NAVARASA:The Series-- # 2 UP on Pg 13! Vibhatsa (Disgust)

napstermonster thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#1


[HIDDEN CONTENT]
The content of this post has been Hidden by User.

Created

Last reply

Replies

158

Views

25.8k

Users

105

Likes

824

Frequent Posters

niyoti thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
I have never read anything on this forum that has reduced me to tears.. I can recall exactly 4 times where a piece of writing had reduced me to tears. This is the fifth. There are honest to godness tears streaming down my face right now.. This was heart breaking..

There are so many. SO MANY things i love about this brilliant piece.

The anticipation and pace of the raid.My heart was in my mouth. I thought she wouldn't leave with Rudra. I thought she wouldn't ever be free. This is one of the few times I've pleaded with a fictional character.

Nandini heard her name for the first time in nine months during the third police raid at the Kotha.

She had been reborn into someone disgusting inside the womb of the earth room.

This. The period of time. 9 months. So apt for a rebirth.. She was taken against her will and moulded into something, someone she no longer recognises.. She reminds me of prisoners who are free after serving a long term. Once they get used to a routine in there, the pseudo safety, if you will, of those prison walls, they find it hard to readjust in the real world. A world that has long forgotten them and moved on. I remember reading an article that stated that a good percentage of criminals get back to prison just for that feeling of familiarity. That she would think she is better off in that brothel and than back home is just...

Eyes she thought she had seen before, in another lifetime, on the face of a woman she had thought was a goddess come to life. The woman who was married to the monster of Birpur.

Eyes she recognized, burning within a face that she didn't.

She felt lightheaded- A BSD man and handsome? It was amusing. But true

Her incredulity at discovering that BSD had come looking for her. Just when she thought the aftershocks from the wreckage of her disastrous wedding had ceased, just when she thought she had pulled herself clear of the ruins and rubble of her dreams and the echos from her previous life had been silenced, her view is changed once more.

Her trust issues with the BSD linger and yet she goes with the officers.. My heart breaks to think of what might've gone through her (or any other woman in her place) mind. The thought of what more could she lose? Her life was in ruins already.

Her feelings of immense gratitude and that attraction one has to their rescuer. Is there a term for it? Hero worship? Reverse of stockholm would be lima.. I can't find a term for this phenomenon. But it is so real.

When she is repeatedly taught a lesson for trying to escape and her spirit broken in the process. Those lessons take. Hope is lost and she begins to find little things to comfort her in her new life. I s'pose that is how the human mind works when trying to cope with trauma. Priorities change and what once seemed so important seem like a far away dream, from another lifetime.Stolkholm syndrome?

When she is finally rescued, my heart aches for how she frantically washes and cleans herself. I can imagine her dispair even in freedom. Her body is cleanesed. But what of her soul?

Vibhatsa.

A heart wrenching insight into the psyche of a victim,this piece coveys the irony of the first Navarasa of the series.

Vibhatsa.

Not for her. Not ever for her. Or the countless nameless, faceless women who endure such brutality, but for the people responsible for it,for breaking and mocking something as strong as the human spirit. I want to wail and beat my fists at the world, somebody, anybody for what those women go through.

This is a fantastic piece to kick start the endevour.

LOTS of love. And admiration.

N
Edited by niyoti - 11 years ago
What_the thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
Unres-ed..
When someone writes about Rudra.. or about Paro.. our mind combines what we read, with what we already know of these characters.
We all watch the show ardently and are so connected to these two..
We know what they look like, we can imagine them in the scenario the writer chooses to put them in, we can feel their emotions with relative ease.

But Nandini..
We know nothing of her.. except that she has vanished sarhad-paar a year ago.
There is no face that we can put to this name...
I randomly mention her in OS-es as Paro's childhood companion, then forget about her.

We had only your words to rely on...and you did not disappoint for a single moment..

With your poignant use of language, you conjured vivid images of a hapless, innocent, village girl - scared and confused at first, balking at the thought of selling her body, trying to escape, calling for help.. and then you showed us how she gradually, changed into a hardened, unemotional woman, benumbed by the situation she finds herself in, resigned to her fate.

She may have been helpless and lost at first. But she learned to take care of herself and of the two other girls. She will do what she has to, to survive.
She is so impassive and cold now - that jail bores her, instead of scaring her.
She turns to cards and beedi to distract herself.
All of this was so well expressed in the below lines.

..all that concerned her was not the mirage of rescue, but the reality of avoiding punishment.

The boredom of getting lined up against a wall, getting barked at, spit on, then fingerprinted at the local station had been quite irritating..

...left inside the lock-up for two entire days, without even a pack of cards or any beedis or paan to relieve the monotony.

The way you described the creepy, contaminated, forsaken interiors of the brothel had me shuddering at the thought that such a place should exist on the face of the same planet where we live. My skin crawled to read the way the girls were manhandled in that place.

And the disgust.
Human beings are selfish by nature. They mostly find it hard to even accept that they are wrong.
Self-disgust is a very difficult emotion to feel.
And yet, you admirably portrayed her feelings, her revulsion at her own self - so much so that I cringed, tamping down an urge to weep, as my heart went out to Nandini.
Her physically scrubbing away at her skin, in an attempt to rid herself of the grime is in vain as she feels unclean deep inside..

She is finally free, but her soul has been imprisoned in the dank confines of the kotha and she is left with nothing but disgust at what she has become.


