Prithvi: Was He Really That Noble? - Page 2

Originally posted by: merry911

I thought someone said Inchini was Bhimdev's niece and Prithvi's wife.

she was bhim's sister-in-law n later on when prc defeted bhim, raja jain most probably inchini's father offer his daughter 2 prc n they got married 🤢

I DON'T THINK THAT IT WAS WRONG AT ALL...YES,PROBABLY,the idea of getting back to Jaichand would have APPEALED to PRC...BUT,HE TRULYYY LOVEDD HER....I MEANN...COME ONN...HE HAD STARTED TO NEGLECT HIS STATE DUTIES FOR HERR...WHO DOES THAT IF HE DID NOT ACTUALLY REALLYYY & TRULYY LOVE HER???? yess,he wasn't the epitome of nobility...He kidnapped 3 OF HIS WIVES [:x] [:x] ..BUT NO-ONE CAN DENY THE FACT THAT HE WAS A VERYYYY NOBLE,KIND,FORGIVING(HELLOOOO?? HE FORGAVE THAT GHORI [:x] [:x] [:x] 17 TIMES?! WUTT DO U CALL THAT??!) & a CHIVALROUS (there are MANYY instances..but the most prominent one being...Ghori's bro; Hussain was in LOVE with a VERYYY beautiful dancer (forgetting her name) who LOVEDD him back too...It was PRC who helped her escape so that she could be with her Love...Noww...He could have easilyy married her..but he was a VERYYY Chivalrous King [:$] [:$] )ruler....& Sanyo did not EVER INVITE Prithvi to her Swayamvar...They both made this plan TOGETHER....That PRC will come to the Swayamvar & take her away

4 sum ppl yes and others no but me..hmm...maybe yess

sara

hmm yeah cool points

but if you was just a random person... i mean like latifa di said peoples lives did get taken..if you was like the family of those people...people of kannauj etc..so prithvi actually did weaken his kingdom by doing tht...and yeah sanyo wanted prithvi to take her away...but it did still weaken ajmer

Originally posted by: Jattinder!

hmm yeah cool points

but if you was just a random person... i mean like latifa di said peoples lives did get taken..if you was like the family of those people...people of kannauj etc..so prithvi actually did weaken his kingdom by doing tht...and yeah sanyo wanted prithvi to take her away...but it did still weaken ajmer

ya i also mean it. tat war was not 4 the country. it was sm1's personal need. prc lost many good general in tat war which weaken his war force. n of course i m thinking those soldiers who gave up their life 4 their raja. now don't want 2 ny more as people has different point of view. but i lov my family members n don't like they die 4 other's lov story.

Originally posted by: avtab

ya i also mean it. tat war was not 4 the country. it was sm1's personal need. prc lost many good general in tat war which weaken his war force. n of course i m thinking those soldiers who gave up their life 4 their raja. now don't want 2 ny more as people has different point of view. but i lov my family members n don't like they die 4 other's lov story.

true! but then times were different then. they didnt have a proper civil justice system like courts etc. the king was the judge and the jury. the king's life/prestige was more important than the lives of ordinary ppl. i am not justifying the deaths of the ppl who helped prc and sanyo elope. but that was the situation then.

Hey u all are simply great.....👏
I m njoying this discussion..... plz continue.....
I haven't read raso or any literature so can't comment much.

Originally posted by: kshreya2002

true! but then times were different then. they didnt have a proper civil justice system like courts etc. the king was the judge and the jury. the king's life/prestige was more important than the lives of ordinary ppl. i am not justifying the deaths of the ppl who helped prc and sanyo elope. but that was the situation then.

yeahh but even if the king was the judical system judge etc it doesnt mean that you actually like him?

its like your teachers, you might not like them but you still listen to them. If there is enough people though you start to play up (usually) its kinda similar...if you listen to your king who you dont actually like. Eventually when there is more of you you can form a mutiny..so say the army people they could refuse to fight at the last minute causing ajmer loss.

and why didnt the people of Ajmer hate sanyogita? or did they? its like after they find out that she left her kingdom. i mean they probably wouldnt think of it as she loved prithvi their king..but she betrayed her father, she chose our king some one that she didnt know over her own father the man that brought her up.

People of Ajmer wouldnt of even known the complete truth because so many peopel would have speculated.

Some people might have felt ashamed of their king for doing that, they might blame Prithvi for taking Sanyogita (even though he didnt) saying that she is a young girl and beign a girl didnt know what she was doing aswell..it was prithvi that led her on the wrong path?

so surely by thinking of all this then we can say that prithvi and sanyogita marrying did weaken ajmer and give him more enemies, right?

Originally posted by: ppiyu

Hey u all are simply great.....👏
I m njoying this discussion..... plz continue.....
I haven't read raso or any literature so can't comment much.

i havent either..im just in one of those historical moments hahaha

so join in 😉

Ya,U could be right,Jyots...But also,HOWW WOULD ANYY OF THIS BE RELEVANT TO THE PPL OF AJMER IF PRC HAD NOT NEGLECTED THE STATE AFFAIRS?? IT WOULDN'T HAVEE...SEE...The first priority that a King has is to his Kingdom...Which,after marrying Sanyo,PRC had started dismissing...SO,THIS could have resulted in feelings of animosity towards PRC(COULD BE) & Sanyo(could be too)...Otherwise,IF he had attended to the State affairs like always,his Kingdom would not have bothered at alll...It all just stems.from PRC not attending to Ajmer properly....THIS is what (IF IT WAS SOO) would have resultted in hostility of PRC'S Kingdom towards him...AGAIN...WE ARE JUST SPECULATING 😆