Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 37 - Page 132

Episode Discussions

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.3k

Views

55.2k

Users

30

Likes

6.7k

Frequent Posters

Rdigest thumbnail
Hogwarts Championship 2025 Thumbnail Fashion Feud Participant Thumbnail + 9
Posted: an hour ago

Originally posted by: Mona_HappyLife

I already mentioned na, why she said that. She is operating out of fear. Her concern & therefore the dialogue aren't ridiculous.

She is a mother now. Whatever decision she takes will affect Dua in the long term. Dua just like Mannat is a daughter of a single mom. While in Mannat's case some decisions worked in her favour which Shruti took doesn't mean will work for Dua if Mannat takes the same decision. The time, the circumstance, the people around her way too different. She needs to keep all these things in mind & then decide.

Bold so we are ok with Mannat operating out of fear and making irrational decisions , but we are not ok with Vikrant who got partial memories of his kidnapping by RoTu back (also found Out about drugging) and acting irrationally?

Daman17 thumbnail
Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail

Team Mannat

Posted: an hour ago
He did make mistakes but I wouldn’t call it a lack of loyalty. Like most characters in the show, his character has multiple layers, and his arc evolves based on the series of events unfolding around him. From the beginning he was made to believe that his negligence was the reason his brother was taken away. Vish deliberately manipulated him and hid the truth, knowing that his profession would eventually give her access to Vik and the Saluja family’s wealth and that is exactly what happened. Throughout his childhood, he lived with immense guilt and when he finally met Vik, the burden only deepened because Vik remembered nothing. His pain eased only when Mannat made him confront the truth about his mother. Until Karwa Chauth, he had clear intentions to reveal the truth at the right time without ruining the Manvik relationship. That’s why he approached Ronnie to clear Vik’s MU. He has spent his entire life burdened with guilt naturally wants to escape that pain. In doing so, he ignored some of his mother’s actions. To protect her identity, he got ARS out of jail, something Mannat later confronted him. His mother manipulated him to the core and exploited his life as well. Yes, he made mistakes but it’s wrong to say he didn’t care for Vik. He witnessed Vik’s panic attack on his birthday just at the mention of Aman’s name. Later, Mannat asking for time and Rotu agreeing to tell Vik the truth triggered a chain of events that changed his perspective. He came searching for Aman but found Vik someone living a blessed life that he didn’t want to disrupt after learning the truth about his mother. Unfortunately, the truth surfaced in the most brutal way. His mother created a wall between the brothers and planted seeds of doubt in Vik’s mind. During his time at SM he also realised Vik’s anger issues and panic attacks which played important role. Vish’s manipulation led to one incident after another and Aat that point, he chose silence not out of selfishness but to protect the Manvik relationship while helping Mannat gather proof of her innocence. Since Vik had already rejected him and stopped communicating, Vish again twisted the narrative and convinced Vik that everything DK did was for Mannat, which further triggered Vik. DK tried multiple times to explain things logically, with reasoning and proof but Vik refused to listen. When Neetu went to jail, DK assured Mannat that he would speak to Vik. But the same day, Shruti passed away. At the funeral, he held his mother back so that Manvik could talk and resolve their differences. Yet, due to another manipulation by Vish, the brothers ended up fighting again, burying whatever emotions were left. Post leap, we saw DK still getting emotional about Vik. If Vik could throw his parents and Mannat out despite such strong relationships then who is DK to him? The least DK could do was stand by the people who were shattered and help them through their darkest phase especially when he knew how Vish had destroyed their lives. DK didn’t leave Vik it was Vik who didn’t accepted him. He is a flawed character but one who still stands his ground unlike many others. The writers are clearly preserving important arcs for him, which will unfold soon. Let’s see how his journey shapes up in the upcoming episodes.
Jyotsna09 thumbnail
Republic Rhythms Aazadi Quest Volunteer Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4

Team Vikrant

Posted: an hour ago

.

Edited by Jyotsna09 - an hour ago
Bettyscar thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: an hour ago

Originally posted by: Taiyo

Dua's life will be in danger once Aishwarya concludes she is about to destroy her well-crafted web of deceit.

Her life needs to be in danger for her birth truth to come out. That trio will never reveal. The secret needs to tumble out.

Rdigest thumbnail
Hogwarts Championship 2025 Thumbnail Fashion Feud Participant Thumbnail + 9
Posted: an hour ago

Originally posted by: Taiyo

I am all right with Dharya being Dua's father and his name on the certificate. Don't see it as a lie. It was choice the Indore unit made. Mannat made that choice based on her own person experience. Should she also conjure up a fake father figure for Dua like her Shruti Ma and made Dharya her bade papa? She chose not to do that. He is not a random person. He is family who has been in her daughter's life from day one. And in the post-leap, not for a moment, the character has behaved with an ulterior motive or inappropriately.

[I can even make sense of Vikrant believing Mannat is having an affair with his elder brother [because in his eyes, his birth-mother was being righteous and revealing what is immoral ... a mother would never accuse her own son if his conduct was not wrong], but I still cannot understand why it is a problem if Dharya is the father on the certificate as well 😂]

Its illegal to falsify information on legal certificates and they could easily lose custody of Vikrant finds out smiley37.

