How the cvs failed Shaad! Mod Note Pg 2 - Page 5

Mandy.

@Soup:





More than Shaad, the excusing and white washing of his actions offends me!

Did u forget how sehar was made sanam infront of aahil nd how he used to get romantically close to her.if seher wasn't in love with rehan they would have even shown a sisters triangle I guess with seher also falling for aahil.what I meant to say was that QH is always showcasing pathetic relationships which ethically are not correct nd watching such pairs also make u feel disgusted.shaad till I saw the episode was tryin to find aahil I guess but now according to discussions here it seems he has turned his decision of finding aahil nd give jannat her family.I seriously think what will be sanams reaction after her memory is returned will she be able to forgive herself thinking she stayed with another man as his wife.I don't thinl there was any need of pak track they would have shown sanam in Indian itself trying to find her identitu doing some chef job nd meets aahil coincidentally nd again falls for him.there love story would have been renewed.and her knowing that he is married to witch nd guilty feelings ,passion,angst,pain etc the track could have been soo intrrsting nd v would have got soo much off sahil 🥱

Originally posted by: MrDarcyfan

@Soup:

I never saw Geet. But I heard about that Maan's brother forgiven part, and some fans said they thought it was disgusting! So I guess opinions are divided! But since I never saw the story, I dont know how I would have felt.

As for Rehan? Yeah, not coming clean with Aahil was always a sticking point. It always worked against Rehan's character. Not telling Seher about how he liked Sanam? Also, not a good move. But then they gave him the death of a hero, and made him the Hero of Season 2. I actually liked him a lot, with his flaws, coz I understood his dilemma. Tanveer was his Mother and the bond of a parent and child is not easily broken! It's a very grey issue. We sometimes stay loyal to our parents, even when they DON'T deserve it. Both Rehan and Aahil stayed loyal to that piece of trash! Two boys who's lives she ruined and who's love she NEVER deserved! The tragic story of Tanveer and her two son's was the biggest drama of Season 2 and the story I loved the most. Even though I loved SAHIL and even SEHAN, AHAAN and their wretched Mum was the actual drama of Season 2.

As for Shaad? Hero he is not. Villain? Only time will tell. Psycho? Not at this stage. But living in "pretend universe?" Yes. Too much poetry? Yes again. Even though he is an Army man, I think he has a very dramatic, theatrical side which he must have got from his Mum. It appears he has difficulty differentiating between Real and Fake? How he has now abandoned ANY moral dilemma about keeping this girl trapped shows me that he can easily forget what is right and wrong for his convenience! Those are signs of an unhinged mind. I honestly don't think he is quite "there!". Because how he just "Fell" into this pretend husband thing almost head first, and then started to "Believe" it, indicates to me that he has some issues he needs to resolve!

More than Shaad, the excusing and white washing of his actions offends me!

Originally posted by: farru786

Did u forget how sehar was made sanam infront of aahil nd how he used to get romantically close to her.if seher wasn't in love with rehan they would have even shown a sisters triangle I guess with seher also falling for aahil.what I meant to say was that QH is always showcasing pathetic relationships which ethically are not correct nd watching such pairs also make u feel disgusted.shaad till I saw the episode was tryin to find aahil I guess but now according to discussions here it seems he has turned his decision of finding aahil nd give jannat her family.I seriously think what will be sanams reaction after her memory is returned will she be able to forgive herself thinking she stayed with another man as his wife.I don't thinl there was any need of pak track they would have shown sanam in Indian itself trying to find her identitu doing some chef job nd meets aahil coincidentally nd again falls for him.there love story would have been renewed.and her knowing that he is married to witch nd guilty feelings ,passion,angst,pain etc the track could have been soo intrrsting nd v would have got soo much off sahil 🥱

SheAish , mandy and soup other thing i hv realized is that these writers are not capable of writing a "grey shaded character" eithet they write up total white or total black ... When they tried to write "Grey" they could not do justice ...

@soup,

@Mischy:

Originally posted by: micshy

Soup 👍🏼 i just reading ur perpective, its always so much fun n insightful at the same time...

I dont know why but i always ebd up quoting u n reply u cz i love having a discussion with u 😳

About Rehan, ditto. I hv liked Rehan, but have never gone crazy fr him, he was a character that was here since the beginning so the emotional attachment is one cause, secondly he was also not the goody guy as he was initially portrayed ... He had his share of character flaws n weaknesses, n i accepted those as his character weakness like every body has but still liked him despite those weaknesses , just like Aahil ( they r poles apart but still both r dear though i love Aahil n only like Rehan)

The fact that he was in love with Sanam is a fact that was not dealt with n was brushed asode fr the sake of another romance, a big big reason i was not able to connect to SeHan love story ... Why it was passed on to as infatuation??? I never got, what we saw Rehan's feelings n intentions regarding Sanam were genuine so it shoukd hv been given a proper closure... Ok he might have not seen Sanam in Seher n he loved her fr what she was but that should hv been depicted. One day we were watching him rememberibg Sanam by looking at Seher and the next day we saw him giving "loooks" to her , thats not how u conbect with a romance. Then his feelings fr Sanan were never brought out i would hv personally loved if Rehan befire confessing to Seher had told her about Sanam but that was never given importance so i was never able to connect with their story, i found them cute afterwards but simply could never feel the way fr them like i wiuld hv felt fr a couple madly in love with each other

Him leaving fr Dubai, well that was again a silly move by the writers ... Domething that cannot be related to...

Rehaan's death was although so heartbreaking but a poetic justice , ,,, write up was great cz it was "the best n most horrible punishment" for Tanveer, getting her kill her own son the one fr whom she has actually claimed to do everything ... N then getting mad fr it, that was the best punishment fr her.

But due to AG's insistence fr thr change of track this brilliant write up was wasted... I know KV gas been blamed by all n sundry fr the change of the tracks regarding season 3 but it was infact AG who put her foot forward n dint want to play a mad character. So she asked the majers to let the character tanveer die n she be brought back as a fresh character.. Thats how season 3 came into existence , ,,,,,, SaHil wrre never their priority n Shaad has come on as a collateral damage,

The whole premise of season 3 has been laid on a wrong foundation... Shaad n SK are the poorly etched out characters cz honestly theres no base to them, neither they appear relatable ...

All of this was done to glorify AG n her character once more...

Thats what i hv concluded from all this drama...