Bhishma's Detachment Against the Dark Backdrop of Greed - Page 6

Other link of quora

which I gave they may have not source but their answer are not wrong and we know it very well

If answer is wrong given by quora link which I provide then u can give me link of correct answer with source

Originally posted by: surabhi01

Other link of quora

which I gave they may have not source but their answer are not wrong and we know it very well

If answer is wrong given by quora link which I provide then u can give me link of correct answer with source

The link of Quora sent by someone stated that majority answers are incorrect. So if Quora is right then it's majority answers are wrong hence post that link Quora being a reliable source becomes a logically inconsistent statement

And there is no question for which we are looking you have just given an instance which finds no reference at all in any of the reliable sources (i.e. the book of Mahabharata, we might also give in if it was written in Bhagwat Puran, that is the second most reliable source after Mahabharata although even that isn't considered reliable enough by many)

How could there be a source for something not being present anywhere? Can there ever be a proof that a white crow doesn't exist in Purani Dilli? Or that Simi Garewal was not a part of Kuchh kuchh hota hai? The only proof could be you search Purani Dilli and say that no there isn't a white crow or you might watch kuchh Kuchh hota hai to day that Simi Garewal wasn't there in the movie. Similarly to check the validity you need to read the Mahabharata and Bhagwat Puran and say I didn't find it there, something which majority of us have done but you aren't willing to do so practically there is no way you could get a proof.

Then give me link of correct answer if quora answer is, wrong

In quora the answer is given that parshuram came to know that Karna can't be bhramin as Karna tolerate insect bites as he doesn't not want to disturb parshuram sleep

Now if this answer is wrong then what is correct answer

Abhimany u id not how to break chakrayyuh

Because subhadra went to sleep .

If this is wrong then what is correct answer

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/post/91585365

Her in link of quiz in India forum post 6 years ago and it also say same thing about bhishm injecting thors in insects

Originally posted by: surabhi01

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/post/91585365

Her in link of quiz in India forum post 6 years ago and it also say same thing about bhishm injecting thors in insects

Originally posted by: surabhi01

Then give me link of correct answer if quora answer is, wrong

In quora the answer is given that parshuram came to know that Karna can't be bhramin as Karna tolerate insect bites as he doesn't not want to disturb parshuram sleep

Now if this answer is wrong then what is correct answer

Abhimany u id not how to break chakrayyuh

Because subhadra went to sleep .

If this is wrong then what is correct answer

Anyway, let me debunk that quora claim and end this topic.

Krishna said, 'O amiable one, be comforted. Do not yield to grief, O thou of beautiful features! Without doubt, thy son has gone to the highest region of felicity! He was one of the Vasus of great energy. Through a curse, O thou of beautiful features, he had to take birth among men. It behoveth thee not to grieve for him. Agreeably to Kshatriya duties, he was slain by Dhananjaya on the field of battle while engaged in battle. He has not been slain, O goddess, by Sikhandin. The very chief of the celestials himself could not slay Bhishma in battle when he stood with stretched bow in hand. O thou of beautiful face, thy son has, in felicity, gone to heaven. All the gods assembled together could not slay him in battle. Do not, therefore, O goddess Ganga, grieve for that son of Kuru's race. He was one of the Vasus, O goddess! Thy son has gone to heaven. Let the fever of thy heart be dispelled.'

The Mahabharata

Book 13: Anusasana Parva

Kisari Mohan Ganguli, tr.

[1883-1896]

Krishna clearly mentions that Bhishma was one among the cursed Vasus who took birth among men. There was no other birth, period.

As u r saying that quora is not reliable site it doesn't not give right answer so I gave other answer of quora to tell whether quora is reliable site or not

I know it is copy paste but answer is same. If this answer was wrong that it has not even copy paste here

Originally posted by: surabhi01

As u r saying that quora is not reliable site it doesn't not give right answer so I gave other answer of quora to tell whether quora is reliable site or not

I know it is copy paste but answer is same. If this answer was wrong that it has not even copy paste here

By the way it's not just us, but also Quora which has called Quora unreliable

To answer Surabhi - If a wall clock is out of battery, that also gives the correct timing twice a day. Just because few answers in Quora ARE correct, that doesn't mean Quora is always correct. Again, like FP and Shruti have repeatedly mentioned, if the source/books/any versus or any damn script has this theory of rebirth, I'd consider this legit point to even ponder upon, but if the only source is Quora, then nothing to comment beyond this😆. The site IS opinion website. Not a truth telling saga. You'd be surprised to know that even Wikipedia is most of the times open for manipulation, one can edit Wiki page. So the only source to consider wrt MB is any legit book. Not these things.

Source u have given me about final instructions from bhishm first of all that source did not give full information but only half information

I tried to other parva that is that parva where ashwathama throw bhramastra . It only tell as ashwathama don't know how to stop bhramastra so it direct to pandav women

It doesn't not tell it was going to uttara womb . It doesn't not even mention uttara name

It just tell only tell pandav women. Now what does pandav women mean pandav wife or pandav daughter in law

And even it doesn't not mention how Krishna save parikshit i. Lot of things are deleted

Even there was conversation between Lord Krishna and bhishm when bhishm lying on bed of arrow that is also missing

May be quora don't provide source but at least it give complete answer

And if read properly answer of quora then most of answer of quora are correct

And answer of quora are not t personal opinion . Most of answer of quora can be really find in Mahabharata scripture

May be quora can't 100 percent perfect but 98 percent it gives correct answer but one has read properly answer of quora

And source also tell that virat parva , shanti parva and anushasn parva all are interpolation parva

It also said valmiki come near bhishm when bhishm about to die . I don't know when valmiki in Mahabharata war