Valenties Day Special epi-Shaan Vs Himesh - Page 5

Originally posted by: shirani7

I couldnt agree with you more. I actually loved Rajas first performance! I didnt like debojits variations at all. I dont know why audience gave 1 point less to Raja 😕
Then round 2, shadab and vineet both didnt do well in that round, but yes vineet was better then shadab and deserved more! High notes are his strong points and in my opinion he DID brought some feeling to the song. And I totally agree with you on the Shankar thing!
Only round 5, i thought Himesh medly was slightly better than shaans medley 😊

and i have to say that Aishwariya was FANTASTIC. Vineet was good too, but aishwariya completely overshadowed him. Loved the performance! 👏

Originally posted by: ashraynaik

Shankar was bang on right when he advised vineet and shaadab.Shaadab immediately sang in a lower scale and sang beautifully.😃

Vineet is very haughty.He thinks no end of himself😕.In both his solo and duet he was way of the sur.And he truly was struggling with "in Dino".It is an extraordinary song.Only a champion at high notes like maybe wadali or abhaas could have done justice to it.😛

Vineet will never improve.It is impossible to teach someone if he thinks that he knows everything.🤢🤢

Originally posted by: xobile

Shaan's team did indeed deserve to win - in fact they deserve to win the whole muqabla!

Jeetenge Shaan se!!

Originally posted by: safeenafarheen

Hey dont support ur fav blindly..we a know and the viewers know how shadab did better while compare to vineet..Harshit,Anwesha rocked much better while compare to aish and vinnet,vineet was no wer good..aish was superb..Shadab did better while compare to vineet.Debo was good in his song ,raja was ood in his song..just comment on fact..

Originally posted by: anutech2006

@Shirani : Chalo at least I found 1 supporter at least 😉 ..Somehow I feel some people in this forum are too concerned on how the singer behaves and not how he sings..Remember the drama in the show is rigged but the singing cant be rigged..It is pure and honest..I mean I really pity when people say that rahul is such a bad singer because he is a showoff..Now we all now that whatever the singers say on the show is decided by gajji..So dont judge rahul vaidya on the basis of that..Dont judge vineet on the basis of that..Remember in jo jeeta wahi superstar rahul vaidya was the winner beating the likes of debojit, harshit,toshi,ameya,himani etc who all are participating in this show too..And he was the most consistent performer there along with abhijeet sawant and vineet regularly getting 9 and 10 from judges..If you people dont believe it then watch the show again on youtube..
SO the bottomline is that rahul and vineet are classy singers and should not be criticised for their singing based on the scripted mannerisms..judge the singer only on singing..IMHO the top 5 singers among the semifinalists in this show are : Rahul Vaidya, Vineet, Anwesha, Abhas and Raja.

Originally posted by: anutech2006

@Shirani : Chalo at least I found 1 supporter at least 😉 ..Somehow I feel some people in this forum are too concerned on how the singer behaves and not how he sings..Remember the drama in the show is rigged but the singing cant be rigged..It is pure and honest..I mean I really pity when people say that rahul is such a bad singer because he is a showoff..Now we all now that whatever the singers say on the show is decided by gajji..So dont judge rahul vaidya on the basis of that..Dont judge vineet on the basis of that..Remember in jo jeeta wahi superstar rahul vaidya was the winner beating the likes of debojit, harshit,toshi,ameya,himani etc who all are participating in this show too..And he was the most consistent performer there along with abhijeet sawant and vineet regularly getting 9 and 10 from judges..If you people dont believe it then watch the show again on youtube..
SO the bottomline is that rahul and vineet are classy singers and should not be criticised for their singing based on the scripted mannerisms..judge the singer only on singing..IMHO the top 5 singers among the semifinalists in this show are : Rahul Vaidya, Vineet, Anwesha, Abhas and Raja.

Originally posted by: anutech2006

@safeenafarheen : If you reread your post you would realise that its you not me who is supporting blindly their favourites..I know your favourite is Shaan..And my favourite is not himesh but shreya..I just commented what i felt as a viewer..Who gave you the right to ridicule our decision..I m commenting on fact but you are swayed away by your emotional loyalty or whatever 😕 to Shaan..Dont pretend that you know too much music and stop acting like a juvenile..And who said shadab sung better than vineet..There will be crores and many in your form too who would support true music and vineet..agar jyada problem hai to poll kara lijiye..
I know that the post is a bit rude but its necessary to remind senior members like you to not force your opinion on others and think rationallly..