Feedback to CVs thread- Story distortion#2 - Page 13

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

97.9k

Users

99

Likes

4.2k

Frequent Posters

582445 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
Indonesian Mahabharata seems to be pretty different from Vyasa's but as CVs are determined to collect their stories from foreign Mahabharatas [and mixing it with their own imagination] it would be good if different track comes from different MB .. like if following track is from foreign i.e. Indonesian MB let the later track be inspired from some native MB like Bheel Mahabharata .. @CVs that will be pretty innovative what say???😎
Justitia thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: SayaneeH.Lecter

Indonesian Mahabharata seems to be pretty different from Vyasa's but as CVs are determined to collect their stories from foreign Mahabharatas [and mixing it with their own imagination] it would be good if different track comes from different MB .. like if following track is from foreign i.e. Indonesian MB let the later track be inspired from some native MB like Bheel Mahabharata .. @CVs that will be pretty innovative what say???😎


In that case, we might have to make a list of all the "distortions" shown in Starbharat so far, and keep searching the respective sources of reference material...that should be a fun activity. 😎

I'm sure there must be one version of MB out there which credits Arjun with resolving the fiasco that was the Lakshagrah track...

But I have to ask - What is the main reason for adopting this mix-and-match MB? Is Vyasa's original version too "controversial" or something?
Edited by shani88 - 11 years ago
Sabhayata thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: shani88

StarArjuna introduces StarDrau as "daan" to StarKunti, and later explains that by "daan", he actually meant "kanyadaan". So, as per CVs, the StarPandavas did NOT "objectify" StarDrau in any way. And even when StarYudi was trying to tell StarKunti that they had actually brought a girl, StarKunti issues her order for the "vibhaajan". Therefore, ALL the blame for Drau's vibhaajan lies with StarKunti...oh well, at least StarKunti possessed ONE flaw, much better than her sickly sweet saintly characterization.

you are worng here StarDrupad along with StarKunti take the blame for Vibhajan.StarDrupad asked for a harsh life for his daughter hence her vibhajan happened.StraDrupad will also be responsible for StarDrupadi's vastraharan since he asked for life full of humiliation for her.So in a way StarDrupad is one of the main reasons for kurushetra
Sorry real Drupad in heaven
Sabhayata thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: shani88

In that case, we might have to make a list of all the "distortions" shown in Starbharat so far, and keep searching the respective sources of reference material...that should be a fun activity. 😎
I'm sure there must be one version of MB out there which credits Arjun with resolving the fiasco that was the Lakshagrah track...

But I have to ask - What is the main reason for adopting this mix-and-match MB? Is Vyasa's original version too "controversial" or something?

Actually only the part where Arjuna plays cupid between Karna and his wife to eb seems to eb from Indonesian MB rest all no idea CV's imagination most probably
Vyasa's MB is boring as per these CV's i think.Not enough mirch masala for TRP's😆
Justitia thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Sabhayata


you are worng here StarDrupad along with StarKunti take the blame for Vibhajan.StarDrupad asked for a harsh life for his daughter hence her vibhajan happened.StraDrupad will also be responsible for StarDrupadi's vastraharan since he asked for life full of humiliation for her.So in a way StarDrupad is one of the main reasons for kurushetra
Sorry real Drupad in heaven

Now I have figured out how the Pandavas will get the clean chit during the vastraharan. Thanks Sabhayata!😃
Then even Duri, Dushi, Karna, Shakuni can get the clean chit too in the vastraharan...

Post vastraharan convo between Yudi & Drau -
Drau to Yudi - Aap Dharamraj hai na?? Aap ne apni patni ko daav pe kaise lagaya?
Yudi to Drau - Tumhare pitashree ne tumahre liye jeevan bhar ka kasht kyu maanga??

Serious question - If ALL the blame for Drau's troubles ultimately falls on Drupad, then, what on earth will be the main purpose of the Kurukshetra war??? Looks like the Pandavas and Kauravas will have too much time on their hands, and so they'll decide to assemble in Kurukshetra...if at the end of it, StarDrupad will have to take the blame for everything that happens.
Edited by shani88 - 11 years ago
Sabhayata thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
@Shani:Let me solve your query in all seriosuness
StarPanadavas and StarKauravas will get the blame for Drau's vastraharan but so will StarDrupad
Let me explain how.Now StarKunti without seeing said'Paancho aapas mein baant lo'now why did she say this because StarDrupad had asked for a harsh life for his daughter hence the universe conspired to make StarDrupad's request real and made kunti say that
In same way StarDrupad asked for humiliation for his daughter then again universe conspired to make that request true and twists yudi's mind and made him and pandavs and kauravas do what they did
SO basically everyhting that StarDrupad requested for StarDrauapdi had to come true
Edited by Sabhayata - 11 years ago
Justitia thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Sabhayata


StarPanadavas and StarKauravas will get the blame for Drau's vastraharan but so will StarDrupad


So now, the chakravyuh issue of Starbharat can also get resolved easily...I've got it all figured out.

