Kool's Commentary on today's Episode - Page 7

Created

Last reply

Replies

69

Views

7.9k

Users

15

Likes

96

Frequent Posters

Tanyaz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#61
I agree too , Deshmukhs are notexactly some royal family that they have to have an heir or somethig like that . Manav is more worried about making Girish angry then anything else ..
koolsadhu1000 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#62
Arien dear
I totally disagree .
I want to make some things very clear coz u guys r now harping on the word 'heir '
It is not question of royal family is only interested in the heir business . Why . do u think poor families dont want or are not that interested in their children ? I am talking of the Indian mentality that they r trying to show. Indians r particular that their own child grows up with them only and dont think very broad mindedly of giving it up for adoption.
If u r asking for direct evidence , has evidence of Shravni sleeping with SAchin been shown? But it has been implied that she slept with Sachin and the later story was accepted .
No evidence is shown of their happiness that it is SAchins baby ..........right now they r all under stress as Archna has refused the divorce and this 3 month period and many things r going on . But instead of looking at direct evidence till it comes[ and im sure it will ] .........why dont u guys look at the characters and their mentality to determine if what I am saying makes sense or no ?
SAvita : She always loved SAchin more than Manav .Initially she didnt want Shravnis responsibility , yes , but see how worried she is about the child when Shravni is sick or sumthing .Partly she dances around Shravni coz she is Girish's daughter and is rich ..yes , but only PARTLY . Do u seriously think Archna wud have got this treatment if she was pregnant ? Even after her legal marraige ? I bet you NO . Even in pregnancy Savita wud have ignored her ruthlessy and made her work . The riches fascvinate Savita and also the fact [ not spoken but implied by the characters thought process uptill now ] that it is her SachcHu's baby . Manavs baby wud never get this importance ..ever .
Manav : He wants to pay for Sachins mistake is the evidence .But study his character and answer this question ..........if Shravni decides to even understandingly move out of his and Archus life right now and go to the US to deliver baby ...........with no anger , plain understanding , and even makes Girish understand ..............what do u think Manav wud do ...........grab the opportunity and happily marry ARchana ? Somehow Arien , I as a viewer CANNOT see him doing that . I can see him going on his knees begging her to stay and give them the opprtunity to prioritise her ..........meaning , THE BABY . It never was her , it always was the baby .If Shravni decides to give Manav the baby and go to the US , Manav will immediately turn around and marry ARchu , yes . But somehow I dont see it in the former situation .
Every man wants his own babies only u said ..........Yes , but Manav is not EVERY man . Therein lies the problem . He will want his babies but he is the type who will make his own wife and own baby secondary while bringing up SAchu's child . If tomorrow Savita asks him that when u get ur own baby u will give Sachins child step fatherly treatment so go get an operation done so u cannot have ur own baby , he is perfectly capable of DOING JUST THAT .
So What opined was by studying the implied thought process of each character , not DIRECT EVIDENCE as u guys put it . ANd while doing it , I suggest u guys even study the implied thought process of this INdian mentality shown in this serial uptill now ..........that a woman needs to be 'saved ' by marrying her for honour etc , family is more important than marraige ................Indian mentality is even that our blood is ours after all [ if option is there of marrying ] like in Shravnis case .Otherwise these same typical Indians are shown in serials of throwing baby in orphanage as they abhor slur on name in society . Here the option is very much available [ Shravni marrying Manav] so they r getting both things.........the baby , and a rich gal ...........and hence Archana loses value in their eyes .
addenise thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#63

Originally posted by: carpe-diem

i don't hate shravani so not tomato from me. i don't like her tone and questioning but i guess thats how people act when in love, so i have been told. shravani initially wasn't going to go into the room but savita made it happen. i don't blame anyone for armans situation but arman. as far as varshu is concern yea she should have kept her mouth shut for now. and yes i like ajit too can't help it. but one think i want to see is shravani questioned for sleeping with sachin b4 marriage. she is questioning manav and archu about their relationship then y can't someone question her since it has effected the lives of arman

I am with u too on this...i dont like shravani but i dont hate her...for crying out loud...manav was the one who suggested he will marry her and brought her to his home...his family agreed. Subsequently, she decided (ha ha ha) that she loves the guy...and like any gal in love (besides archana) is doing things to prove her love..for one...being frank and to the point...no beating around the bush...
How can anyone fault her when manav and his family continue to support her. He took her on a date, held her hands........what has he done to demostrate his love for archana ....oh yeaaaa, he keeps looking at her longingly and got jealous when a jerk gave her the dirty look...i love archana but i have to fault her here...what has she done to prove her love...oh yeaaa...went to his house to be ill-treated for three months and cry....(she calls that atonement) jeezzzzz...i think we should stop hating sharavin and start begging CR's to give manav and archana some backbone..
addenise thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#64

