I'm sorry but I'll NEVER get over the fact that...

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

sanju

@Sanju_

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#31

lemme copy-paste this again for you😆

hmmm you failed to see the big picture here...Asad was being practical, clever, and reasonable there!! if he had shouted to save Zoya or run to save her, those goons would have killed asad and zoya right then and right there...but asad acted so smartly...he quietly went to the bus station, because he knew he wouldn't be able to fight so many people, all armed with guns and weapons...he knew he would be able to come back to save zoya and that's what he did...I am so glad that Asad was being so practical at that moment and not an emotional fool😊

Quote

Teja....

@Teja....

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#32

very nice opinions

for me it looked like a very nice scene but PH should have shown something asad thinking abt the plan while going out of the sight with goons i felt like asad thinking what he has to do next. if he resisted they definitely will fallow asad to make sure he reached bhopal or not(in my view)he did what exactly a person do in that type of situations.

some are saying he is angry man he dnt know what he doing in angry mode but he def calculative when he handling situations u can observe that he analyzing every thing first he is feeling guilt for not listening zoya after that he observing every situation what is going on his back so he could come and rescue when the van went out of sight he did only one thing that run back its not realization guys its just he is waiting for that but i disappointing that PH should have at least show some of his thoughts at correct time.

and some are saying he didnt pleaded for zoya.he pleaded he asked for zoya that she saved ur daughter life then y u doing this to her after that only mamu told everything iam mean truth after that he also said he he got mariyam then he thinking to leave zoya that means the decision is made that they are not going to leave her. so he moved with then but i also felt he could have pleaded one more time but i guess asad calculating all and guns are there around him

and guys one more thing we all want to see realistic things in shows now they are showing it then we have to accept that ri8 iam not opposing ur opinion iam just saying my point of u. how many days we will see hero fighting with goons who have guns and all seeing realistic make sense ri8 iam sorry if it apposing any ones opinion but i want to share this ya

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

princessjojo

@princessjojo

Dazzler

+ 6

Posted: 12 years ago

#33

I don't understand your first sentence. Why not?

As for the second one, yeah time will tell. More realistically, it can be a combination of guilt and heart instead of one vs. another.

Quote

Rockerchic

@Rockerchic

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#34

Originally posted by: enchanted.

👏I agree with everything you just said! Especially ^. People are talking about realism and Asad being practical..umm..ok..where did this sudden practicality come from?! we've never seen it before!

It's not about practicality. It's easy to say that you'll save someone unconscious when you have a gun to your head.

But to be in that situation, you think about returning to your family alive in one piece and basically think about yourself only.

It was wrong of Asad. No denying there. But I guess what I'm saying is I liked that he was wrong. If that makes any sense.

Edited by Rockerchic - 12 years ago

Quote

princessjojo

@princessjojo

Dazzler

+ 6

Posted: 12 years ago

#35

Basically, to summarize, we have 3 POVs:

-Asad was right in doing the right thing

-Asad was right (human) in doing the wrong thing (spade a spade POV)

-Asad was wrong in doing the wrong thing

Quote

sanju

@Sanju_

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#36

like you yourself said, this is just a TV show and that is why asad said whatever he said...the things with I wish I never knew you...blah blah...they wanted to "connect" asad saying "I hope you go away from my life" to her near escape...hence, such harsh dialogue from Asad...I know Asad was wrong in not listening to Zoya at all..I felt like ughhh but that is to show his guilt later on since this is a TV show...

now you tell me, Asad actually saw the hand of the bride who was killed and buried there...he already got the idea that those goons could do anything for their egos...these goons aren't the same kinds of goons he had fought before...when he saved Zoya, those were more like eve-teasers, when he saved Ayaan, he was fighting with the so-called police but today it was all different...he was fighting with those goons, whose hurt egos are mended only and only by "killing" people and this actually still happens in some rural areas in India...I was appalled when I watched Satyamavev zayate's episode on this issue!!!

You feel bad for zoya, I do too...but I don't seen an ounce of reason to blame asad for not struggling to save her in front of goons...but yup, I do blame him that he didn't listen to Zoya...but again on his defense, they were chased by goons to kill them, so it's kinda understandable that Asad would be very angry and be kinda unreasonable as well!!! (just my POV)

Quote

Rockerchic

@Rockerchic

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#37

Originally posted by: princessjojo
I don't understand your first sentence. Why not?

As for the second one, yeah time will tell. More realistically, it can be a combination of guilt and heart instead of one vs. another.

Then why show him leave? To realise he feels something for Zoya, that was the point right?

If he was humane then like people mentioned they could have shown him planning etc while he was being silent.

Quote

nebuna

@nebuna

Sparkler

Posted: 12 years ago

#38

Originally posted by: KulfiBai
...Asad was walking away with his Mamu and Gang, leaving an unconscious Zoya with the kameenay gunday 😡

Realism is good. It's all good. But in real life I would NEVER leave my unconscious house-guest (or any innocent person for that matter) alone in the jungle with KAMEENAY GUNDAY WHO POSSESS GUNS AND WHATNOT OH AND DID I MENTION SHOVELS, AND THEN LEAVE SAID INNOCENT PERSON, ARRIVE AT THE HIGHWAY, SUDDENLY REALIZE, "OH, actually, no, I don't want her dead" AND THEN DECIDE TO GO LOOK FOR HER, KNOWING SHE'S PROBABLY BEEN BURIED ALIVE ALREADY.

Bull. To the Shit.

I wanted him to fight against the gunday for the sake of HUMANITY.

@bold exactly even i was thinking of the same while watching
realism fine ok to an extent i thought you want to save her for that
you need to be safe so asad moved out
but at least while moving out in car
he should have been suffering with an uneasy feeling for leaving a girl behind
but no he just felt confused
again he was waiting to deliver that dialogue
mein aise marne nei doonga
and then ran
but once he reaches the spot he shouts like maniac
think there is no continuation in story telling or his feelings

@blue that is one thing which i expected

along with that humaira has slit open her wrist
and the family is watching her as if they are watching a show 😕
should nt they be running into to save her

Edited by nebuna - 12 years ago

Quote

Rockerchic

@Rockerchic

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#39

Originally posted by: princessjojo
Basically, to summarize, we have 3 POVs:

-Asad was right in doing the right thing

-Asad was right (human) in doing the wrong thing (spade a spade POV)

-Asad was wrong in doing the wrong thing

That sums it up 😃

Which one are you?