performance abt ma-beta deserved only that..no dance ..only emotion.mother and son rishta shown in whiichever way can be emotional..so ppl cried..but still dance element was missing..remo,didn't see that???

Originally posted by: --Rachna--

Are you kidding me? 😲 21 is given to a performance which was average or even below average. Are you saying his performance was average only? 🤔 His performance was the BEST and did deserve a 30

I think you're saying this because you don't like Sushant 😛 Oh well, it doesn't matter cause you're not the judge 😃

Originally posted by: Chits1

even i agreed with this one
in other remo want dance
and in shushant he want only emotion....................what the judging this be??

Originally posted by: digitalone 33

I am a mother of a son too..get emotional very easily but I didn't shed any tears for this performance..shampa didn't look a mom at all 😆😆😆

Originally posted by: *Woh Ajnabee*

Chits ji, I TOTALLY agree with you! They played a rather disgusting game on emotions last week. By telling us and the judges that Sushant lost his mother and is dedicating this performance in her honor, the stage was already set with heartfelt emotions right in the middle of the AV! It was obvious that regardless of how the performance went, Sushant will be getting a 30 to give "due respect".

Sushant and Shampa have performed much MUCH better in the past. The choreography in the Maa performance was very monotonous and there were no new movements. I feel that Shampa's choreography is getting very repetitive in contemporary and similar styles. Sushant always has the same typical jazz moves in all his performances. The performance also lacked dance overall. There was too much time spent emoting and depicting that somewhere along the way, the element of dance was lost.

Definitely not a 30 performance! Instead, I thought their Chumma Chumma performance was more refreshing because they finally chose a different style that was very different from things they've done in the past. That compelled Shampa's choreography to be different as well. However, I did think Sushant's hip hop was not matchable to Shampa's dancing in that performance.

Originally posted by: krait

@bold: agree with you completely on this one. ..my cousin is a trained jazz dancer and this is exactly what he says.. i wonder why none of the judges pointed this out.. now i seriously doubt their knowledge of different dance forms...this is where i really miss judges like Vaibhavi and javed....

Originally posted by: *Woh Ajnabee*

Chits ji, I TOTALLY agree with you! They played a rather disgusting game on emotions last week. By telling us and the judges that Sushant lost his mother and is dedicating this performance in her honor, the stage was already set with heartfelt emotions right in the middle of the AV! It was obvious that regardless of how the performance went, Sushant will be getting a 30 to give "due respect".

Originally posted by: *Woh Ajnabee*

His floor work at the beginning of each performance has been almost identical. We have seen him do these jazz movements in other shows as well. He does the very basic jazz steps in all his performances regardless of the style he is performing that day. I feel Shampa's choreography only kicks in during the lifts and other movements that they have together.

As far as judges are concerned, it is one thing to be a good dancer and it is a totally different thing to be educated in dance. Madhuri and Malaika (I highly doubt) are knowledgeable in various dance forms, especially foreign dance forms. We need judges who can tell the difference between all the various Latin dances, who can encourage something more than hip hop and contemporary on this platform, and who know more about dance than just Bollywood's matka's and jhatka's! Malaika mentioned once that she has studied dance ... well I've studied biochemistry last semester, too, but that in no way means that I remember any of it! I love Madhuri, but I think that if they want to keep her, they should've brought in another choreographer in Malaika's place. Remo-Madhuri-Vaibhavi would have been a MUCH better panel of judges. I'm a huge Vaibhavi fan- her judging is terrific!