Kool's Commentary on today's Episode

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

mimas

@mimas

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

#41

Archi is plain stupid and Manav is dumb.. what can we say.. they are being played by others.. they deserve all they get.

Quote

carpe-diem

@carpe-diem

Dazzler

Posted: 15 years ago

#42

it is a pavitra rishta
well lets face it once the purity is gone its hard to create problems for the leads in a serial. in most of the serials except (AJMBHKJ) it remains pure

Edited by carpe-diem - 15 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

carpe-diem

@carpe-diem

Dazzler

Posted: 15 years ago

#43

Originally posted by: nikitagmc
Kools, I agree with all your points. In fact, the falling in love with Manav so quickly part also makes a lot of sense to me, coz of two reasons...:

1.) Right now, she is emotionally vulnerable.

2.) Right now, she is in deep trouble, and right now Manav is the one sacrificing a lot for it. Hence it doesn't really surprise me that she has fallen for the person who is doing so much for her at this point of time, coz right now she is extremely grateful/extremely thankful and somewhat trying to know him more and seeing him in a different light than just her Dad's faithful servant. I think she is right now at the peak of all this gratefulness and so her falling in love as of now doesn't seem to be unrealistic, at least to me.

But yes, this love seems to be more like infatuation... in fact 80% infatuation. She has not fallen for Manav, his qualities etc. (he was the same all the time and she never fell for him before... she knew him since long even before she knew sachin) she has just fallen for 'her savior'. There is a difference in both these things. When she realizes that these are two different people and the real Manav is a person whom 'the savior' has been cloaking till now, a person who loves his wife like mad, and won't ever be happy with her, no matter what decisions 'the savior' in him takes, that will be the day she will reconsider her decision. As of now, she loves her savior for supporting her, and his being hot and handsome and extremely noble is a big plus point.

I hope I didn't make it up as a multiple personality disorder or something... but actually that's how it is even in a normal person, our character has a number of faces. Shravani right now has seen only one facet of Manav and has fallen in love with it is what I feel. for that love she is ignoring the Manav within.

i agree with you but when she realize who the real manav is will be fall out of love or will she turn in to a vamp?

Edited by carpe-diem - 15 years ago

Quote

Nikita Lakhe

@nikitagmc

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 15 years ago

#44

@carpe: Well that is what remains to be seen. If she is a good girl as has been portrayed, she might give up. If they decide to make her negative they will show her ignoring Manav's happiness and being happy with him just as a child is after getting a favourite doll or teddy bear.

Or we can have a third situation wherein she realises that Manav being happy or not, she herself won't be happy coz Manav is clearly not interested and wouldn't even consummate or be of one mind with her. If at such a realisation she withdraws thinking I can get another person much better then I would call her intelligent.

Quote

mimas

@mimas

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

#45

I don't blame Shravani simply because preganancy hamones have totally screwed her up. her mood swings are understandable..i just don't understand how this woman falls for some other guy when she ia actually carrying someone's child ? This is so unanatural.. and so not a common behavaior.. Jai ho preganancy harmones !!😡

I think Manav is happy , there are two women in love with her 😎

Edited by mimas - 15 years ago

Quote

carpe-diem

@carpe-diem

Dazzler

Posted: 15 years ago

#46

Originally posted by: nikitagmc
@carpe: Well that is what remains to be seen. If she is a good girl as has been portrayed, she might give up. If they decide to make her negative they will show her ignoring Manav's happiness and being happy with him just as a child is after getting a favourite doll or teddy bear.
Or we can have a third situation wherein she realises that Manav being happy or not, she herself won't be happy coz Manav is clearly not interested and wouldn't even consummate or be of one mind with her. If at such a realisation she withdraws thinking I can get another person much better then I would call her intelligent.

i doubt that the ct will let her character to withdraw. they will use her till theres nothing left of the character. with the child in the picture she is not going away from arman because i don't think she will give up her child to arman. she is going to do everything she can to separate arman and savita is her biggest strength.

Quote

Arien_03

@Arien_03

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

#47

Originally posted by: koolsadhu1000

but I found Shravani's outburst very human AGAIN . ESpecially the part where she categorically told Manav MERA DIL ITNA BADA NAHI HAI . She came across as frank , young and easily mislead and influenced {by Savita] , with a medley of human weaknesses like desire , jealousy and becoming selfish in love . Pulling Archana was no way condonable but guys

Nice post again, Kool. You carefully selected word 'human' for Shravani, yes its very much human albeit its wrong. But humans do wrong things, isn't it. Why do I think she is wrong, coz she herself knows she is wrong and yet she behaves the way she did.

When she confessed to Vandu abt loving Manav, she said it bothers her to see Manav with Archana. Whenever Manav does anything for Archana she feels bad. And then she said she shouldn't feel that way.

Is this the same girl who didn't care abt her child and decided to hv abortion so that she cannot come in between Arman. (So we can drop the argument that she is vulnerable and doing this for sake of her child). What happened to her since then. Oh yeah, she got engaged to Manav and like I said in my other post, she took U-turn in her outlook towards Arman realtionship. She forgot Archana is Manav's wife, she forgot her sacrifice and now she has begun to view Archana as the other woman. Manav might hv told her that everything is finished between Archu and Manav but did he ever show her sign that he is being attracted to her.

