Critics and Genre

Why do Indian critics review a movie keeping a template in their mind which doesn't go with the genre of the movie they are reviewing?

They don't comment on cinematic short comings of movies, they just go for the message, narrative of the movie.

Why would you review a movie like Baghi 3 with Pink or Chapaak or Tumbad as a template?

Originally posted by: NoraSM

Why do Indian critics review a movie keeping a template in their mind which doesn't go with the genre of the movie they are reviewing?

They don't comment on cinematic short comings of movies, they just go for the message, narrative of the movie.

Why would you review a movie like Baghi 3 with Pink or Chapaak or Tumbad as a template?

Critics across the world are guilty of that. Frankly, the most useless profession ever. A person who has a mind of his own and doesn't get swayed by the opinion of the majority is a rarity. In this case, one should watch the movie rather than looking for critics reaction.