SRK's career without KJo and YRF - what would it be? - Page 14

Originally posted by: M.Wheeler

I have noticed that there is general consensus that MNIK was a bad movie on this forum. Even on this thread someone said that Shah should not have done it

I personally think that MNIK was the best product of the KJO-SRK-Kajol combo. An extremely relevant topic with great scope for performances. Rizwaan Mandira s argument after their son s death is just so heartbreaking. So well done

Rahul and Anjali are very cute. But Rizwan and Mandira are real deal. Raw human characters

This isn't unusual to find certain hate for certain films, stars on this forum. MNIK might be one of them. We can't change that, but we can keep liking what we like.

oh wow......Yankees blocked me after replying to my posts and getting personal in those......Sweety ...don't go in the kitchen if you are afraid of getting burned....😉....if you get personal atleast give me a chance to return the favor.....don't run away after attacking someone from behind..😉

That's very strange: "The user you are trying to quote may have blocked you. You cannot quote his/her posts."

Well, I will copy/paste what I wanted to quote from Yankees:

"Somehow Srk as a lover boy always seems rehearsed, repetitive and kind of plastic/made-up to me.

But what to do, just like everything else about him, he and people made a big deal about this as well."

1st line: I never felt that although I agree that some kind of his acting got repetitive. But I think, even in real life we repeat gestures and expressions of romantic love, so, actually, it doesn't bother me.

I think, every actor has his/her own way to express romance and it's understandable if one does connect with some and doesn't connect with others. As for me, my heart and mind could connect with ShahRukh enacting romance.

2nd line: The "big deal" I don't like are the labels made by media and enjoyed (I feel) by fans like Baadshah of Bollywood, King Khan and King of romance. I know, his name signifies "face of a king" and watching the crowd on his birthday and SRK greeting them from the platform has a very 'royal' touch and is plain overwhelming. It's most the stamp of "King of romance" that bothers me because of the danger to get typecast which, imo, isn't what SRK deserves.

Originally posted by: Guddu.Pandit

Yes to be more frequent in forum & buzy with duty?

More frequent after a few weeks

without KJO and YRF, i think SRK's career would have been very sad.😭 He would have been haklaoing in some 3rd grade movie, what else. 😉Big thanks to KJO and YF, we were spared those scenes👍🏼😆

Both benefited from each other,

hope SH doesn’t take any idea from this topic 🤔😆

Nishita, that's exactly my point of view ("they benefitted from each other") and I think, that's the best way to see it...and nothing to really discuss about...except the emotional angle that bound them together...an angle I saw in many relations between SRK and his directors/co-stars...and I've witnessed that the emotional bond was even with the dance troops in his shows...and the technicians...basically almost all those who work with and for him even if it's 'only' about the trust and appreciation he has for their work.

Birdie, through your posts, I know that you dislike SRK (which doesn't bother me as nobody is liked by all) but I disagree with your assertion that his career would have been a sad one. There already were directors and producers who had made positive experiences with SRK before he did his first movie with YRF (Yashji only contacted him after Aamir's negative reaction and because of his performance in Baazigar). He would have succeeded in any way...and YRF would have made a movie with him - for sure!

SRK also was a Rakesh Roshan "boy" until Rakesh launched his son...

Originally posted by: Taiz-Ladki

Actors got the most benefits from the production houses.

PH cannot depend on a single actor or actress.

Aao Thakur Aao, Mujhe Taiz-Ladkiyaan bahut pasand hai. I am myself very fast 😎

Next ID kya banani hai - Return_Of_KingKhan 😆

Oh yes, Taiz, they can and they do...oups, there were other posts in between...sorry

However, it still fits as the producers have THE say (far too often "unfortunately").

SRK's a unique actor that comes once in a generation.

KJO & YRF saw the talent, and could not overlook it. 😃