As per Starbharat, Drupad knows about chakravyuh and Shikhandini knows about chakravyuh (& both are supposed to fight on the Pandava side). I know Bhishma is Dhrit's yes-man now, but Arjun's reasoning with Madhav (about Pitamah getting them their kingdom) might just work and might make Pitamah cross over to the Pandava side during Kurukshetra, and consequently, Shikhandi might cross over to Kaurava side since he/she needs to be the cause of Pitamah's death. And, as punishment for asking a harsh life for Draupadi, Krishna could ensure that the first fatality of Kurukshetra could be Drupad himself.

And in Starbharat's Kurukshetra, since Drupad gets killed very early on, Shikhandi would be on the Kaurava side, Arjun occupied elsewhere, and Mahadev's boon to Jayadratha working in his favour, the whole chakravyuh plot could work itself out...

I known all this sounds ridiculous. But since StarDrupad and StarShikhandini have prior knowledge about chakravyuh...
Edited by shani88 - 11 years ago
Ashwini_D thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: shani88


So now, the chakravyuh issue of Starbharat can also get resolved easily...I've got it all figured out.

As per Starbharat, Drupad knows about chakravyuh and Shikhandini knows about chakravyuh (& both are supposed to fight on the Pandava side). I know Bhishma is Dhrit's yes-man now, but Arjun's reasoning with Madhav (about Pitamah getting them their kingdom) might just work and might make Pitamah cross over to the Pandava side during Kurukshetra, and consequently, Shikhandi might cross over to Kaurava side since he/she needs to be the cause of Pitamah's death. And, as punishment for asking a harsh life for Draupadi, Krishna could ensure that the first fatality of Kurukshetra could be Drupad himself.

And in Starbharat's Kurukshetra, since Drupad gets killed very early on, Shikhandi would be on the Kaurava side, Arjun occupied elsewhere, and Mahadev's boon to Jayadratha working in his favour, the whole chakravyuh plot could work itself out...

I known all this sounds ridiculous. But since StarDrupad and StarShikhandini have prior knowledge about chakravyuh...


If only Starbharat were that particular about consistency and logic
Ashwini_D thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: shani88

Now I have figured out how the Pandavas will get the clean chit during the vastraharan. Thanks Sabhayata!😃
Then even Duri, Dushi, Karna, Shakuni can get the clean chit too in the vastraharan...

Post vastraharan convo between Yudi & Drau -
Drau to Yudi - Aap Dharamraj hai na?? Aap ne apni patni ko daav pe kaise lagaya?
Yudi to Drau - Tumhare pitashree ne tumahre liye jeevan bhar ka kasht kyu maanga??

Serious question - If ALL the blame for Drau's troubles ultimately falls on Drupad, then, what on earth will be the main purpose of the Kurukshetra war??? Looks like the Pandavas and Kauravas will have too much time on their hands, and so they'll decide to assemble in Kurukshetra...if at the end of it, StarDrupad will have to take the blame for everything that happens.


Yup all the blame for everybody's sins will fall on Drupad, except the blame due towards Kunti, which would fall on-what's-her-name-Sukhda? And the rest of the characters whenever accused of something will make an appeal to Suryanarayan to prove themselves innocent. 😛
Ashwini_D thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: shani88


Part in red - As per spoiler (and precap), Indra will try to konk off Arjun before Krishna (finally) intervenes, and convinces Indra to help Arjun instead. Takshak decides to leave in a huff. Indraprastha gets established. HP gets a whiff that Indraprastha has plans to declare sovereignty as per Kunti's instructions which she relays via Karna who has now become buddies with the Pandavas (Is conducting a nagar poojan the same as "declaring sovereignty"??). And, Shakuni proves his Hogwarts potioneering skills by using a "green liquid" to invoke Takshak who returns as a cow thief to create problems and stop the nagar poojan from taking place...baaki sab kuch CVs explain karenge.

Part in blue - I so wish he had said that!!



Wait is this the same cow thief that causes Arjun to walk in on Yudsithir and Draupadi and go into exile?

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".