SG vs. MN vs. Criticism - Imp Pls Read - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

55

Views

4.2k

Users

16

Likes

271

Frequent Posters

Gagan-06 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 16 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: Gossip Girl

I see where you are coming from Gagan.

Can someone please explain why this particular individual was lurking there?

Mainly considering the individual was not even part of that place.

I really wouldn't visit a place that hurts my sentiments.

I have seen quite a few rude YT comments, but very people bother to report them, and the comments do not get deleted, unless there is harsh language i.e. swearing et al. When watching videos on YT all of us catch the comments, and at this point people are not hurt, yet when it comes to visiting a CC, which is considered to be filled with horrible and negative people members still visit this horrible place & claim to be hurt.

GG, I understand. Those comment may be from the forum as well.. there were just a lot going on in MJHT forum.
Definently we are trying our best to allow as much freedom, but also owe an explanation to others..
I am trying my best to build a communication here between fans..
I want everyone to understand each other and again respect other POVs.
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#12
@Gagan: Exactly....the tone of the comment and the basis of it needs to be understood.....if ppl are unable to understand and just go around blindly reporting every little thing that 'hurts' them, what will be achieved??

As GG pointed out, what was this person doing lurking in our CC in the first place??? If they are oh so easily 'hurted' by simple basic opinions that don't even use harsh language like the one GG's giving examples of from YT...then why are they oh so busy stalking such a place??? Such is their ardent 'lowe' for it??? LOLL

And I find it amusing that ppl are so worked up over the MN spoof siggies.....I personally found those very creative and entertaining......and I'd like to point this out as a example of OBJECTIVITY....Ppl could use some sense of humor! ;-)
OHYE thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#13
O wow! y am I not surprised at this? LOL. Gagan first of all thanks for the post.
From my part I always try to state my opinion in a way that doesn't hurt other ppl's sentiments --- even though I am very straightforward. I do make snide remarks, but only when one is made on me. You know the tit for tat game when I have the time, but next time I'll make sure I don't do that --- sometimes can't help its human nature. Even though none of the remarks above relate to me luckily, I'll definitely make sure nothing like that happens in the future from my side.

Words are a powerful tool --- some don't care about other ppl's feelings and use harsh and accusatory language. Its okay with me, but I don't like it when others r not respected for what they voice, yet respect is asked for oneself. I truly despise this mentality. Differences lie from person to person its simple to accept that notion, but hard to follow. Like something state it, don't like something state it, don't care about something state it, but there's no need to get into more frustrations over a trivial matter ---- its just a show. Thank you for bringing to my attention how to handle situations of this kind from now on. Report button will be in my sight.
382958 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: trouble_maker

Ok with all this Mohit discussion, I don't get why those who don't give a damn about SG, care about Mohit's acting. They may think that he's a weak actor...but the comment learn "some acting from Arjun"...that's just pure bashing. And I think it's pretty clear that bashing an actor is totalllly not allowed.



Sure, that is harsh. In this case it sounds harsh, since he is compared with Arjun (another lead actor from the same show). However, if it was SRK, then a lot of people might have taken it lightly.

Each actor has his/her role model. SRK has been an ideal role model for a lot of actors today, and will continue to be one for the future generation as well. There is nothing wrong to grow and improve, as an actor by looking at others. Aamir and Srk have been known to give tips to the young actors. Is that such a wrong thing then?
Edited by Gossip Girl - 16 years ago
Gagan-06 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 16 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: trouble_maker

Ok with all this Mohit discussion, I don't get why those who don't give a damn about SG, care about Mohit's acting. They may think that he's a weak actor...but the comment learn "some acting from Arjun"...that's just pure bashing. And I think it's pretty clear that bashing an actor is totalllly not allowed.

Binu,
Absolutely!! Such comments fall under "No Comparison Rule"
We definently do not allow such comparison topics and DT would object to that post.
As i said i was really not saying which comment were right or wrong😆
Edited by Gaganjot.S - 16 years ago
Gagan-06 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 16 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: Gossip Girl



Sure, that is harsh. In this case it sounds harsh, since he is compared with Arjun (another lead actor from the same show). However, if it was SRK, then a lot of people might have taken it lightly.

Each actor has his/her role model. SRK has been an ideal role model for a lot of actors today, and will continue to be one for the future generation as well. There is nothing wrong to grow and improve, as an actor by looking at others. Aamir and Srk have been known to give tips to the young actors. Is that such a wrong thing then?

GG, I understand the analogy you have made.
I think we have sort of defined this on the forum and said comparing is not allowed and i felt that comment falls under comparing the two.
Gagan-06 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 16 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: OHYE

O wow! y am I not surprised at this? LOL. Gagan first of all thanks for the post.
From my part I always try to state my opinion in a way that doesn't hurt other ppl's sentiments --- even though I am very straightforward. I do make snide remarks, but only when one is made on me. You know the tit for tat game when I have the time, but next time I'll make sure I don't do that --- sometimes can't help its human nature. Even though none of the remarks above relate to me luckily, I'll definitely make sure nothing like that happens in the future from my side.

Words are a powerful tool --- some don't care about other ppl's feelings and use harsh and accusatory language. Its okay with me, but I don't like it when others r not respected for what they voice, yet respect is asked for oneself. I truly despise this mentality. Differences lie from person to person its simple to accept that notion, but hard to follow. Like something state it, don't like something state it, don't care about something state it, but there's no need to get into more frustrations over a trivial matter ---- its just a show. Thank you for bringing to my attention how to handle situations of this kind from now on. Report button will be in my sight.

Ohye, words are definently a powerful tool here. lol
There have been a lot of instigating posts on the forum. This is why I mentioned in this post.. that members should be aware of what they post and know what kind of reaction it can trigger from the other member.
Have some kind of self awareness. 😆
I am not teaching anyone how to write comments.. but just be aware of what you are posting.
Thanks for sharing your thought.
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#18
And Gagan, coming back to that earlier point......I'm a MN fan......do you see me sitting here and complaining about how 'hurt' I am that some ppl called the gola scene 'cheap'??? ROFL.......that's fine....that's their opinion....I don't agree with it but they are welcome to that opinion...so WHY is this an issue??? :S

Gagan-06 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 16 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: nureat01

@Gagan: Exactly....the tone of the comment and the basis of it needs to be understood.....if ppl are unable to understand and just go around blindly reporting every little thing that 'hurts' them, what will be achieved??

Anu, I am sort of going to keep CC matters out.. I think this forum has plenty of examples if not more😆
I just stated in my reply to Ohye..
that just being aware of what you are posting or even reporting for a matter of fact would help everyone out..
I think that is what i am trying to do is communicate this info to everyone.
Ozymandias thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 16 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: nureat01

And Gagan, coming back to that earlier point......I'm a MN fan......do you see me sitting here and complaining about how 'hurt' I am that some ppl called the gola scene 'cheap'??? ROFL.......that's fine....that's their opinion....I don't agree with it but they are welcome to that opinion...so WHY is this an issue??? :S


That's more of the show. But if I was to make an insulting comment on ArTi, I'm sure u wouldn't stay quiet either!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".