They have nothing different to show ? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

32

Views

4.3k

Users

12

Likes

105

Frequent Posters

617251 thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: In_love

We know ak intension are pure and love. But making favourite food and arranging party are diff things.

My point is she should involve atleast Neil and parth in the party. Anand and mahima are elders of house atleast she have to take permission from them.

We always can't justify ak action only saying her intentions are pure and she wants everyone happy.

Every person and family has its own past and limits to do things.

She even not listening abhi and his point of view. If abhi gonna angry with her it's totally justified. No child can saw their mother in manjiri situation from childhood and today ak definitely at fault.

I agree that Abhi's anger will be justified, because more than anger, it will be his traumas coming out. He will be deeply re-triggered. My heart breaks for him entirely, because this anniversary day is already painful enough for him. It reminds him of the first time he saw his father abusing his mother. But, this party, will quite literally rub salt onto his already open wounds. It is as if he will have to relive all of his past traumas. No one should ever have to go through that.

But, Akshu does not nearly know the extent of what has happened in the past. Abhi has not told her, and him being able to open up about something so painful will take time. She knows Harsh and Manjari have a rocky relationship, but the way she was raised, she thinks that bringing the family together with love can solve these problems. Also, like I said, Manjari genuinely looks happy in the precap, and Harsh isn't creating a scene either.

I know that making a favorite food and planning a party are different, but the intention is the same -- to make Manjari happy and make her feel seen and valued -- something that no one else has done for her in a really long time. It is intentions that define a person.

Akshu will bring the entire Birla family together in the end and heal their pain. This is about her journey and how she becomes the glue for this family. Of course it is going to be a rocky road, but she will succeed in the end.

I don't think Abhi nor Akshu are wrong in this situation.

Edited by tptwi - 4 years ago
Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8

Team Critics

Posted: 4 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: Life_Is_Dutiful

I

In the precap we did see that Harsh was kinda enjoying the party. I had always felt that Harsh likes attention and if he is garnering attention due to the party he will surely enjoy it. It was only Abhi who is having problems with the party because this party ruined his plans of a trip with Akshara. Coming to Abhi, even he hid the trip plans from Akshara. If he had told her they have to go to Chicago for some conference she probably wouldn't have made those party plans. Abhi secretly packed her bags and till last minute didn't let her know that he has planned a trip with her assuming that she'll be ok with the last minute informing.

Harsh is seen enjoying as he keeps a diff face for the world . What happens post party might be ugly where harsh can taunt manjari to encourage akshu.


Anyways it's not about the Consequences . Akshu is in character, we have seen it , that's why growth will be good. Hell even naira left kartiks family problems to him for a while and settled with him I a diff house .


Abhimanyu planning a surprise and akshu planning a surprise party are totally different . Abhimanyu will check his schedules and then plan an outing. Doctors apply for leaves so that alternate arrangements r made in their absence. Akshu will have to keep this in mind ..what if Anand mahima harsh abhimanyu had emergency in the hospital and they didn't come home that day, just like her greh pravesh day? And then she is doing it for harsh and manjari against abhimanyus wish.



The sabudana kheer sequence was lovely ! It's these small sequences that will make her understand them..manjaris face was worth a watch.. ..its just fine to make manjari happy but not rile up the other family members.specially abhimanyu. Will manjari be happy if abhimanyu and harsh have a huge showdown bec of this party ? One must consider all angles ..akshus intentions are always good but her actions are mostly disastrous.

Salutethearmy thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 4 years ago
#13

Hello peeps,

In Bepannaah Zoya had organised Adi's birthday party because her ex husband's event management company received a work order, she did not realise that that their respective spouses are no more.

Aditya Hooda literally starts shelling bombs in the party.

Apni Akshu, Zoya jaisi hai..

Really S2 writers are running out of ideas.

iheartChai thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 4 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: Salutethearmy

Hello peeps,

In Bepannaah Zoya had organised Adi's birthday party because her ex husband's event management company received a work order, she did not realise that that their respective spouses are no more.

Aditya Hooda literally starts shelling bombs in the party.

Apni Akshu, Zoya jaisi hai..

Really S2 writers are running out of ideas.


This scenario has been done before in other TV shows. People planning a surprise while the other person is also planning a surprise not realizing something else is going on and boom drama.


Probably half the writers out there writing for TV shows have probably reworked many a same track for other shows considering how long ITV allow their serials to run of course ideas are being reused and rehashed in the same serial or other serials.

Salutethearmy thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 4 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: iheartChai


This scenario has been done before in other TV shows. People planning a surprise while the other person is also planning a surprise not realizing something else is going on and boom drama.


Probably half the writers out there writing for TV shows have probably reworked many a same track for other shows considering how long ITV allow their serials to run of course ideas are being reused and rehashed in the same serial or other serials.

Oh yes it looks out of place because till the wedding Goenkas insisted on rasams and rituals.

Pagpheras are out of mind and sight.The very USP is missing. Almost every show is dramatic the core, the detailing makes Yrkkh tower over others.

