Posted:
Originally posted by: ---Khushi---
Mandy. ..im glad you asked these questions...1) when I first read your theory...it looked to me like you had hit the nail on the head...but then when I thought more about it, I was convinced that it can't be Ruqu as mastermind for sure ...A) I believe this whole has Atifa track been plotted to dethrone Jalal thru zinakari...if that is so, Ruqu will NEVER want thatB) RUQU simply doesn't have the brains for this kind of plotting...she can only plot most ridiculous n silly plans like murti kaand, FP, etc 😆C) Most imp clue, when Jalal drew Atifa's painting in his hojra, after returning from the hamam where he had first seen Atifa, Ruqu saw the portrait too. ...& there was no reaction from her...if she had sent Atifa, she would have known that Jalal knows OF her ...if u understand what I'm saying...2) i think Atifa is unmarried...she is probably an enchantress to make Jalal fall in love with her...Hence she has been sent with a KS, to pretend as if she is married, so that Jalal can fall her ...but Jalal falling for her ONLY does not solve the purpose to dethrone him, unless they say she is "married" & her "husband" approaches the qazis for "zinaakaari" & hence dethrone him...So my guess is, Jalal is one step ahead of all of them in this track, n hence has defied Atifa's husband to approach the maulvis...Adham was already seen talking to him...when the confrontation will happen in front of the qazis, Jalal will trap all...Atifa, her KS of a "husband" & the mastermind behind this whole saazish...hence Jalal's dialogue to Atifa, hum usska bhi shikar karte hain jo dikhai nahi deta..." ..To make the enemy believe that he is besotted with Atifa, he has to make them believe that he has also fallen out of love with Jodha...WE SAW MA EAVESDROPPING IN THURSDAY EPISODE DURING JJ FIGHT ...Jalal knows that the enemy has spread it's poisonous tentacles all around the mahal...hence he was so rude to Jo, whom he loves more than his life...he is desperately trying to protect 4 lives...his own , Jo's, n the unborn kids...n indirectly his awaam's. ...coz if he is no more, his awaam will go to the enemy as well...This is how I think this track is gonna proceed...let's see...😊...first time, a completely logical track from the cvs...Looks like a lot of intricate planning has gone in this track...almost like an Alfred Hitchcock whodunnit 👏
Khushi my problem in believing it can be MA plot is - how will Jalal be truly redeemed if it is her plot?
Cos after Adga Khan warned Jalal about sin and against Shriyat etc. why would Jalal wait for the plot to unravel? Why not just nip it in the bud? What does he care about Atifa?
Also NOW that Jalal has no illusions about MA, he knows she can go to any extent to harm Jodha and his babies, if truly Jalal had got a hint that she is plotting this, there is now no emotional baggage about MA to stop Jalal from atleast sending her away.
Why would Jalal pretend to fall in the trap by Atifa and MA and go to such extreme lengths? Jodha and his babies would be his first priority. If he has to hurt Jodha so that he can punish MA and Atifa it does not make much sense to me atleast.
How can he be Teda Jalal if he can't act against these two - Atifa and MA? So there has to be more.
I still think it might be Ruk cos of Jalal's waning to her. CVs have not given Ruk 2 wishes just for nothing!
BTW still curious about if a marriage is considered legal if husband is a Khwaja Shera?!
Kyunki Saas Bhi Kabhi Bahu Thi 2
24