Created

Last reply

Replies

63

Views

6.7k

Users

18

Likes

128

Frequent Posters

Oliver.Queen thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: aviation-ca



Yes of course he liked her (more tolerate than like).. and he really felt bad when he broke up with her.. realizing that she loved him & he could not reciprocate her feelings.. and instead used her feelings for him to stave off his growing attraction to Khushi... using her as a shield ... at this point he is attracted to Khushi, he is fighting it but does not love her..

As he confesses to Di.. even when he married her he doesn't love her (prior to finding about Shyam).. he only started loving her, feeling she is essential to him after marriage...




That scene always stumps me. If he didn't love her before marriage then what did he wanna tell her when he wanted to meet her alone before the misunderstanding with shyam occured? Clearly he loved her before marriage
NishaAP thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: aviation-ca



We see a very brief ASR/La interaction pre-Khushi during the cake episode... we see the slight smile & tolerant, affectionate (OK, affectionate for ASR) attitude ... afterwards... every time we see ASR/La interaction the specter of Khushi is between them... do you think anyone can physically touch him like La did without his tactic prior permission.. no matter.. how much La can desire him... no the fact that La could wrap herself around him itself is the indication that there is a relationship.. and what other kind of relationship would ASR have apart from a pure physical one...

Also, remember La assumes she is going to share a room with him... do you think she would on her own assume it?? No she assumed it because it was already a fact.. he had already given her the right to assume it...

When she is adjusting his tie.. he is thinking of Khushi.. when she comes to his room, he is thinking of Khushi.. the only reason he doesn't share a room with her is because deep down he respects his nani, even though he rebels against her wish to conform him to norms.. and more than that his Di.. who would tolerate his foibles.. but would not want him to cross the line...

Given that it was daring for daily soap.. to show open physical relationship... they beautifully implied it.. without ever spelling it out...


Hmmm now it makes sense. But my doubts are valid too. Even though they can not show open physical relationship part they can easily show the comfortable comrade ness between ASR and LA. They never did that may be because it may reduce the impact of Arshi romance on viewers. There is some logical mistakes on basic level also from CVs. Like ASR never agreed for marriage and he never said he would marry LA but Nani kept saying that she would never accept LA as her bahu. When he himself did want that then there was no need of that argument. Next ASR and LA both did not want to marry and ASR knew that Nani never agree for live-in then why Nani needed to accept LA and for what purpose? ASR did not share room with LA because he respects his Nani, that's why he did not even get intimate with LA in that house. Then what is purpose of his live in relationship with LA? He only needs her for physical purpose and he only get that by marrying her if he still wanted live in that house with LA. If he did not want to do that in his house he did not even think about moving out with her. he only blackmailed his Nani to accept LA and his relation with her, but did not have intension to blackmail her to allow them to share a room. Even when LA asked him marry because she wanted to share room with him he did not respond and he did not say she can share room without marrying him.
Oliver.Queen thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: Serene77

When it came to arnav - la physical intimacy part, I m still confused...

As much as it was hinted that they were intimate, he never even reciprocated her hugs...her 'I love u' were never reciprocated...since he doesn't care about society and its norms, I wonder why he was shown a little withdrawn from her ..so one way, it's hard to imagine that they were actually physically intimate. I also felt he brought her home to defy his nani that he doesn't need a marriage . And they were never shown as living in as she was in a dif room. And when la broached the subject that she wanted to share his room, he didn't react. And when she tried to get close to him in the confines of his or her room, he never reciprocated..
So it's actually confusing what they actually shared.


I also had the same line of thought. Logic tells me in a relationship there would be intimacy but seeing asr and la gave no such implications. I can only see convenience n defying nani as the reason for arnav's actions. I guess we would nvr know the magnitude of their relationship
NishaAP thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#34

Originally posted by: Sindu1991


That scene always stumps me. If he didn't love her before marriage then what did he wanna tell her when he wanted to meet her alone before the misunderstanding with shyam occured? Clearly he loved her before marriage


True. He realised his love before he came to know about Syam. He felt like his breath going to d
Stop when he thought Kushi met with accident. When Akash was thanking him about Payal and talking about love Arnav realised each point his Di said is true and that girl is indeed Kushi.

