All Positives about the finalists... - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

1.1k

Users

10

Frequent Posters

Vsakhi thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#11
oh.. where were all these nice posts all this while?? i had to dig till pg6 to find this one. what a wonderful post anu.. thanks for making the sun shine again on IF! 😊

ok, here's my two cents..

amanat: superb classical base and has now blossomed in the mainstream playback style very well too, though his forte is ghazals and semi-classical type songs. he would also be great in the fusion-rock style of he ever ventured into it. needs to work on diction, expression, breath control and energy a little more.

aneek: superb classical base and flawless singing across all genres. also, gifted with a melodious, honeyed voice texture that would fit any of today's heroes. his forte is the mainstream bollywood songs, though he'd do exceptionally well in semi-classical-fusion-rock type songs as well. needs to let his voice mature and ripen.

raja: superb classical base and exceptional voice quality - very earthy, powerful voice, tailormade for the sufi-rock type singing, which is his strongest point though he'd be brilliant in folk, qawwali, semi-classical and fusion-rock styles too. i definitely think he has great scope in bollywood, even if his is not the mainstream hero ki awaaz! needs to work on breath control.

and finally, may the best win!! 😊

bsb-star thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#12
wow i love this post

i second this positive approach to the fab 3

amanat: great playback singer singing on the lines of k.k and shaan

aneek: romantic numbers like sonu

raja: energetic/powerful/meaningful/ anthem- like songs like sukwinder and kailash kher
bsb-star thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#13
i'd like to add:
1)Maestro Jagjit Singh said Raja aapko Ghazal suit karti hai aap aage sirf Ghazal gaya karo.This means Raja can be a Ghazal singer.
2)The following performances of Raja will be included in the best of SRGMP 2007
a)Naina Thag lenge
b)Allah Ke Bande
c)Ankhiyan noo Chain Naa Aawe
d)Tere bin nahin Jeena
e)Kesariya Balam
f)Piya Hazi Ali.
g)Dum Dara Dum Dara
These were not peppy or rock numbers.These were pure classical numbers and were perfectly sung.
So Anu ji I would request you to increase Raja's capabilities.
Anuradha thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 17 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: bsb-star

i'd like to add:
1)Maestro Jagjit Singh said Raja aapko Ghazal suit karti hai aap aage sirf Ghazal gaya karo.This means Raja can be a Ghazal singer.
2)The following performances of Raja will be included in the best of SRGMP 2007
a)Naina Thag lenge
b)Allah Ke Bande
c)Ankhiyan noo Chain Naa Aawe
d)Tere bin nahin Jeena
e)Kesariya Balam
f)Piya Hazi Ali.
g)Dum Dara Dum Dara
These were not peppy or rock numbers.These were pure classical numbers and were perfectly sung.
So Anu ji I would request you to increase Raja's capabilities.



I am not disagreeing to the fact that he cannot sing other genre songs.. My point is he can be a good rock star.. As I said earlier - we are here to find out what is the best among these people and so I mentioned that he can do well as a rock star 😊
advil thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 17 years ago
#15

Ok my 2 cents:

1.Amanat : This guy is truly versatile. Happy sad, peppy ghazal, pop rock, sufi, he can carry all.The credit for this versitility should go to his excellent classical base.He voice is deep and sweet both at the same time. It can bring out the feelings very well.He needs to get a grip on the breathing and also on his diction, sometimes its not so clear.Also he needs to add a bit more energetic feeling when he is into peppy numbers.

But he has a voice that can suit most romantic heroes of the present time, and can sing any types of songs.

However, he should seriously contemplate ghazal singing and classical singing. Talents like him can keep classical music alive.

2. Aneek - Has a very good classical base.Perfect on sur and taal and most important, knows how to put in the feelings into the lyrics. His voice is a bit immature still and in a few years it will reach the maturity needed to playback for a older heroes. His voice would suit any current young college going chocolate hero.

I would love to hear a rabindrasangeet in his voice.

3.Raja : Raja has a very nice voice and it has a lot of zest in it. He puts 100% feel into his songs.Raja can do justice to certain genre songs and he will do very well. But he wont be that good in sad,or soft numbers.Raja has a very good grip on high notes, but at low notes he still falters a bit.

Raja's voice wont suit every hero, but those that he sings will be surely chart toppers as he would do full justice to that genre .

Edited by advil - 17 years ago
advil thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 17 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: mas999

Hi Advil,

The order in which you have described each and the number of words that you have sopken about each, is their a clue ???

Nope.I just went in alphabetical order...😆 Am (amanat)...then An(Aneek) and R comes after A...so....

No, they are all unique in their own ways.As a music lover, I really can't take sides of any now. I am well aware of the potential of each and know my personl 2 favorites out of these three...but all 3 of them are really excellent...

Too tough to delare one the best....

At times like this I wish I was more a Fan than a music lover....😆

124014 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#17
Adi's top 2 favs r Amaanat and then Aneek 😉 ...which happened to be in alphabetical order😉
Edited by 2smart4u - 17 years ago
advil thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 17 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: 2smart4u

Adi's top 2 favs r Amaanat and then Aneek 😉 ...which happened to be in alphabetical order😉

Wow Einstein...what a great discovery....now if that is right or wrong....well, its for me to know....you could be wrong or right...who knows...but I am NOT telling.

Just tell me one thing, why is it so important to know who my fav top 2 are?

swifthorse thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#19
Hey Adi..as a true music lover we know what your choice would be 😉
Edited by swifthorse - 17 years ago
124014 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: mas999

Beacuse you are too cute 😳 and because U can not hide the clues, its all in your words, Come on give your one cent now. I can add you to ****** fan list.

i know right??/😳😆...plus the suspense is killing me!!!!!!!!...u've been avoiding this question for past 2 weeks!... i wanna know so i can bash ur fav. contestant(if he's not as same as mine)😆...aap ke saath ladhne mein bohut maza aata hai😃😆...if he is the same...then we'll bash others together😉😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".