Pehla Pyar- Rehaan Vs Shaad- Can you compare love? - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

105

Views

5.5k

Users

13

Likes

434

Frequent Posters

chicksoup thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#41
chicksoup thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: Az07


arent they doing the same with sanam now?


NOT AT ALL!😊

Shaad- Jannat si not a love story...It is an illusion. The moment Sanam regains her m,emory, she i snot going to have any of these feelings...because she feels for her 'HUSBAND'- not Shaad...

And the day she knows Shaad is not her husband, the whole equation changes!👏


chicksoup thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: MrDarcyfan

@Soup:

Yes we ALL connected to Rehan and Sanam's story because it was well done. It was well executed and it was nicely portrayed. Through their first tentative chats, to becoming friends, to Rehan supporting her through her issues, to then developing feelings for her and finally deciding to make it official by asking her grandma for her hand, and buying the ring.


THEN the rude awakening when his own Mother gets Sanam married to Aahil! He had no idea Aahil Bhai was harboring many a romantic feeling towards Sanam as well. I think he realised after marriage that maybe Aahil was acting possessive over Sanam. But he knew it was love, when he confronted him and openly showed him his jealousy and displeasure. At the same time, we saw him realise that Sanam also shared Aahil's feelings. SO like a SMART and Mature man would do he realised "They are married, they are in love, now what am I doing here?"


So he left, even as Aahil wanted him to leave. But the decision was his as well. That final "Kuda hafiz Sanam!", as he turns around and looks one last time at Sanam walking on the balcony above, as he leaves IM? That was his Aakri Alvida to his first love. That story was SO beautiful that anyone can appreciate it! That is why I appreciated Rehan with Seher too. Because I could tell he had matured through that experience and used it when he approached his relationship with Seher. Maybe the looks played a part at the start, but soon that didnt really matter!


I cant believe the SAME makers made such a shambles of Shaad and made him the object of so many people's despise! That is THEIR fault. Because we could ALL have felt the same way about Shaad too. Had they given this story even 5% of the honesty they gave the Rehan and Sanam story! Unfortunately they were more embroiled in "superficial" things like trying to "create chemistry" show "cuteness" and playing ASYA BG in a cynical way, that they FORGOT, that a good STORY is what makes people relate to a character or characters. NOT all these fake BS that they were doing. Maybe some people "fall" for all that outward fakeness. But most don't. If they had concentrated on the "story" aspect and given Shaad a better characterization, like they did to Rehan, then HE would also have got the same level of appreciation from people. The fact that people just dismiss him harshly, is the makers fault. Plain and simple!


Mandy,

Point to ponder:

Why do U think he has been written this way?😳

Is it because they can't write a decent story..or is it because they really want Sanam in the CLUTCHES of her 'HUSBAND' when she meets Ahil now?

And they don't want the husband to be evil...but misinformed...misguided...Because they are done with possessiveness and obsessiveness with Faiz...Now is the time to add an immature , yet innocent guy stupidly complicating a love story?
MrDarcyfan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#44
@Soup:
He is NOT innocent. But he is immature. Coz no one really "Mature" would have taken the sort of risks he has! He has brought a strange girl to his house and had her living with him ALL these weeks! Has NO idea who she is! She could have been anyone. A spy, a terrorist, a killer, even SK! This could have been HER plot to come to his house, so she can steal all the info he has on SK!

The same thing the REAL SK is doing right now, could have been done by THIS girl! I heard she calls the authorities. Again Tanveer calling Indian immigration! Do they even have ONE original idea in their heads? Airport proposal? Or will it be "Bus stop?" LOL. The point is, they are supposed to be "married?" So how on earth can he propose and keep her? Other point is immigration will ask for marriage cert? Where will he get that?


He really IS immature and foolish as well! Coz the way he dealt with this? He will surely land himself in jail!
chicksoup thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: MrDarcyfan

@Soup:

He is NOT innocent. But he is immature. Coz no one really "Mature" would have taken the sort of risks he has! He has brought a strange girl to his house and had her living with him ALL these weeks! Has NO idea who she is! She could have been anyone. A spy, a terrorist, a killer, even SK! This could have been HER plot to come to his house, so she can steal all the info he has on SK!

The same thing the REAL SK is doing right now, could have been done by THIS girl! I heard she calls the authorities. Again Tanveer calling Indian immigration! Do they even have ONE original idea in their heads? Airport proposal? Or will it be "Bus stop?" LOL. The point is, they are supposed to be "married?" So how on earth can he propose and keep her? Other point is immigration will ask for marriage cert? Where will he get that?


