Himesh sued for 5 crores over Karzzz song - Page 6

Originally posted by: Indradhanush

yes I never denied that , but 30 hits in a year are forgotten equally fast unless they are competing for the category of Roza, Dil se, Tare Zameen Par, Kal ho na ho etc or are trend setting like aap jaise koi.

Originally posted by: Indradhanush

yes I never denied that , but 30 hits in a year are forgotten equally fast unless they are competing for the category of Roza, Dil se, Tare Zameen Par, Kal ho na ho etc or are trend setting like aap jaise koi.

Originally posted by: Anuradha

Thats your POV.. Except for Banaras, Humraaz and Terenaam and just one song for Namaste London none of them are commendable.. Terenaam, Himesh has himself agreed to have been inspired by LP..

What is wrong with that? It is inspiration in the true sense. Many MDs were inspired by previous MDs and tried to emulate their style without copying anything. Vishal-Shekhar do it quite often. Dil haara was inspired by Omkara and Dastaan-E-Om Shanti Om was inspired by Ek hasina thi (which itself was a lifted song). It is still their work but they are using another MD as a role model.

Now, coming to the debatable point:

I saw in the news where the reporter interviewed both Himesh and Kally.. I was very sure after listening to them that its all for publicity stunt.. Why didn't T-Series come to defend Himesh or Sameer while they know very well that the song is T-Series intellectual property?? Himesh knows that this movie is not to become a big hit and all these publicity will help him, but in turn it will turn negative for him.. As asked by SS, why didn't Kally come out and charge T-Series for it??

Now, even if Himesh and Sameer had lifted the song, they must have given atleast the credit.. I listened to both versions, and there is no any difference between the songs.. Its not re-creation - its complete lift..

They could have easily given him the credit both for music and to the lyricist.. Now if he had given the due credit, no one would have been in question here..

This is what every MD must do.. If they are getting inspired by any song, then give the credit saying inspired by so and so band or MD.. This will solve most of the issue and everyone will get their due credit.. This is an industry and its better to work in as a team rather than copying the work of one member and giving the credit to themselves..

Now just a question to those who are defending this act - If you are working in a team and some member from another team copies your work, will you not object them?? How will you feel when your own work is being copied by another member of someother team??

Originally posted by: Anuradha

[

Thats your POV.. Except for Banaras, Humraaz and Terenaam and just one song for Namaste London none of them are commendable.. Terenaam, Himesh has himself agreed to have been inspired by LP..

Now, coming to the debatable point:

I saw in the news where the reporter interviewed both Himesh and Kally.. I was very sure after listening to them that its all for publicity stunt.. Why didn't T-Series come to defend Himesh or Sameer while they know very well that the song is T-Series intellectual property?? Himesh knows that this movie is not to become a big hit and all these publicity will help him, but in turn it will turn negative for him.. As asked by SS, why didn't Kally come out and charge T-Series for it??

Now, even if Himesh and Sameer had lifted the song, they must have given atleast the credit.. I listened to both versions, and there is no any difference between the songs.. Its not re-creation - its complete lift.. They could have easily given him the credit both for music and to the lyricist.. Now if he had given the due credit, no one would have been in question here..

This is what every MD must do.. If they are getting inspired by any song, then give the credit saying inspired by so and so band or MD.. This will solve most of the issue and everyone will get their due credit.. This is an industry and its better to work in as a team rather than copying the work of one member and giving the credit to themselves..

Now just a question to those who are defending this act - If you are working in a team and some member from another team copies your work, will you not object them?? How will you feel when your own work is being copied by another member of someother team??

Originally posted by: vijaykkk

No Anuradha what you have said is just your POV.

Go and check any website you will come to know that namaste london has many good songs like

Aanan Fannan

Yahi hota Pyaar

Veeraniya

Rafta Rafta

you will find these songs even today on Tv channels. If still dont belive me check out youtube and you will come to know how many people listens to himesh songs.

Second thing himesh was nominated for best music Director for Aksar,Maine pyaar Kyon Kiya and Aap ka Surror

so that means even classes have loved those albums.

Now regarding Kulvinder Kally and Himesh

As I said earlier That SEL has used Pretty Women song in the movie kal ho na ho will you call that also a lift. What about Ek Hasina thi song in Karzzzz will you call that also a lift.

If Yes then why? and if No then Why?

Think ten times to these question and then I will answer all your doubt.

Originally posted by: vijaykkk

No Anuradha what you have said is just your POV.

Go and check any website you will come to know that namaste london has many good songs like

Aanan Fannan

Yahi hota Pyaar

Veeraniya

Rafta Rafta

you will find these songs even today on Tv channels. If still dont belive me check out youtube and you will come to know how many people listens to himesh songs.

Second thing himesh was nominated for best music Director for Aksar,Maine pyaar Kyon Kiya and Aap ka Surror

so that means even classes have loved those albums.

Now regarding Kulvinder Kally and Himesh

As I said earlier That SEL has used Pretty Women song in the movie kal ho na ho will you call that also a lift. What about Ek Hasina thi song in Karzzzz will you call that also a lift.

If Yes then why? and if No then Why?

Think ten times to these question and then I will answer all your doubt.