SG vs. MN vs. Criticism - Imp Pls Read - Page 3

oh god...yeh phir shuru ho gaya! lol..*shakes head*

umm i don't see how saying "mohit needs to improve or work on his expressions is bashing" ?? its just an opinion...

i say that often...n yes i watch the show n i have full right to comment.. i find mohit blank ...that's an opinion..not bashing... :S

like someone finds the gola scene cheap ..i don't have a problem with that...their opinion..i don't report such things!! i don't even care... like only yesterday i read ppl saying indirectly ofcourse that MN fans love overacting..lol... i read that n found it hilarious actually 😆 so they wanted to say that arjun n rati overact... not that i care..just giving u an example....

ppl need to grow up!

Gagan yaar, I know you're talking generally.....but some ppl IMAGINE posts to be instigatory when they are perfectly harmless! It's cuz they choose to INTERPRET them in that manner!

I can't speak for the rest of the petty groupism in this forum, but I don't sit around trying to figure out ways to instigate one group of fans or the other :S LOL....

But yes, I can understand what you mean that some general prudence can be exercised in order to avoid the drama......it's sad that some ppl are unnecessarily raking this up again when this issue had already been settled once *sigh*

Originally posted by: trouble_maker

That's more of the show. But if I was to make an insulting comment on ArTi, I'm sure u wouldn't stay quiet either!

Depends on the interpretations of insulting.....if you were to say that you don't find there to be any chemistry b/w ArTi, I wouldn't go whining to Gagan with a PM or report you for it....I can speak for myself on that....you may choose to believe whatever works for you.

Originally posted by: trouble_maker

Ok with all this Mohit discussion, I don't get why those who don't give a damn about SG, care about Mohit's acting. They may think that he's a weak actor...but the comment learn "some acting from Arjun"...that's just pure bashing. And I think it's pretty clear that bashing an actor is totalllly not allowed. <br>

I agree. There are fans that always say, they don't care about SG etc, and they only care about MN, so why make a comment like this?

Sure Mohit is a weak actor among all 4 leads but should we encourage him instead of bashing him all the time.

and Mohit is a different issue. I don't even wanna get started on Sanaya or it will take me 15+20 pages to write on this so I am just gonna leave it..

I just don't understand one thing ; why compare actors? Each Character is different and that's why the actors were given the role because people felt that they could do it.

No one can do Mayank the way Arjun does BUT at the same time, I don't think other than Mohit can play Samrat better.

So seriously.. Let the actors do their character roles.

Originally posted by: nureat01

Depends on the interpretations of insulting.....if you were to say that you don't find there to be any chemistry b/w ArTi, I wouldn't go whining to Gagan with a PM or report you for it....I can speak for myself on that....you may choose to believe whatever works for you.

exactly...

same here...even if ppl say that MN were blank or there was no chemistry... i wud never report...
i have ready such posts..but i have never reported anything! it's just an opinion...i DON'T see any bashing there! what exactly is the definition of bashing? 😕

gagan can confirm this!

WOW.. ok this is a tough one...so I confused here n might need some help to sort things out...

so clearly in the first reposted case... PM1 the fan was disturbed at what he or she thought was bashing.. well Mohit according to someone is not a good actor..or rather BAD actor.. fine thats the person's opinion. I personally dont fancy SRK...Laugh all u will that doesnt take away from his achievements.. although comparing SRKand Amir wld be unfair..hence the comparison was definitely stepping the line..altho knowing ppl they dont stop to compare SRK n AB SR...so we cant really take responsiblity for people lack of judgement here...

as for the groupism post..where do you draw the line. I mean if a not an ardent MN fan can spoof on MN tracks is it fine and if a sajanian makes the same humor is it derogatory...i need help in comprehension here.. but at the same time I am not advocating calling names...then again who decided whats below the belt. for ex I saw a pointless below the belt sig on CJ yest n told the maker what i felt about it. but someone else may have been okay with it..trust me many were..again objectivity is a rare virtue anu...I wonder how IBL is surviving in todays times..every post wld be reported there..although most people mean no harm

as for the sig post..oh well I own up to having voted for the sig in question thats coz i found it funny..then again..if it was derogatory wldnt the MOD resposible disqualify it before it made it to the list.. again a case in point here.. so we dont care to repect the people who have the authority to decide and cant stop cribbing about anything..Call me a sadist but its a winless situation n I dont see a solution here...

EXACTLY, Manali! I CHALLENGE anyone to prove otherwise! I think there are BETTER things to do in life that sit around getting 'hurted' over someone not happening to praise your fav. pair/actor to the skies!

And Manali, log HUMEIN kya bolenge?? Humse zyada KAUN point out karta hai when there is a lack of expressions etc. with MN/ArTi??? On what basis am I being told that I would go report ppl if they said such stuff about ArTi?? :S LOL

Originally posted by: jenny1000

I agree. There are fans that always say, they don't care about SG etc, and they only care about MN, so why make a comment like this?

Sure Mohit is a weak actor among all 4 leads but should we encourage him instead of bashing him all the time.

and Mohit is a different issue. I don't even wanna get started on Sanaya or it will take me 15+20 pages to write on this so I am just gonna leave it..

I just don't understand one thing ; why compare actors? Each Character is different and that's why the actors were given the role because people felt that they could do it.

No one can do Mayank the way Arjun does BUT at the same time, I don't think other than Mohit can play Samrat better.

So seriously.. Let the actors do their character roles.

Originally posted by: nureat01

EXACTLY, Manali! I CHALLENGE anyone to prove otherwise! I think there are BETTER things to do in life that sit around getting 'hurted' over someone not happening to praise your fav. pair/actor to the skies!

And Manali, log HUMEIN kya bolenge?? Humse zyada KAUN point out karta hai when there is a lack of expressions etc. with MN/ArTi??? On what basis am I being told that I would go report ppl if they said such stuff about ArTi?? :S LOL

lol exactly anu!!
i challenge too!

@bold: lmao! 😆 anu ppl don't see what they don't want to see...
we keep on bashing ArTi when they are blank..especially arjun ...lol... (yes bashing...its not an opinion..isnt it? *rolls eyes*)
so hum kya hai? 😳

like i said..i didn't even feel bad when ppl said MN fans like MN cuz they are used to overacting 😆
i shud have cried buckets...mera naazuk dil toot gaya 😭😆

Originally posted by: Gaganjot.S

Jenny, as i said we definently dont allow comparing posts on this forum. Usually anything thatwe come across or see reported DT takes action. 😛

About why others make comments if they dont like SG... this becomes a whole different issue.. as when you watch MJHT youwatch both couples.. so i cant take away the right from anyone to state their opinion.

So definently please let us know if we missed out on any comparing topics. I usually go through reported posts.

I agree with all you have said Gagan.

As far as the Sanaya's issue, I explained to you over PM's many time so it does not matter. 😊

I agree with what you say. When you watch the show, you watch it for the whole, so you don't have a choice..

Seriously, I don't care when people are like ArTi has 100% chemistry and MoNaya has 0% as it is their personal comments.. but when people cross their limits, it gets heated.