FACTS FROM THE DEVIL’S ADVOCATE - Page 2

u guys r seriously sick........ did any one among hema n himani say that debo is undeserving..???? n did they say that its crime if debo got highest votes from home town or ask for votes in assamese or bengali....???? u silly jerks..... they r so scared abt the ULFA threat which made them walkout of the show.. though vinit is a good singer i totally disagree with his comment on debo.... stop thinking negatively abt every1. know the details of the walkout totally n then talk abt them......

*** Please mind your language and do not call other members names. You are welcome to your opinion and they are to theirs...just as your opinion does not make you a 'jerk', theirs don't make them one either...so please observe the forum rules and observe prudency while posting.***

Originally posted by: sherley

u guys r seriously sick........ did any one among hema n himani say that debo is undeserving..???? n did they say that its crime if debo got highest votes from home town or ask for votes in assamese or bengali....???? u silly jerks..... they r so scared abt the ULFA threat which made them walkout of the show.. though vinit is a good singer i totally disagree with his comment on debo.... stop thinking negatively abt every1. know the details of the walkout totally n then talk abt them......

Firstly, you have full right to have your opinion, but not by calling other members silly jerks. So mind what you say when addressing to other members.

debu iz the gr8 singer buh not the best one..n even in qawali round ..he doesn't deserve more than 9...i know AS n HR were unfair ..they gave him 6 n 7 ..which was unfair..he deserves better than that..buh he was not the best in qawali round..i m not a vinit fan..i juss hate vinit..buh i think he sang better than debu...may be it was an easy song thatz y..buh wateva...debu didnt deserve highest votez this week..other 3 were better than him.....so offcourse when other 3 heard that he got the highest votes 41 % which iz also record breaking......so any normal person would do that...debu got sympathy votez n thatz the truth...if AS n HR were being fair with him n would have given him 9's or 8's ..he wouldn't have got highest votez..buh thatz juss my opinion!..............himani n nihira were (are) better than debu n vinit..buh anywayz......NVM

well said apparaohoare!!
DEBO is doing great!!!
..Even getting lowest votes from mentors and critisizm from other contestants..Debo was perforing absolutely great.. But if you are looking from HR and AS glasses.. Then you(those who are critisizing debo) will always say like that.. Forget abt mentors and other things going arround.. Just see gunuine and honest versatile singer.. (by closing ur eyes and please keep open your ears...) You will definately get true singer..

Originally posted by: sadaf84

debu iz the gr8 singer buh not the best one..n even in qawali round ..he doesn't deserve more than 9...i know AS n HR were unfair ..they gave him 6 n 7 ..which was unfair..he deserves better than that..buh he was not the best in qawali round..i m not a vinit fan..i juss hate vinit..buh i think he sang better than debu...may be it was an easy song thatz y..buh wateva...debu didnt deserve highest votez this week..other 3 were better than him.....so offcourse when other 3 heard that he got the highest votes 41 % which iz also record breaking......so any normal person would do that...debu got sympathy votez n thatz the truth...if AS n HR were being fair with him n would have given him 9's or 8's ..he wouldn't have got highest votez..buh thatz juss my opinion!..............himani n nihira were (are) better than debu n vinit..buh anywayz......NVM

That means you agree that Hemu, Vineet, Himani, and Debu were better than Nihira. They should have walked out then too.

Originally posted by: apparaohoare

That means you agree that Hemu, Vineet, Himani, and Debu was better than Nihira. They should have walked out then too.

offcourse not! u know when nihira got eliminated ..every1 thought its gonna be debu buh instead of him ..she got eliminated..n same thing happened with himani again..u know the step the contestants took (walking out)..it must be preplanned...but wateva the reason was..it was wrong..they should have walked out when nihira was gone.... but see no1 was expecting that nihira would be out..every1 was expecting debu will be out...buh then that happened all thses contestantz (n mentorz) must have thought sumthing that if this happen again then we will walk out...i m not too sure yaar y they did that..................

