What was wrong with MNIK? - Page 3

Originally posted by: PhoeniXof_Hades

[Opinion] Acting was horrendous, especially Kajol's. If these kinds of acting were allowed in Hollywood, they would have all bagged the Razzie awards by now [/sarcasm]. Had the acting been a little better maybe I would have liked the movie, as I give too much importance to acting than anything else. Too pretentious, too melodramatic, and absolutely hollow and lacking any depth whatsoever. It seemed as though they were all trying to give their best, but falling short of it at every step. A good concept doesn't make a good movie. A movie has to be executed well enough, too, to be considered a great work of art. And it is in this department where MNIK falls short. What an idiotic, illogical, absolutely hilarious plot. 9/11 is a sensitive issue, and so is terrorism and Asperger syndrome. And what did KJo do? Make a mockery of them, just as he made mockery of love, friendship, family, humanity, religion, homosexuality, etc etc in his earlier works. His early works were at least good in the sense that they did not at least delve into such serious and controversial issues. Ugh.

I totally agree 👏👏 Cudnt have put it in a better way that this. People rave about SRK's acting but he looked more constipated than someone having Asperger 😕 (and yus, we have people whose cousin or someone they know have that syndrome. It's not like that we dont know either) But there's a difference between acting and over doing it.
Don't know how KJO gets away with all these emotional torture--- Chalo let's write a character with some incurable/ dreadful disease, Indian audiences are bound to show their pity-- what a shame!!!

Originally posted by: Nuktaacheen

i t i w a g m... s w g i t m... s w k... k j t s d a i w... y, i w a b s i p... b o t t, i c't f a f i t m...

s h w o c u w t m r a s e j t b h a a o h m... 😛 b h, w c y d a i...? 😛 p a g g-g o a s m l d, b i h s... 😆 b c h a c m b i h s... a t i t t i t s b w t d n l t m... o m t w t t m i a b d t m f t l... f t i e d'n r m... n w...!!

g t...a i a h n c a t w i a t a, i's a g... 😉 e i i h t i a o, i w h o c a... 😛

😆😆😆 U're talking in codes...I need clues to decipher 😆

Originally posted by: chatpati900

I just watched My Name is Khan a couple of days ago and I was blown away by it. I cried BUCKETS and I just found the movie extremely touching and inspiring.

However, I believe a lot of people didn't actually like it very much. Which, surprises me. I personally thought it was refreshingly different from KJ's other movies and while it obviously had a dramatic element to it, I thought the acting and the subject was very well executed. After a long time, I thought SRK was able to bring a certain innocence and newness in his characters.

So what is it about the movie that didn't appeal to the audience? I'm curious to know 😊

It did appeal to the audience. Movie is a HIT.

Well if other ppl didnt like it, i cant really question them as everybody has their own choice...but for me, I SIMPLY LOVED THE MOVIE from the bottom of my heart! One of the best of 2010! :) It was actually THE BEST Kjo movie according to me.

i found it too illogical and way over-hyped! And I didn't like the fact that some Indian critics thought it should automatically deserve an Oscar b/c it dealt w/racism issues...MNIK is not but I call OScar-worthy partially b/c the script was weak in certain places and too filmy in other places!

It was def a very honest and different Kjo film! I personally liked Kurbaan better! Because in MNIK it was a bit boring and it dragged on! I still enjoyed the film though, since I was a Muslim and could relate to the fear Muslims have to live through in America! But loved SRk was the best part in the film. Loved seeing different character from him other than the romantic hero type!

Originally posted by: lensahunte08

It was def a very honest and different Kjo film! I personally liked Kurbaan better! Because in MNIK it was a bit boring and it dragged on! I still enjoyed the film though, since I was a Muslim and could relate to the fear Muslims have to live through in America! But loved SRk was the best part in the film. Loved seeing different character from him other than the romantic hero type!

I didn't like it or hate it. I'm quite neutral about MNIK. One thing that I did like was the message in the film, which was in the world there are only two kinds of people, good people and bad people. That was a really simple message but so true.

only rizwan saving the whole of wilhemina was ridiculous but other than that the film just was bang on....loved it especially rizwan-mandira .....