I understand DCP is addicted to using position for his personal gains pre and now post leap but a crime is still a crime.

Mannat definitely has her own personal experience and she should know all the more how much she suffered because Shurti didn't reveal the truth about ARS and how much destruction happened because she felt for Vikrant's benefit we will all lie.

Last paragraph, no way , if Vikrant really believed Mannat was having an affair pre leap I don't want Mannat to forgive him even if she finds out Vikrant didn't know about the baby.

Rdigest thumbnail
Hogwarts Championship 2025 Thumbnail Fashion Feud Participant Thumbnail + 9
Posted: an hour ago

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

Her life needs to be in danger for her birth truth to come out. That trio will never reveal. The secret needs to tumble out.

I am dreading this and I may have to take a break though I want the story to move.

I still haven't forgotten previous killing scenes and if there are any attempts on Dua I would want to crucify Mannat and Vikrant for being so dumb to give importance to every person but each other in their lives.

Mona_HappyLife thumbnail
Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4

Team ManVik

Posted: an hour ago

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Bold so we are ok with Mannat operating out of fear and making irrational decisions , but we are not ok with Vikrant who got partial memories of his kidnapping by RoTu back (also found Out about drugging) and acting irrationally?

No one is judging Vikrant's actions post him knowing the truth (half truth though) in pre leap. Majority of the people have issue with how he behaves with Mannat when in anger & not giving the other party a chance to tell the truth.

Mannat decided never to tell the truth but post Ronny's intervention did she still stick to the same decision ? No na.. She understood what Ronny was trying to say.

Also Vikrant doesn't have a child (till truth comes out). He doesn't have a responsibility to take care of. His decision will affect only Him & no one else now.

But Mannat's decision is going to affect her kid.

Edited by Mona_HappyLife - an hour ago
Bettyscar thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: an hour ago

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Its illegal to falsify information on legal certificates and they could easily lose custody of Vikrant finds out smiley37.

I understand DCP is addicted to using position for his personal gains pre and now post leap but a crime is still a crime.

Mannat definitely has her own personal experience and she should know all the more how much she suffered because Shurti didn't reveal the truth about ARS and how much destruction happened because she felt for Vikrant's benefit we will all lie.

Last paragraph, no way , if Vikrant really believed Mannat was having an affair pre leap I don't want Mannat to forgive him even if she finds out Vikrant didn't know about the baby.

Red: The way Vikrant was quoting the law in the PS i'm seated for the next round in court smiley36 He might not even need a lawyer to present his casesmiley36

Bettyscar thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: an hour ago

Originally posted by: Rdigest

I am dreading this and I may have to take a break though I want the story to move.

I still haven't forgotten previous killing scenes and if there are any attempts on Dua I would want to crucify Mannat and Vikrant for being so dumb to give importance to every person but each other in their lives.

That's the problem with them not knowing Aish is alive and Shruti's death being ruled an accident.

But i wonder if the update about an attempt on Mannat's life by Aish turns out to be true how it will impact the current narrative. Any repeated attempts on Mannat's life will result in a truth coming out which may change how Manvik will respond to Dua's truth.

Taiyo thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: an hour ago

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Its illegal to falsify information on legal certificates and they could easily lose custody of Vikrant finds out smiley37.

I understand DCP is addicted to using position for his personal gains pre and now post leap but a crime is still a crime.

Mannat definitely has her own personal experience and she should know all the more how much she suffered because Shurti didn't reveal the truth about ARS and how much destruction happened because she felt for Vikrant's benefit we will all lie.

Last paragraph, no way , if Vikrant really believed Mannat was having an affair pre leap I don't want Mannat to forgive him even if she finds out Vikrant didn't know about the baby.

😂 I still don't see why it is a problem 😂.

Audience, including me, burden characters with our own expectations and beliefs. A character will make choices as per their beliefs, experiences, and the world they inhabit. Dua would have come to know the truth at an appropriate time -- when the elders in her life thought she was old enough to understand it. Not today, but someday, it would have been revealed to her. With Vikrant's return in their lives, it will now be revealed soon. And it is up to Dua ... what she does with that truth. What is a story without these conflicts.

Last paragraph: that is Mannat's choice to make.

Edited by Taiyo - an hour ago

Related Topics

Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7 · a month ago

WRITTEN UPDATES AND DAILY DISCUSSION THREAD NO 36 Welcome to Mannat - Har Khushi Paane Ki EDT

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: Shemer · 6 months ago

Welcome to BTS Thread of MHKPK...

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7 · 1 years ago

Permission given by Leprechaun

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: purplegirl7 · 1 years ago

Welcome to Chat Corner for Mannat forum We can do gupshup here

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7 · 1 months ago

WRITTEN UPDATES AND DAILY DISCUSSION THREAD NO 35 Welcome to Mannat - Har Khushi Paane Ki EDT

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".