Himesh sued for 5 crores over Karzzz song - Page 8

Created

Last reply

Replies

114

Views

11.2k

Users

21

Frequent Posters

Summer3 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#71

Originally posted by: girija babu

Maan gaye yaar. Moderator ko bhi nahi chhoda apne. By the way i agree that u know lot about how music company functions.

Viajy is too enthusiastic and got carried away.😆
Anuradha thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#72

Originally posted by: ReemAnshu

And why would t-series and HR want publicity out of someone who probably is not know even by a few hundred people outside of punjab ?? If T-series needs publicity they have RGV or Yash Raj to clash with and if HR needs publicity then he has the SRGMP platform.



We have seen this in the past as well.. Himesh/T-Series has always seen doing publicity just before any of their albums are released.. May it be Ashaji controversy, or anyother - everytime before his albums are released, there is some controversy or the other that strikes.. I hope you will agree that Ashaji does not require any publicity stunt...
kabhi_21 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#73

wooooow what a topic 😆

after a long time HR topic has gone so long lolz..... dont wish to meddle... i would just say agree with vijay, sursangam and reemanshu....
it is an attention garnering tactic.... though himesh makes news even if he sneezes so i dont think he need kally to get attention 😆
ReemAnshu thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#74

Originally posted by: Anuradha



We have seen this in the past as well.. Himesh/T-Series has always seen doing publicity just before any of their albums are released.. May it be Ashaji controversy, or anyother - everytime before his albums are released, there is some controversy or the other that strikes.. I hope you will agree that Ashaji does not require any publicity stunt...

Anuradha, I totally agree with you when you say that Publicity is important and everyone does it. HR & T-series is no different. I think clash with Ashaji was more of a publicity stunt for the promotion of SRGMP and not an album. I doubt that anyone would buy the album or come to know of it because HR & Asha have an arguement.
To me this looks like more of a case of Kally wanting publicity and thats why he is making the noises. Honestly it does not look like a publicity stunt from HR or T-series. my point is that they will do a much larger scale publicity and positive publicity for the album to get noticed.
Like last time when Aap Ka suroor was to release there was a controversy with the song Mehbooba Mehbooba. HR was to sing that song for RGV's Aag but things went sour between them and HR was no longer on that project. So he (read t-series) bought the rights of the Original song and had a duet with Ashaji and put it in the movie at the end (even tough it was not a part of the movie) just so that RGV could not use the original in his film.
This is common in the industry (getting even) and it not only promoted the song / Album but also got the right publicity for the film (picturising on Mallika helped).
Here I dont see HR or T-series gain anything out of this. The only person who will gain is Mr.Kally. It is the first time I have heard his version of the song and even heard his name. I think now a lot more people know him in India then just a couple of days ago.
vijaykkk thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#75
Please make yourself very clear .
Some people are saying its all publicty stunt. and in the next line they are writting himesh has lifted the tune.
If himesh has lifted the tune it wont be a publicity stunt it is real . If it is a publicity stunt that means himesh is not lifted the tune.
When I said It is not a publicity stunt then I also said the reasons why I feel so. It was just my opinion why I felt this is not a publicity stunt.
Even Manoj Kumar raised objection to Om Shanti Om which was for real.
Karzzy 4 song lifting case was also real.
In afternoon if someone says to me that it is night and I tell him to look in the sky and see the bright sun and that guy keeps his eyes close and keep on repeating that it is still night and not afternoon then what I can do about it.
Shakh ka illaaj Hakim Doban ke paas bhi nahi tha.
I have given all proof which I had to make my statement very clear. If anyone has something that shows himesh is guilty. He has lifted the tune and T series does not have copyrights of the song than please support your statement with proof.
Edited by vijaykkk - 16 years ago
vijaykkk thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#76
.


We have seen this in the past as well.. Himesh/T-Series has always seen doing publicity just before any of their albums are released.. May it be Ashaji controversy, or anyother - everytime before his albums are released, there is some controversy or the other that strikes.. I hope you will agree that Ashaji does not require any publicity stunt...
AKS movie realised on june 29 2007
Himesh and Ashaji conterversy on Mehbooba Song was on Nov 24 2007
If any one wants proof I am ready to post.
Now please any one tell me how a conterversy which happened on 24 nov 2007 has benifted a movie which was realised on June 29 2007. ?????????????????
vijaykkk thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#77

Originally posted by: Anuradha



It is not that I dont know about the so called music rules of the industry.. And my first post clearly said that its all done for publicity and also asked why didn't kally sue the T-Series company?? You were the ones to start defending that this is not a publicity stunt..