He really IS immature and foolish as well! Coz the way he dealt with this? He will surely land himself in jail!


Jail is only for the leads...and since he is not, he will not be in jail...I suppose Sanam could be...😆

Anyway, the police cannot touch him since he has the immunity his status offers...and the Army si not going to touch him...because I feel that is not what the story is about.

So what happened to real Misbah!😲

😆 He can't even save his own cousin and aunt from the clutches of his sworn enemy...

Yes. Immature...Stupid...Naive...But not negative.

He has a one track mind...HE SEES ONLY HIS SIDE OF THE STORY...and sees Sanam's side as and when it suits him.

But it is actually sad for Jannat...She knows only him...and has pinned all her hopes on this guy...and this happens...and he comes for her again! Further jannatification coming up!🥱
MrDarcyfan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#48
@Soup:
If further "Jinnatification" happens, I think she should just bloody well stay in Pak with her brainless dud head. I really cant STAND her, and dont think I can suffer watching her for much longer! Just LEAVE her there with Shayar and show us AAHIL's second love story!

TOO bored to care about the fake love story of a liar and a dud!
chicksoup thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#49

Originally posted by: MrDarcyfan

@Soup:

If further "Jinnatification" happens, I think she should just bloody well stay in Pak with her brainless dud head. I really cant STAND her, and dont think I can suffer watching her for much longer! Just LEAVE her there with Shayar and show us AAHIL's second love story!

TOO bored to care about the fake love story of a liar and a dud!


🤣 Mandy,

U R not supposed to feel for them! 😆

U can feel for poor Jannat who has half her brain missing, being dragged away from lie to more lies...and fiction...Shaad will start writing a fiction on his life with Jannat soon...and pretty soon believe it all happened, including the gubbare..(Joking.😉)


The lines of fiction and reality are getting blurred for him...😉

And U could feel for poor Ahil...😳

That is all U R supposed to feel for- Two lovers separated by fate!😲

😉

Yes, it is dragging..it will...until they meet.

KhatamKahani thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#50

Originally posted by: chicksoup


Jail is only for the leads...and since he is not, he will not be in jail...I suppose Sanam could be...😆

Anyway, the police cannot touch him since he has the immunity his status offers...and the Army si not going to touch him...because I feel that is not what the story is about.

So what happened to real Misbah!😲

😆 He can't even save his own cousin and aunt from the clutches of his sworn enemy...

Yes. Immature...Stupid...Naive...But not negative.

He has a one track mind...HE SEES ONLY HIS SIDE OF THE STORY...and sees Sanam's side as and when it suits him.

But it is actually sad for Jannat...She knows only him...and has pinned all her hopes on this guy...and this happens...and he comes for her again! Further jannatification coming up!🥱


Soup, yes he only sees his side of the story. Meaning there is something not right with his head. He is living in a delusional world.He is not negative you are right, he is emotionally or mentally imbalanced in some ways. Maybe we would feel sorry for that, but makers give no reason to.

There is no need for us to feel sorry for him or try to understand him. Is my point. Because the makers don't bother to try to explain him. So why should we try to understand or feel sorry for him or what not...

We just don't care. And the makers don't really care about him either, because they are not developing him well. So he is just a means for them to set up and shape their story. That is all.

Just read the above post. Yup, we are not supposed to feel for him for the most part.. So why bother trying to understandhim or trying to explain away his actions or make excuses or what not... He is what he is. 🤪A tool.😆


Edited by KhatamKahani - 10 years ago

Related Topics

Qubool Hai thumbnail

Posted by: nushhkiee · 7 months ago

Theme - Theme 1 : The Bag (Graphicer - WildestDreams) The Weight of Love The rain drummed softly against the glass windows of the airport, a...

Expand ▼
Qubool Hai thumbnail

Posted by: minakrish · 8 months ago

A dream come true for AsYa fans, Karan and Surbhi have once again reunited. This time for an ad campaign for Zouk Bags! (Details: HERE ) This...

Expand ▼
Qubool Hai thumbnail

Posted by: missFiesty_69 · 7 months ago

AsYa OS - Love, Lies and a Spilled Latte

This is one of the entries I had submitted for Valentine's Day contest - A bag full of love . cover : ExoticDisaster aka Shiri | writer :...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".