Originally posted by: koolsadhu1000

Oh i very much doubt that Manav wud rather much have Archana back and make his own babies . Now this is a point on which I wud very strongly differ with anyone on this forum .
Shravani was stubborn in not wanting to abort the child , yes . But had she planned to get married to Manav ..........did she even know at that point that such a proposal wud come her way ?she was extremely unhappy , disoriented , and wanted to run away from her Dad who was insisting she abort the child . At that point she had come to manav asking for humanatarian help .aasra .....sanctuary .
Manav advised Girish to give in to her obstinacy and then Girish asked him if he wud marry her upon which Manav took a decision.....yes . Ths decision was based on two things.......the knowledge that Shravni wud NOT abort the child and also the fact that idea , once it took root and grew on him that Sachins child was very much gonna come in this world , should then rather be in this DEshmukh home than anywhere else as it was THEIR blood . It is not just Girish's practicality or pressure as u put it ...........Manav took this decision with a great deal of thought . Girish was trying to find the best solution for this situation and manav agreed ....it fitted hand in glove .
Today .........exactly at this point if Shravni decides to leave the house what do u think the picture will be ? Manav will be relieved ?Somehow I just don't see that .I see him running frantically on the roadssearching for her . If what u say is true why did he go running to the doctor to stop the abortion when she decided ? Only coz she was gonna die ? I dont think so .
Manav can indeed procreate and extend the DEshmukh lineage but it wont be sAchin's child or a last memoir of Sachin . Once the idea that Sachins child was gonna live grew on them The Deshmukhs began weaving dreams around the child and all wanted it ...........Manav Savita , Vandu all are of one mind in this . Today if Shravni leaves midway , Manav WONT GO BACK TO ARCHU HE WILL RUN TO GET THE BABY BACK SOMEHOW IN HIS LIFE . He IS very firm on this ...........The baby [ not Shravni] is hs priority NOT ARCHNA.
i only nowwwwwwwww read this posttttttttttttttt..thank u thank u thank u...i guess it is only the two of us who think manav should be held solely accountable for this mess....no one forced him....he is the one who promisedddddddddddd (which is huge) marriage to the poor gal after his tilak....and deserves to have a "hate manav thread" open..yaaaaaaa...never even thought about the kid sister angle...thanks for reminding me...i clearly remembered that episode when he told her how she was like a kid sis to him and blah blah blah..yuukkksss

Arien_03 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#65

I don't think I got your answer… I'll ask again….If Shravani was a poor girl carrying Sachin's child would Savita press Manav to marry her just coz she has their blood growing in her womb or Savita would try to get Manav married to another rich girl so that she can have material gains after marriage.

What you said is true that she loved Sachin more and will give Sachin's wife more importance, that happens all the time in real world. But this is the women, who is getting happy over dead son's insurance money, her greed comes above any other setiments, even above mother's love. Do you really think she is emotionally attached to the child growing in Shravani's womb. When she is trying to make Manav guilty for being with Archana, she only tells abt keeping his promise, she didn't even use Sachin's last memory for emotional blackmail at any time. I ,somehow hv hard time to believe that Savita wants this child at any costs. Even if Shravani offers to give up the child so that the baby will be with Deshmukhs, Savita would try to demand money for upkeep of the child from Girishji. OK, this is a bad scenario for an example, but if Shravani loses her baby , wouldn't Savita still want Shravani to be married to Manav. I say yes.

Tomorrow if Girishji comes and says that he is willing to take care of the child and Savita stops emotional blackmailing and Shravani convinces Manav that she is going to be fine on her own, I doubt Manav will be bent upon to marry Shravani when he knows he is ruining Archana's life by doing so. Or say Shravani falls in love with some other guy and wants to marry him, do you think Manav will stop her just for keeping Sachin's child. Agreed Manav is not EVERY man but he still hv sensitivities for Archana and her family. He went to Varsha's engagement even after being committed to Shravani. He is beginning to warm up to Archana and there will be time when he will understand that he is doing injustice to Archana.

koolsadhu1000 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#66
Let that time come Arien and we shall see . Ill be only too happy to be proven wrong .
Savita may be greedy but she isnt without sentiment .
Her crying when Damodar went missing
Looking after Archu at night
Softness to Punni
She isnt black , she is grey . When it comes to money or Sachins child ......i wont be surprised to see the latter .Her preference will always be money but the child too will matter .
Anyways this is my opinion .To each his own . Am writing todays commentary now .
Arien_03 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#67
Manav gave thought to offering marriage for Shravani only after Girishji asked him a hypothetical question ' Who will marry my daughter now, you tell Manav, will you marry her' .... You say no one forced Manav, I think this question of Girishji was enough to shake Manav and that was the force behind his decision to marry Shravani. If Girishji didn't pressurize Shravani to go for abortion and was ready to take care of the child, Manav would not come forward with the proposal
Tanyaz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#68
Call me a bakri lover ( I have always liked mutton 😆 , sorry bad joke ) , but I loved Archu today .
I loved the way she spoke honestly to the chawl women and trusted them . This girl truely believes that people are generally good and if you give them love and trust then they will do the same for you .
The chawl women were crying and so was I .....😭
I see how she takes Shravani now . She takes her as a young girl , who has made a mistake and has to be helped .
She does not get effected at all by her tantrums and anger ...
She will never ever wish Shravani ill, she loves Manav too much to wish his future wife any ill.....
She thinks that she has destroyed Manav's happiness by not trusting him and now she wants to do whatever she can do to make him happy again ...if he can have a better life with someone else then she will do whatever she can to make it happen .
Baba asked her to ask God for her hak ...I think she will ask for Manav's happiness .
The satish and varsha romance was cute ....
I do wonder who complained .....maybe savita did ...
Edited by Tanyaz - 15 years ago
Arien_03 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#69
Ofcourse Savita has sentiments.... I said her greed comes over her sentiments.... Agreed that her preference will be always money but child too will be matter....... But the argument we were discussing was- Deshmukh blood that Deshmukh wanted very very badly...
I somehow don't see that Manav is marrying Shravani so that Deshmukh blood grows in the family thats all.
Arien_03 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#70

Originally posted by: toothbrush13

In fact, the camera then shows us what Shravani is seeing from the doorway...

Manav looked awesome in white T-shirt and black tracks. Did anyone notice that? His sleepwears are way better than his daytime clothes 😆😆😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".