FYI - I am not against Himesh.. I am just trying to make my point against plagiarism.. Now just answer me this question - T series could have easily gone ahead with the name of Kally as the music director.. I have heard both the songs and I dont see anything being re-created over here.. Not only the song, but also the lyrics has been taken for the song.. So, why was Sameer given the credit for the song?? Isn't it unethical?? Well, the music industry rules in itself should be redefined.. Give the credit to the original music composer and also the lyricist.. Well, if the music directors want, they can easily give the credit to the original composer..

This is the last time I am trying to expalin.
My question to you is why T Series has not given credit to LP for the Ek Hasina Thi. If you have brought the rights there is no necessary to give credit to original singer and original lyrics writter. Song Belongs to the company now they are the owner. They have paid for it.
Same way T Series Does not require to give credit to Kally becuase according to T Series they are the owner of the song . They have the copyrights with them.
Anuradha thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#78
Now coming to proving that this is all publicity stunt.. When you, a comman man can know that music company owns the rights for the song - im sure even Kally, a musician will definitely know about this rule.. Right?? So, if he had any doubts then he should have contacted T-Series for clarification and not sue a case on Himesh and Sameer... I think this is what anyone would follow... We all know what happens in the industry for publicity...

Now coming to even Reema's comments on this is publicity for Kally and not Himesh - We know Himesh comes up with some or the other publicity stunt for himself.. Its not publicity for SRGMP as they have their own publicity stunts with their extreme Himesh touched drama 😉 If Kally had sued a case against Himesh and T-Series didn't require the publicity they would have easily sorted the case with Kally rather than coming up in the media... It could have easily solved in 4 rooms and not in the news channels covering up this as the hot news... 😉

So, that proves its the publicity..

Now if it is lifted or not - Himesh talked about all the songs in that article.. He mentioned about 7 other songs so what would he have lost if he had mentioned about this original song composer?? Well, why would he?? He has lifted it - so why does he need to mention about the lift??

vijaykkk thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#79

Originally posted by: Anuradha

Now coming to proving that this is all publicity stunt.. When you, a comman man can know that music company owns the rights for the song - im sure even Kally, a musician will definitely know about this rule.. Right?? So, if he had any doubts then he should have contacted T-Series for clarification and not sue a case on Himesh and Sameer... I think this is what anyone would follow... We all know what happens in the industry for publicity...

Now coming to even Reema's comments on this is publicity for Kally and not Himesh - We know Himesh comes up with some or the other publicity stunt for himself.. Its not publicity for SRGMP as they have their own publicity stunts with their extreme Himesh touched drama 😉 If Kally had sued a case against Himesh and T-Series didn't require the publicity they would have easily sorted the case with Kally rather than coming up in the media... It could have easily solved in 4 rooms and not in the news channels covering up this as the hot news... 😉

So, that proves its the publicity..

Now if it is lifted or not - Himesh talked about all the songs in that article.. He mentioned about 7 other songs so what would he have lost if he had mentioned about this original song composer?? Well, why would he?? He has lifted it - so why does he need to mention about the lift??

Himesh has not mention about any song .
Read mumbai mirror
Himesh only said he has composed 7 songs.
Edited by vijaykkk - 16 years ago
Anuradha thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#80

Originally posted by: vijaykkk

.

AKS movie realised on june 29 2007
Himesh and Ashaji conterversy on Mehbooba Song was on Nov 24 2007
If any one wants proof I am ready to post.
Now please any one tell me how a conterversy which happened on 24 nov 2007 has benifted a movie which was realised on June 29 2007. ?????????????????



I asked the same question when the controversy happened... When the music got released long back, then how come Ashaji didn't know about it while this song was all over on the television and radio?? So now that proves that it was all for publicity stunt... People forgot the song, they needed to be reminded.. How can that happen?? This is the only way to do it...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".