Can we blame jhanvi? - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

23

Views

1.2k

Users

7

Likes

42

Frequent Posters

annihilation thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: love_taher

@ani

Your points are very much valid. In my opinion, jhanvi was a victim herself, and she has been controlled to a great degree by both Ashwin and Maya. There has to be more to the story. As u said earlier, jhanvi is a depressed soul. And somehow I feel both Maya n Ashwin have contributed to this. I'm not justifying jhanvi or saying she did not hv anything to do with maya's present state, but until we know for sure that is just jhanvi being a mere spectator to Ashwin's tortures on maya, we cannot comment, IMO.
We're trying to judge the characters too soon I feel, me included when I spoke abt Maya being a psycho/evil and stuff like that. Courtesy the immense excitement this show is generating with every passing episode. Sure Maya is not a psycho, tho I still believe it's some sort of personality disorder. Then again, we need to watch more to be sure.


That's the reason why I don't despise Jhanvi, she disappoints me a lot but I can't bring myself to not sympathise with her situation as well. See, that's the point if Jhanvi had taken an action back then, Maya wouldn't have been controlling Jhanvi now. Instead, she would have had a very supporting and understand daughter. She's suffering at the hands of both her husband and her daughter because somewhere she allowed them to.


As for the speculations, I don't even think you and I or most of us here are passing any judgements over the characters. If we all keep waiting for each and every detail to unfold, the time and chance to speculate is lost. What's the fun in being told everything when you have the chance to think? 😳 I personally like to speculate, analyse and deduce what interests me. So, if any of my theories doesn't reason with you, please let me know. I'll refrain from sharing my POV. :)
Edited by .annihilation. - 8 years ago
love_taher thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: .annihilation.


That's the reason why I don't despise Jhanvi, she disappoints me a lot but I can't bring myself to not sympathise with her situation as well. See, that's the point if Jhanvi had taken an action back then, Maya wouldn't have been controlling Jhanvi now. Instead, she would have had a very supporting and understand daughter. She's suffering at the hands of both her husband and her daughter because somewhere she allowed them to.


As for the speculations, I don't even think you and I or most of us here are passing any judgements over the characters. If we all keep waiting for each and every detail to unfold, the time and chance to speculate is lost. What's the fun in being told everything when you have the chance to think? 😳 I personally like to speculate, analyse and deduce what interests me. So, if any of my theories doesn't reason with you, please let me know. I'll refrain from sharing my POV. :)


No no. Why would u do that. Of course u can share ur pov. Ur sensible n I love ur posts. I don't disagree with anything uve said over here. What I meant was, it's too soon to strongly comment n blame. Im not targeting anybody here, as I said, I too judged Maya too early n gave her terms which I shouldn't have.Yes we can speculate, n put up theories...that's what the forum is for, but blaming is a different thing. N im just trying to look from jhanvi's perspective here. I thot it would be a good topic of discussion too.
Edited by love_taher - 8 years ago
RebeccaValentin thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#23
u r right..

I guess she wasnt d SOLE reason y maya was put in2 extreme torture..
bt yes she DID play a major role.. lyk maya said, jhanvi shud hav wokd out (even though its vry diff in practical terms2 wok outta a relationshp wid a daughter) atleast afta knowin dat her daughter is bein tortured.

More than dat, d fact dat shez still so much in2 ashwin despises me. it angers me a lot. hw cud a mom b lyk dat? 🤢 😡
Sharmin-JW-20 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: RebeccaSweety

u r right..

I guess she wasnt d SOLE reason y maya was put in2 extreme torture..
bt yes she DID play a major role.. lyk maya said, jhanvi shud hav wokd out (even though its vry diff in practical terms2 wok outta a relationshp wid a daughter) atleast afta knowin dat her daughter is bein tortured.

More than dat, d fact dat shez still so much in2 ashwin despises me. it angers me a lot. hw cud a mom b lyk dat? 🤢 😡

Wo to hein . .. .
Jhanvi maybe not the sole reason..but have made huge impact..
But..like siddhi said..she wasn't too brave amd strong about man ... and she can be easily manipulated..
Like in sweet wala scene..
If she was brave and intelligent😉..then that moment she would have understand that..ashwin is doing all this intentionally..not for her love..and would call for the bodyguard..
Like you I can't take that..y she is into so much in her despicable hubby . ..🤪
But after all she is too a victim of violence by ashwin...😭
Edited by ArYa-JenWin20 - 8 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".