debu iz gr8 no doubt bout it...buh he iz not the best

apparaohoare.please,thesekids how can they snub zee bosses and industry bigwigs(music directors).as soon as the results were announced,singers from rival gharanas ganged up and became united?all this happened in a live studio.debo got max.2 others had a chance.zee was housing them feeding them.
if that is the case they have distroyed their careers.I have only seen saffection among the kids.please dont call them monsters.ALLTHE WICKEDNESS LIES SOMEWHERE ELSE.but root cause is gaj(ji?).seeing fame gurukul he became greedy
everything snowballed from there.
i would give the poor kids a chance.every one, even vinit seems like a nice kid(least fav,but)

I agree completely on Nihira. If everyone, all mentors, all judges so far, all contestants, all music lovers think she is the best, how did all of them kept quite when she was kicked out??

If public voting is it, public voting is it. Debo or not is irrelevant at this stage. SRGMP had a distinction above Idol and Gurukul that Music was given importance in earlier stages. But now, there is no such distinction. It is public voting, results are going to be weird, unpredictable, and have absoultely nothing to do with MUSIC!

I think people need to realize it, and then only then this will return to be a reality game show again..and we will get through with it. Saving grace is that Hema, Debo, Himani and Vinit are at least not as bad as Kaji(Fame Gurukul), if you know what I mean.

Cheers..lets enjoy whatever music is left in SRGMP!

offcourse not! u know when nihira got eliminated ..every1 thought its gonna be debu buh instead of him ..she got eliminated..n same thing happened with himani again..u know the step the contestants took (walking out)..it must be preplanned...but wateva the reason was..it was wrong..they should have walked out when nihira was gone.... but see no1 was expecting that nihira would be out..every1 was expecting debu will be out...buh then that happened all thses contestantz (n mentorz) must have thought sumthing that if this happen again then we will walk out...i m not too sure yaar y they did that..................

debu iz gr8 no doubt bout it...buh he iz not the best

Wrong judgments have been made in this show earlier. Do you think Raktima deserved to go out before Rajeev. Or Sharib before Vineet or Rajeev or Paresh. Come on give me a break. But why should Debu be victimized every time. When the contestants agreed to a show where public makes the final decision you will have to accept that. It was never said that this part of India is allowed to cast so many votes and this part cannot. Till now it was in your favor and this system was Okay for you, now that it is going against you its bad and you walk out. Why didn't you walk out when the first candidate Raktima was victimized by this system. She surely did not deserve to go out first.

But why should Debu be the legitimate candidate to be eliminated every week. Why not Vineet? Is Debu so bad. Debu is in such a position right now just because of HR and AS's negative comments all the way through. Now everyone thinks that he is bad. To tell you the truth, Vineet would never dare to try the Qawali song that Debu performed. He was a bit shaky during the first 30 seconds, but he was fantastic after that. The alaaps, the sargams, the taans, it was mind blowing. If Vineet is good, then Debu has to be better than that. I am not the one saying this. History speaks. Which judgment should we respect: Pt. Jasraj ji or Himesh's.

If they were scared of ULFA then they would have left the show secretly not like this. So all the arguments about this is BS.

Originally posted by: sadaf84

offcourse not! u know when nihira got eliminated ..every1 thought its gonna be debu buh instead of him ..she got eliminated..n same thing happened with himani again..u know the step the contestants took (walking out)..it must be preplanned...but wateva the reason was..it was wrong..they should have walked out when nihira was gone.... but see no1 was expecting that nihira would be out..every1 was expecting debu will be out...buh then that happened all thses contestantz (n mentorz) must have thought sumthing that if this happen again then we will walk out...i m not too sure yaar y they did that..................

debu iz gr8 no doubt bout it...buh he iz not the best

I agree. Nihira's result came as a shock to everyone. It was pretty evident with Himani's reaction. I guess they didn't have much time to react to it. But a week later it hit them and they realized it was totally unjust for her to be out in place of Debo. And in the next shoot when they realized that it was happening again, they could not take it anymore. I feel they might have talked about it in private and decided to do this. Also they must have been irritated at the attention Debo got at ID's walk out. It was unfair to them, when all came out praising Debo.