Originally posted by: anutech2006
Look Baghabayen, I am not questioning Shankar' ability ( Not that it would even make a bit of difference to Shankar)..I was just saying that it SEEMED that he was trying to generalise shadab's apparent lack of comfort on high scale to that of Vineet.. Plus one more thing..If you have watched JJWS, then you would know from where my comments are coming..Vishal Shekhar there themselves said that Vineet is master of high notes..Vinnet sang many songs there which were of much higher scale than yesterday's performance (eg. Main jahan rahoon and teri diwani)..So there is no secret that vineet cant be uncomfortable on realtively lower scale scale to these songs..He has a problem with low notes..I agree..But high notes there is not aan iota of doubt amongst the people who have been following him since his saregamapa days..everyone with concur with that..
May be shankar haven't seen many of vineet's performances..So that were his reasons for the comments..
And anyways this is a public forum where one is free to form his/her opinion and shouldn't be chastised for that 😉 .. and i also formed my opinion on the basis of what i saw like i am sure many times you would have..So ye sab mat kariye ki bring the link or anything when u know it is just an opinion..
If you disagree you are welcome and free to do so..I appreciate each member's freedom of speech till it is not disparaging other member personally..not that you have done so.. 😉
Of course you have freedom of speech,and if u see carefully i have no objection with any other point except your 2nd point,We have our freedom of speech but it does not mean we can say anything .I know vineet since sa re ga ma pa days and it is TRUE that he has deteriorated a lot,forget higher scale or lower scale,he sometime misses sur,What vishal sekhar said during jjws can not be taken into consideration because vineet and his singing has been changed,i should rather say deteriorated badly.And as a judge shankar's acceptability is much more than vishal sekhar.And this is a public forum iska yeh matlab nahi ap shankar jaise personality ko "Shankar ko lagta hai ki wo Shankar bhagwan hai.. Too bad." aisa statement use kare..aur agar kare to better come up with prove,else i can entitle my opinion on rahul that "rahul was in lock up as he molested a girl"...personal opinion tab tak accha hai jab tak woh dusro ko hurt naa kare😊
But yes i have to admit i really enjoy replying you.It has become a daily routine now 😆
Take care.😉
Hindi TV Shows
