Valenties Day Special epi-Shaan Vs Himesh - Page 7

Originally posted by: anutech2006

Listen dont threaten me ki i will face problems..I said about music because it was you who were trying to imply that everyone would agree that shadab was better except his fans..So It came out because of that..Aur haan one more thing see my first post on this thread..ddi i name you..no..It was a very general post which was dragged into unnecessary arguments by you/./

Originally posted by: safeenafarheen

<font color="#000000">
Did i said u to agree with my thoughts that shadab is better than vineet..i just replied with my thoughts..dont be come with the comments watever u think..</font><font color="#000000">if i replied with ur thoughts means just see wat i replied i just viewed my comments with ur thoughts that doesnt mean that u2 accept with my thoughts ya..oh noooo..</font>

Originally posted by: anutech2006

OK..Lets stop this mudslinging on each other..we r here discussing on the singers and not on the members..Sometimes i agree the arguments do get heated as happened in our case..but can we call a truce..because i dont see the point in carrying on..One more thing..I am not supporting any particular singer/judge in MKMM..this you can read in one of my posts in some other thread where i said ki vineet and rahul ki awaz common hai and have nothing new to offer..So i try to analyse on the merits of singer..hence i found rahul not on your list amusing..Anyways you have your own views and opinions..So lets leave it to that and dont convolute the thread..enjoy 😊

Originally posted by: anutech2006

I think in today's episode
1. Round 1 : Raja was definitely better than debojit but audience gave him 1 mark less unnecessarily
2. Round 2 : In jugalbandi, i was surprised. Vineet was a notch above shadab and deserved more marks from judges than shadab. But I guess judges hv developed a biasedness against vineet and give him low marks generally. Especially Shankar seemed to unnecessarily ask vineet to accept that he was not comfortable at higher scale.Infact vineet seemed very comfortable. This pitch is nothing for vineet,He has sung at much higher pitch and scale. This was a cakewalk for him. But Shankar ko lagta hai ki wo Shankar bhagwan hai.. Too bad.. 😕
3. Round 3 : Raja was in no way lesser than harshit but got 0.5 marks lesser from judges. In fact i guess he sung better and the song was more suited for club mis type songs.
4. Round 4 : Here i guess that shaan's team just edged Himesh' team thanks to Anwesha. So i agree with judges marks here.
5. Round 5 : Shaan's Medley was better than himesh..No doubt about that..

Overall, I have no problem with shaan winning..But I hope judging would have been better..Especially Shankar as a judge is pathetic and seems to have biasedness against HR's team..

Originally posted by: 4teen11

everything is acceptable but not Rd 3. Harshit was far better than Raja and Rd 4 where Shaan's team won coz of Harshit n Anwesha n not her alone.....I fully agree that Shankar is picking on Vineet unnecessarily.Maybe coz he said Rahul is next best to Sonu and now realizes that Vineet is better than Rahul

Originally posted by: 4teen11

everything is acceptable but not Rd 3. Harshit was far better than Raja and Rd 4 where Shaan's team won coz of Harshit n Anwesha n not her alone.....I fully agree that Shankar is picking on Vineet unnecessarily.Maybe coz he said Rahul is next best to Sonu and now realizes that Vineet is better than Rahul

Originally posted by: bambooshoot

Shankar is a legend in the making. If there is anyone in this team whose judgement I can rely on, it's him. I don't think it's a good idea to criticize someone like him.