Moderators please take note:Viewbie's note on pg5 - Page 3

Originally posted by: April2007

I do understand

India is not hindu or Sikh. India belongs to all as much to sikhs as to hindus.

Hindus don't own India sikhs have as much right by saying commenting India i am judging hindus is totally wrong and defranchizes Sikhs and make them outsiders. Gurpreet is as much Indian as Pri..being India is not a religion.

Didn't anybody judged hindus by judging Pri behavior or Virinda's behavior.

You have somehow seperated Sikhs from India by saying Gurpreet generalization will be Sikh girls and rest of the girls are Indians their generalization is Indian.

When I said Indian I thought Sikhs, hindus all are Indians but it seems you don't think so, I included myself in that India. It seems according to your view Gurpreet is Sikh thersfore her generalization is all sikh girls while and rest of the girls on show are Indians their generalization is Indians.

SIkhs hindus are all the same in India. Its the only tolerant country in the world, which has elected a Sikh Prime Minister and a Muslim President! This Speaks a lot about the country as whole!
You are confusing things and bringing in too many variables into your argument! Everyone here is talking about Gurpreet as an individual and not as a person belonging to any culture/caste/religion. Period.

Originally posted by: April2007

I do understand

India is not hindu or Sikh. India belongs to all as much to sikhs as to hindus.

Hindus don't own India sikhs have as much right by saying commenting India i am judging hindus is totally wrong and defranchizes Sikhs and make them outsiders. Gurpreet is as much Indian as Pri..being Indian is not a religion.

Didn't anybody judged hindu girls by judging Pri behavior or Virinda's behavior. Why did you seperate Gurpreet from being called Indian..where did Sikh came from..

You have somehow seperated Sikhs from India by saying Gurpreet generalization will be Sikh girls and rest of the girls are Indians their generalization is Indian.

When I said Indian I thought Sikhs, hindus all are Indians but it seems you don't think so, I included myself in that India. It seems according to your view Gurpreet is Sikh thersfore her generalization is all sikh girls while and rest of the girls on show are Indians their generalization is Indians.

Originally posted by: sunandshine

SIkhs hindus are all the same in India. Its the only tolerant country in the world, which has elected a Sikh Prime Minister and a Muslim President! This Speaks a lot about the country as whole!
You are confusing things and bringing in too many variables into your argument! Everyone here is talking about Gurpreet as an individual and not as a person belonging to any culture/caste/religion. Period.

Since you brought toleration and Sikh prime minister..I will remind you killing of Sikhs on streets of Delhi in 1984 and killing of muslims in Ahmedabad.

@purva, i had already said, that any argument with this member, will lead to ur words being twisted out of context, to show that u are anti-so and so, and a bigot, and regressive......

Originally posted by: sunandshine

SIkhs hindus are all the same in India. Its the only tolerant country in the world, which has elected a Sikh Prime Minister and a Muslim President! This Speaks a lot about the country as whole!
You are confusing things and bringing in too many variables into your argument! Everyone here is talking about Gurpreet as an individual and not as a person belonging to any culture/caste/religion. Period.

I think april 2007 is crossing all limits, is this is venue to discuss sikh killings, muslim riots, or khalistaan, as she has so nicely mentioned in another post???????????? what do any of these have to do with this show???????? it seems like this member is completely anti-india, and cannot tolerate any indian views....

Originally posted by: mechocoholic

@purva, i had already said, that any argument with this member, will lead to ur words being twisted out of context, to show that u are anti-so and so, and a bigot, and regressive......

Originally posted by: purva

@ bold.. do you even understand what I have written... please read it again. It is an example of what will be wrong. More like... "it will be wrong to judge all sikh girls on the basis of one sikh girl.. i.e. Gurpreet" just like you are judging whole India on the basis of few comments written here and a reality show.. if you don't understand this then there is no point of arguing further..

And stop putting words in my mouth... I never said anything about any religion..

Originally posted by: purva

I don't really get this yaar... since when it became about the whole India and then Sikhs and Hindus and all.. I used that Sikh girls example to show how it will be wrong to judge whole community based on one girl's behavior on the show.. it's useless to argue further I guess 😕

Originally posted by: mechocoholic

I think april 2007 is crossing all limits, is this is venue to discuss sikh killings, muslim riots, or khalistaan, as she has so nicely mentioned in another post???????????? what do any of these have to do with this show???????? it seems like this member is completely anti-india, and cannot tolerate any indian views....