I wondered why there was no Paro in this update.
But then I thought, given Nandini's current state of mind, the poor girl may not have been able to selflessly dredge up joy at Paro's good fortune...her loving, handsome, brave, BSD officer husband.
So it was best that she did not confront Paro, it would have caused more heartache.

The dark, damp underground room - the womb-like environs, where Nandini felt safe, cocooned from the world that she was once a part of...where she had been reborn...amazing metaphor.

The below parts just stood out for me...such skillful use of words Navin-sa. Loved it.

That lilting accent brought to her mind the image of topaz hills, of sandstorms and thunder, vast empty miles and free eagles soaring the endless horizons of her home.

She drifted, a small speck of dirt in a large sea of new experiences.

..until the water ran pink with her raw, abraded skin.

She was the Nandini who had not come to the sound of her own name.


I am an escapist by nature.. I prefer to avoid the harsh realities of life as they disturb me too much.
But I wouldn't have missed this for the world...it is one of the most moving pieces that I have come across in a long time..

This is an incredibly brilliant start to the Navarasa series and like Niyoti said, I hope that this high standard of writing, urges all other writers to put their best foot forward.

Lots of love,
Maya

PS: I hope that I did not push someone to Page 2 with the length of my comment.
Apologies in advance!

Edited by What_the - 11 years ago
_SenbonZakura_ thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
Navin-Sa, can I ask why you even thought that this was crap?

I have tears rolling down my face. My chest feels heavy. And I feel like throwing up after reading this.

This piece was goosebumps inducing. And I don't remember reading anything that has made my skin crawl like this did.


The only line that remained throughout with me, was how she didn't come when being called her own name.

I honest to god am bawling my eyes out right now. And I don't want to write anything more.

This vibhatsa has made so many negative emotions swirl inside me, I think I am gonna wallow for days to come.

And even though this brought out exactly the emotions it was aimed for, I couldn't help re-reading it.


You evoke powerful emotions Navin-sa. Not everyone can do that.

If I ever hear you doubting yourself on this forum... I'll straight away beat you up. Bas.


Goddammit. This piece will break records.


Edited by _SenbonZakura_ - 11 years ago
chotidesi thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
Navin Di, taaliyan. You deserve endless, endless standing ovations.
Every bit of your writing invokes so much emotion. The hairy hands groping at her breasts made me shudder, made the bile come up. Nandini's anguish- and the confusion she feels- is so well defined.

For me, the strongest part of this OS was when she scrubs at herself to rid herself of the grime, but finds that it's almost... comforting in a way. Her old life, her life in the brothel is something she knows- she's comfortable with, as disgusting and terrible as it is.

For her, that's the only life she knows- she's been away from herself for so long that she's redefined herself as filth, as the scum of the Earth. It's just- heartwrenchingly painful, and it truly did bring tears to my eyes.


I'm just in awe of you. Every time. I cannot express how much this oneshot impacted me. What a fabulous, moving start.
Edited by chotidesi - 11 years ago
Javeria3991 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
WOW WOW WOW WOW WOW WOW WOW WOW WOW
This was superb, hats off to you for writing such a master piece, I haven't read anything so deep and emotional on RR forum.
Love the way you wrote down the journey of nandani from a blushing innocent bride to Vibhatsa. Reading her terrifying and sad story was like going through a novel which totally got me hooked.
Poor nandani, in her initial days she lived in immense hope to be save by someone but her hope was too crush and she became lifeless, her soul shattered, a body without heart and conscience who was left for vultures to take pleasure from her.
The treatment with girls living in red light areas is really disgusting and her story is perfect for the title.
Rukhsar was very brave, she didn't let nandani to loose her only chance to freedom though for nandani it was another life long imprisonment where she will no longer be the baisa of birpur whom used to be colorful and full of life. Her life was destroyed.
This sentence caught my most attention and is my favorite sentence and made my heart cry She was reborn into this name, and from now on, she would always be-- Vibhatsa.
This one shot is Fabolous.
Very well written.
👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏
Edited by Javeria3991 - 11 years ago
-NatureLover- thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
OH MY GOD!!!

And this is what you call crap???!!
I mean seriously ...where is your dictionary???

This was just brilliant...simply superb!!!
No better way to describe the disgust...this is the sheer feeling of disgust...the disgust we feel for ourselves...no other way to describe it more aptly...

I can never imagine anyone living the life the way Nandini had lived for nine months...I would have given up long back...

But your writing??? Oh My God!!! It was like I was reading some Novel...Can I request you something????
Please with due respect..leave your current job and take a job of full time writer...I am serious...
the scenario you craft with your words..it gives us goosebumps...the way to terrorize us with your words...YES! you terrorize because thats what I felt when Nandini was not ready to come out of her hiding place...I was like come on get up...go...someone is looking for you...and you build that tension with your words..


Just superb!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


But I felt really bad for Nandini...I know it's not easy BUT if you get a second chance than do try to make full use of it...



Love you Navin-ji🤗


Sambhavi...
Edited by tic-tac - 11 years ago
Jaz1990 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
You are lucky too be so talented! Bravooo naps !

I actually stopped reading, didn't think I could go on, then forced myself to read on! It was just so heart wrenching to see nandini in such a situation! Her pain her anger. Seriously I don't have enough words to express how amazing dis is!
Edited by Jaz1990 - 11 years ago
DiyaS thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
No words ...
Just ... AWESOME 👏

Can we send this to the writers please? I want to see this in the show.
MissAsian thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
Omg Nandini! This was a intense and dark piece
but so beautifull written
i wonder if they'll ever show Nandini in RR

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".