Originally posted by: bolly007
syndrome means that u have a specific problem sum peeps also have OCD but again they are very much normal hence i cannot see the arguement of y mandira will let such a person near her kid
-second of all i dun think u have seen the movie properly, in the movie when she finds out that it was a racist attack then she attacks srk wid her bad words
-and it is ur opinion that the movie was bad but since it got great reviews and is a box-office success, i guess a lot of peeps thought otherwise
-i guess everyone have difference of opinions, maybe the movie seemed a bit try hard, maybe it lacked subtelty, but i think it was a real good attempt
Ok let's get this straight 😛 erm never said Riz wasn't NORMAL...and what is normal in this mad world????????????????????? And sorry s.o who needs a legal tutor makes him an infant in the eyes of RESPONSIBLE grown ups.......That's reality...so all his wandering all over the States is silly cause if Mandira & his Bro were responsible - they would have stopped him....and taken him back.
I've seen the movie 4 times-- so I have seen it properly....thanks.😃 Yes Mandira is a racist & stupid character for me. Her son was killed by ignorant people -- I don't even think they were racist because I don't think they knew he was indian and Hindu/muslim (?).... You should re read properly what I wrote....yourself....😊😉
I never said what I wrote was the OPINION? OF THE MAJORITY.....it's only LALIXLILI who posted the previous comments not ALL THE WORLD....it's not because movies are hits that make them smart or good movies....It only make them movies which recover their initial costs and make extra money. MNIK's second part is ridiculous and if I was indian I'd be ashamed that an indian director made a movie full of racist cliches and showed clear ignorance about how people in the US felt the 9/11. Sorry but the sequence of a teacher saying Islam is the religion of Devil or sth like that...= stupidity!!!!!! teachers are not generally allowed to express racism in classes...maybe in India it's normal but not in The US sorry...😊
I think Avatar & Titanic are silly movies./....😆😊 and they are like the biggest hits ever....😕😳 so the BO status of any movie doesn't count for me - that counts for producers who make money --- But some coherence in a storyline does matter to me.
FYI --- I read a lot about the reactions of international critics & random non asian american people and sorry to say - one indian critic witnessed lots of foreign critics laughing out loud at the candidness and OTT melodrama of MNIK during the screening and there are black people who walked out the theaters when seeing the Mama Jenny sequences....
Sorry but in MNIK there are a lot of racist cliches unseen since a very long time...and that just shows the ignorance/non originality of Kjo & his scriptwriter about some minorities in the USA...
If the movie was a fantasy --- I'd have understood and taken it like when I saw Big Fish --- because there are uncoherence & random elements in the movie but it does make sense cause it's a FANTASY movie - MNIK is/was supposed to be a serious one - I don't get all the FANTASY in it...🤢
I understand people like it - I don't question that - the topic is about THE WRONG in MNIK --- that was what I was pointing out --- if it was about the right/good things about it --- I'd have said that the first 30 minutes are awesome.😊
yes it was a good attempt....🤢😭 perhaps next time it'll be a concrete attempt let's dream....
Most of people went to see the movie for Kajol & SRK...not because of the subject...this is reality...with another lead characters...Kareena & Saif for example --- it pbbly would have flopped just like Kurbaan...
Edited by lalixlili - 15 years ago
Ye Hai Mohabbatein
CID
3