Why is she forgetting that this is a compromise and its wrong for her to have the medley of emotions ( u mentioned abv) for Manav especially when she is pregnant with his brothers child and when Archu is still around. Why is she so oblivious to Archu's feeling. She is only Manav's fiance and it hurts her so bad then why she doesn't consider Archu's feeling as Manas's wife. She was wrong in getting engaged to Manav before divorce in the first place . Manav was helpless but she could hv put her foot down and said 'No'. She is plainly ungrateful and selfish.

And then she says 'Mera Dil Itna Bada Nahin hai', right thing for her to say was 'Mera Dil Bahut Chota Hai'.

Originally posted by: koolsadhu1000

Surprisingly Shravni DID NOT PLAY THE BACHCHA CARD .

Shravani will not play Bachcha card coz thats her weakness not strength. Any man will not want to be romantically associated with a woman who is carrying other man's child, even if its his own brothers. Its very difficult for a man to hv any feeling for such a woman.

Totally agree what you told about Varsha.

Originally posted by: koolsadhu1000

Guys PR is becoming INTERESTING . I think Manav will not do complaint . He was looking at Archu . Although I dont understand Why Archu doesnt want the complaint against Ajit .........she gave Manav permission outwardly but didnt want it from her heart . Any reason? I fail to see it .

When Manav told Archana that he chased the pimp coz he wanted to know who wanted to defame Archu by sending her to brothel, Archu said she wants to forget the whole episode and its best sometimes that some question remained unanswered. If Manav had followed Archu's suggestion and not found out Ajit was behind it and if he had not challenged Ajit, Arman relationship wudn't be at this stage. I guess Archu believes that when you unearth something, some dirt falls on you too. Besides, if Ajit gets jailed, it will put strain on Vinod-Manju relationship.

Edited by Arien_03 - 15 years ago

Quote

Arien_03

@Arien_03

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

#48

Originally posted by: koolsadhu1000
You are ignoring two vital things in wanting to see this serial as u wish it had been .

1] The marrying a guy who is like a brother point : How can u hold it against only Shravani when the same thing applies to Manav too? Wasnt she like his kid sister all his life ? Yet he was the one who proposed to her . So ok , if u are going to hold that as a crime , then why is Manav absolved from it .........had anyone forced his hand ? Why is a Manav hate club not there for committing moral incest? I dont understand this logic at all . At least she asked him twice or thrice if he wanted to get back with Archu . The reason for this whole Bro Sis marraige was the child in the womb , The Deshmukh blood that the Deshmukhs wanted very very badly .U keep saying she cud have married another guy but answer this question first .............will Manav like it ?

I am telling u NO .Coz their child........the Deshmukh child will go to another man .The Deshmukhs want this child as Sachins memory . They want their blood to grow up in their house . I dont think Savita and Manav wud want Sachins child , their Deshmukh bloood to go away from their lives . Archna is not his priority at all , its ok for him if she goes , its definetely NOT ok for him if the baby goes elsewhere .Priorities r clear .They want Shravni much more than she wants them , make no mistake !

And if she leaves at this point hundred percent this Manav will run behind her saying Dont go........for the Deshmukh baby which He wants at any cost in his house . He threw Archana away for it . Face facts guys .

\

The reason for this Bro Sis Marriage is Shravani's stubborness about giving birth to Sachin's child and not coz they badly wanted heir to Deshmukh. When Deshmukhs came to know abt Shravani's pregnanacy even Savita was trying to talk Shravani into aborting the child. Manav offered marriage only coz Shavani was not ready to go for abortion and he wanted to save her from disgrace and also he wanted to repent for Sachin's mistake. Why would Deshmukh want this child very very badly, Manav is still there to extend Deshmukh lineage. Even today if Shravani refuses to marry Manav and wants to go away and theres no pressure from Girish, Manav would rather hv Archana back and make their own babies.

Edited by Arien_03 - 15 years ago

Quote

soap-critic

@soap-critic

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#49

Hi KS:

I used to read your threads in the Betiyaan forum and reply to most of them too. I still remember the one you had written after the Betiyaan played their cricket match. 😆 Nice to see you rocking the PR forum with your observations and comments.

I started watching PR when it started airing in the US and so I am about 2 months behind. We are at the part where Archu refuses to divorce Manav and Manav has already commited to marrying Shravani.

About Shravani's outburst - all I can say is why is she not showing this characteristic of hers in front of her father? Why not fight for her right to give birth to the child of the man she loved but so tragically lost? If she is bold and unconventional enough to engage in pre-marital consummation why not be bold enough to say she will raise the child as a single mom because it will be the living symbol of the man she loved? And that when she is ready to move on, the right may find the right man who is ready to share his life with her child and all.

Shravani is already 4 months preggy and by the time the court deadline of another 2 months goes by she will be 6 months preggy and it will definitely show. The chawl people and other will already come to know the reality. Society is going to talk anyways.

Knowing that Archana wants to give her all to make her marraige work and that both Archana and Manav love each other, her outburst does not make her look good. What if Archana was the type who would have turned around and said that Manav is her legally wedded husband and that she will go to court tomorrow and inform them that instead of trying to make the marriage work, Manav has got engaged to another girl and that she and Savi Aai are preventing them from working things out - where will they all stand - Manav included. (We know Archana would never do this - it is just a hypothetical question).

I have read the TB article and I hope that Vandu rises to the occasion now that she will come to know the truth about Ajit's involvement in the Manav-Archu misunderstanding. All she has done until now is smile and looks pretty and server water, tea and food to people. Hope she smacks some sense into Shravani and stands upto her mother to help her brother and vahini get back together.