I can understand if UT was writing the tracks, he does not adhere to the norms however the S1 and 2 writers skipping customs is not acceptable.

Life_Is_Dutiful thumbnail

Team Phufasa

Posted: 4 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: Salutethearmy

Hello peeps,

In Bepannaah Zoya had organised Adi's birthday party because her ex husband's event management company received a work order, she did not realise that that their respective spouses are no more.

Aditya Hooda literally starts shelling bombs in the party.

Apni Akshu, Zoya jaisi hai..

Really S2 writers are running out of ideas.

This show's tracks remind me of bepannaah all the time and then I realize bp writers tried all the typical itv formulas to make their show garner trps yet failed badly due to the show not starting on time and Rangu changing time slots frequently.

harshad_17 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: Life_Is_Dutiful

This show's tracks remind me of bepannaah all the time and then I realize bp writers tried all the typical itv formulas to make their show garner trps yet failed badly due to the show not starting on time and Rangu changing time slots frequently.

I m sorry to interrupt....I m also fan of bepanah...infact it is the only show I have watched from start to end.it failed because pH, writers, channel, editors, director ,stylists everyone thought that just bringing HC & JW together is more than enough and they don't need to do anything else.dont take efforts in any dept.thats why it failed miserably.except actors no one literally cared what they are showing excluding starting few episodes.n you know what it still hurts me.just like HC had said that it's a void.

Life_Is_Dutiful thumbnail

Team Phufasa

Posted: 4 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: harshad_17

I m sorry to interrupt....I m also fan of bepanah...infact it is the only show I have watched from start to end.it failed because pH, writers, channel, editors, director ,stylists everyone thought that just bringing HC & JW together is more than enough and they don't need to do anything else.dont take efforts in any dept.thats why it failed miserably.except actors no one literally cared what they are showing excluding starting few episodes.n you know what it still hurts me.just like HC had said that it's a void.

Oh 100%. I would actually blame the writers more. Only the first 5 episodes were awesome. Second week onwards it became typical itv show which still was watchable till the jungle track. After that the show went downhill. I will never tired of saying that fans expected to see a matured and intense love story but instead got maha crappy tracks that ruined the essence of the story.

harshad_17 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: Life_Is_Dutiful

Oh 100%. I would actually blame the writers more. Only the first 5 episodes were awesome. Second week onwards it became typical itv show which still was watchable till the jungle track. After that the show went downhill. I will never tired of saying that fans expected to see a matured and intense love story but instead got maha crappy tracks that ruined the essence of the story.

Exactly....ditto ....n u know what is so funny.some so called fans think that it was such a masterpiece and HC should not do a show like yrkkh after doing bp.the only good thing in that show was his character.n they are just not moving on and trolling HC and PR on everyday basis.I pity those persons seriously.anyways I know we are off tracks but is just that bp name triggers so much memories that I can't help to ventout my frustration.

harshad_17 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: _charu_

Other than recycling the kaira tracks in different ways , what else do they offer ? can the writers be a little more creative? In s2 , Consummation was dragged for 3-4 weeks while kaira had differences over family issues. What really changed ?


Here akshu knows. She has seen how harsh treats manjari and the most imp thing is that abhimanyu hinted her clearly that this day carries some bad memories ...manjari tells her they never celebrated this day...yet she went ahead with the surprise party ..this is when birlas keep reminding her that they are doctors , they don't have time for rasms rituals and parties.


Forcing her opinion on others , poking her nose , creating problems , not listening to their husband's is the standard itv bechari bahu akshu who thinks good for everyone but gets abused in return ..bechari akshu = more trps... . But nobody sees its her own doing. She is a new bahu, take some time to understand the family dynamics. What's with these "surprises " ? Def abhimanyu was shocked 😆

With all due respect I really want to know which ITV show is showing something different and refreshing plot.every other show has same kind of tracks.all crappy kind of shows gets trp and good shows which dare to show something different doesn't get trp ends abruptly.

Off topic but there was a show on Sony called story 9 months ki.it really was a refreshing story something completely new at anupama slot.but unfortunately it didn't get trp and anupama the story of same bechari abla naari became hit.so offcourse makers will take easy route.afterall it's a buisness.

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: Tani16 · 3 months ago

Same thing happened in Season 2 when Kairav was traumatized by Naira as she blamed him for Vansh's paralysis and he used to get severe anxiety...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: A_Star39 · 2 months ago

https://www.instagram.com/p/DWMP2XliKbj/ Okay so here's a little background on this couple. The guy mocked his wife for infertility and ran away...

https://www.instagram.com/p/DWMP2XliKbj/
Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: Agni_Jytsona · 3 months ago

https://x.com/agni_jyotsna/status/2021828793758101630

https://x.com/agni_jyotsna/status/2021828793758101630
Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: Aleyamma47 · 5 months ago

Any Garvita fans here? Just look at the couple pic from her new show. They look so good together....

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: LaughingGirl · 5 months ago

https://www.reddit.com/r/PAKCELEBGOSSIP/comments/1pygbng/iqtidars_copy_in_india/ Found this on Reddit Text Iqtidar's copy in India :...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".