Bhishma's Detachment Against the Dark Backdrop of Greed - Page 5

Originally posted by: surabhi01

They may not give source but they are not giving wrong answer too

I have check many questions but each time they give right answer

Btw can u provide link that these these site giving wrong answer

Every time I know answer from quora and there is no source but they give correct answer

For eg I ask why did not drona teach karn

Though I know answer but still for its reliability I. Check it and give me correct answer and there is no source given

If someone gave correct answer earlier doesn't mean that someone else will not give wrong answers later. That is exactly what you are doing while quoting Quora.

I am more interested about the second link. It gives references from Mahabharata about Arjun Krishna varta and about other things too, but it doesn't make any reference from Mahabharata about 73 births story which was the article all about.

It's like I am writing say against big bang and I start writing about the formation black holes with complete detailing after having written black hole didn't happen.

About the link of yours the simple link is online Mahabharata, have told you this multiple times

But you aren't ready to do that.

Last time I am asking u can u provide single link of these like quora speaking trees site which proove those site are not reliable

Can u provide any answer from quora which proove quora don't give correct answer

I am finding those site reliable because when ever I try to find answer it gave me always correct answer and I am referring to that site since many months it never give me wrong answer

But as u said it cannot give always right answer.so can u give me link of wrong answer provide by these site

Originally posted by: surabhi01

Last time I am asking u can u provide single link of these like quora speaking trees site which proove those site are not reliable

Can u provide any answer from quora which proove quora don't give correct answer

I am finding those site reliable because when ever I try to find answer it gave me always correct answer and I am referring to that site since many months it never give me wrong answer

But as u said it cannot give always right answer.so can u give me link of wrong answer provide by these site

OMG do you even know what are asking??

If someone says that Vikarna was not a character of Ramayana, you are asking to give a link which states so. Funniest thing of all times. Definitely no one will write about all the characters which were not there in Ramayana, How can there be an article about something which was not there? Similarly no one will write an article that there was no mention of previous births of Bheeshm.

Mahabharata the epic doesn't mention any mention about such instance and to be sure about that you need to read the epic.

Anyhow now that you are so much into links, I am sharing a few

So here is one from your beloved Quora. Here the respondent mentions about past life but not the 73rd past life, he didn't prick thorns but by mistake threw the snake on thorns

https://www.quora.com/When-Bhisma-Pitamah-was-laying-on-the-bed-of-arrows-and-asked-Lord-Krishna-Why-do-bad-things-happen-to-noble-people-what-did-Lord-Krishna-reply/answer/Ankit-Agarwal-159?ch=10&share=355f91e2&srid=xzCH

This another link which states that since he wasn't to take any rebirth hence his crimes of this life was punished this way

https://www.quora.com/What-was-the-karma-of-Bhisma-for-him-to-suffer-on-the-bed-of-arrows/answer/Vaibhav-Singhal-121?ch=10&share=c130404a&srid=xzCH

This link of Quora states that he lied on arrows since earth wouldn't have accepted him

https://www.quora.com/Is-there-any-story-like-any-curse-behind-Bheeshma-laying-on-a-bed-of-arrows-at-war/answer/Chinmay-Mukhopadhyay?ch=10&share=bae8a2f9&srid=xzCH

So you can see that this site isn't reliable since it has different answers to the same question at different places.

If these links can't prove to you that Quora isn't reliable then I guess you just want to keep believing what you have heard

Answer is different because u have provided me link of different question

Question are different that is why Answer is different

Curse question is different sin committed by bhishm at 73rd birth

Here I am giving u link of only one question and it gives almost same answer by different people https://www.quora.com/Mahabharata-Hindu-epic-When-Bhagwan-Parshuram-sees-Karnas-tolerance-he-says-that-Karna-cant-be-a-Sut-Putra-Son-of-a-charioteer-what-does-he-actually-mean-when-he-says-that

@ Surabhi - Read this one friend.

https://www.quora.com/Why-are-most-of-the-answers-on-Quora-wrong

Quora would be the last source to know about MB. The best one that I have read so far is KMG version. I read that you are not allowed to have the books, how about eCopy? I have the eCopy as well.

https://www.quora.com/Why-did-Abhimanyu-never-learn-the-way-out-of-Chakravyuh#MoreAnswers

Originally posted by: surabhi01

Answer is different because u have provided me link of different question

Question are different that is why Answer is different

Curse question is different sin committed by bhishm at 73rd birth

Here I am giving u link of only one question and it gives almost same answer by different people https://www.quora.com/Mahabharata-Hindu-epic-When-Bhagwan-Parshuram-sees-Karnas-tolerance-he-says-that-Karna-cant-be-a-Sut-Putra-Son-of-a-charioteer-what-does-he-actually-mean-when-he-says-that

All the questions are related to why Bheeshm was in the death bed and the answers are different. All the questions aren't about curse, they are about why was he on the arrow bed, some talk about curse and others about

Anyhow as someone posted above Quora itself says that most answers in Quora are wrong, still you want to believe that it is true

https://www.quora.com/Why-was-Amba-given-a-boon-that-she-will-be-the-reason-for-Bhishmas-death-Even-though-her-request-was-purely-revenge-and-was-not-dharma

https://www.quora.com/How-Lord-Krishna-got-his-Sudarshan-Chakra

https://www.quora.com/How-were-all-100-Kauravas-born-together

Anything that doesn't find its existence in the authentic Mahabharata texts is wrong. Quora/speaking tree isn't Vyasa's spokesperson. :)

Originally posted by: Wistfulness

Anything that doesn't find its existence in the authentic Mahabharata texts is wrong. Quora/speaking tree isn't Vyasa's spokesperson. :)

She has just one point that prove that Mahabharata doesn't mention this episode, and she doesn't want to read Mahabharata to get this answer, now I am not sure how to exactly answer that.

Although someone has already given the link that Quora itself is wrong