But we can not think about logic from the kidnap track because there is no logic. When he talked to Kushi about his love with Kushi, he told her that he thought she had affair with Syam but did not say about his confrontation with Syam and the way Syam agreed that he loved Kushi. Normally that was the first thing that need to be said even before he throw Syam out of his house. How can anybody expect Anjali to believe about Syam with out her chotey telling about what happened. The way no body cared about Arnav even after knowing he escaped from death and how Kushi saved him. Everything is illogical from the kidnaping episode, may be even before that.

aviation-ca thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#35
I have thought long & hard about it.. will get back to you guys after finishing up few things.. I can only give my POV.. but gr8 in depth discussion.. aren't we pathetic..
aviation-ca thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: nishaipkkdian


Hmmm now it makes sense. But my doubts are valid too. .. always, do the CVs know what the story is?? 😆..

Even though they can not show open physical relationship part they can easily show the comfortable comrade ness between ASR and LA.They never did that may be because it may reduce the impact of Arshi romance on viewers... au contraire... this was shown to contrast the leads.. one who openly hugs everyone.. the other who holds himself completely aloof.. because there is La who is comfortable enough to touch him freely.. and she does frequently..but there is ASR who holds himself aloof.. unless it is manhandling Khushi. 😉..

There is some logical mistakes on basic level also from CVs. Like ASR never agreed for marriage and he never said he would marry LA but Nani kept saying that she would never accept LA as her bahu. When he himself did want that then there was no need of that argument... Ahh.. .. when Nani declares she doesn't accept La, I think ASR says good (though need to confirm this scene)...but iit was actually Di (with Mami's reluctant help) who brought in Khushi to train La so the everyday fights between Nani & La over Rehen Sehen could be lessed.. and also slowly to make Nani accept La.. ironically this idea was given to her by none other than dearest hubby Shyam.. little did he know that Rani Sahiba will ask Khushi to train her...

Next ASR and LA both did not want to marry and ASR knew that Nani never agree for live-in then why Nani needed to accept LA and for what purpose? ... ASR only brought in La because he found out that Nani was snooping.. and trying to fix him up? If I remember correctly Khushi was somehow inadvertently involved in this too...I need to see these episodes again to refresh my memory...

ASR did not share room with LA because he respects his Nani, that's why he did not even get intimate with LA in that house. Then what is purpose of his live in relationship with LA? He only needs her for physical purpose and he only get that by marrying her if he still wanted live in that house with LA. If he did not want to do that in his house he did not even think about moving out with her. he only blackmailed his Nani to accept LA and his relation with her, but did not have intension to blackmail her to allow them to share a room. Even when LA asked him marry because she wanted to share room with him he did not respond and he did not say she can share room without marrying him. .. I think at this point La was more as a shield against Khushi.. unfortunately.. it is again Khushi herself who goads him into proposal...but I need to re-watch to refresh my memory... 😉

abayance thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#37
i think by the time la was brought into rm asr was already attracted to khushi and started to loose interest in la. probably this was the reason we could not see ars's physical attraction towards la.
..Scarlett.. thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#38
I wonder If Arnav n Lavanya was really a jodi,i really love d chrtr of lavanya,dimple doll sana khan.
SpellofJoy thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#39
they met on AR😊and they had a deal that LA would never force ASR to marry her
and that was all.. he wanted to date a girl who agrees on this deal

Related Topics

Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon thumbnail

Posted by: Mysticaldivine · 2 years ago

Walking through the memory lanes of the secretive doors of our remembrance, looking for forgotten benchmarks of our lives, we can find...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".